American Depository Receipts: An Innovative Tool for Global Investing
Introduction
American Depository Receipts (ADRs) are financial instruments that enable investors to own overseas assets without actually acquiring them. Depositories in the US issue ADRs. These banks or depositories take actual possession of foreign securities and then issue receipts via their subsidiaries abroad or custodians. The receipts are agreements between the bank and the holder that a specific number of foreign shares has indeed been placed with the bank’s overseas branch or custodian and will be held on deposit for the duration of the ADRs.
ADRs are traded similarly to domestic securities since they are traded on national stock markets or the over-the-counter market. On-demand, ADRs can be converted into the underlying shares, and foreign stocks can be traded for ADRs. For its services, the depository bank charges a fee typically.
Types of ADR
Sponsored ADR
When international firm issues sponsored ADRs, it hires a bank to mediate between the corporation and the ADR holders. The ADRs, in this case, have been properly registered with the Securities and Market Commission (SEC) and are available for trading on a stock exchange. The foreign firm pays the banks’ fees.
Unsponsored ADR
Unsponsored ADRs are produced at the request of American brokerage companies, with no involvement from foreign corporations. They trade on the over-the-counter market and are not registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission. In this case, the investor pays the banks’ charges.
Issuance of Indian ADRs: Regulatory Framework
The Indian government allowed Indian enterprises to raise capital from foreign stock markets as Depository Receipts in result of the economic liberalisation programme in 1992. The DRs can be traded on any worldwide stock exchange and allowed to freely convert in denominated currency. Several multinational corporations seek this opportunity to their advantage and raised a huge amount of capital in the form of equity from foreign markets by issuing DRs on international markets. The subsequent selling of ADRs in international stock markets is not taxed in India as capital gains taxes. Arbitration involving the DRs is prohibited by law. Two options are essential if a foreign investor wants to invest in Indian shares. One option is to register as a foreign holding company (FH) and purchase and sell stocks in the Indian stock market; the other is to buy ADRs of Indian companies in foreign markets.
Literature Review
Whether to invest in the ADRs or not is a concern area for scholars, professionals, investors, and advisors, but the answer to this question is still not provided systematically. As in today’s time when the cross-border trade is increasing day by day, the cross-listing of assets also plays a remarkable role in this, which allows the investors to go global and also helps the investors from the emerging stock market like India to go to the developed stock exchange, i.e., U.S. stock market which is less volatile, more stable and securities also give an excellent return (Xuechun et al., 2020).
The study conducted by Saxena, (2006) supports the investment in Indian ADRs by giving the risk premia reward and trend for political and reasons for investment. The studies conducted by Amary & Ottoni (2005); Bhatnagar & Khan, (2015); Hansda & Ray, (2003); M.Punitham, (2015); Schaub & Simmons, (2020) also support the idea of investment in ADRs due to its high return and stability of developed stock markets. The global equity ADR report also stated returns as a key factor for attracting the investors to the ADRs investing (Harding Loevner, 2020).
However, on the other hand, the research conducted by several past researchers like Beckmann & Ngo, (2020), Dania & Verma, (2007); Foerster & Karolyi, (1999); Raj, (2012); Samant & Korth, (1999); Visalakshmi et al., (2016) showed a significant adverse risk associated with the investment in ADRs like political risk, integration of stock markets, price diffusion and, exchange rate risks. Tong et al., (2022) in their study examined the importance of dividend yields and stock repurchase ratio at the time of investing in the ADRs and also compared the performance of ADR firms to the non- ADR issuing firms.
It was observed that the previous studies gave confusing results and did not explain much about positive aspects of investment in ADRs in a detailed manner. While most of the research provides the negative aspects of the ADRs (Dollani, 2019; Grossmann & Ngo, 2020), there is a positive side to investing in ADRs. Thus, the study has been undertaken to ascertain the movement of ADRs concerning the market and the earning efficiency of their shares and to bridge the gap between positive aspects of ADRs in terms of returns and fundamentals of the companies. The present study undertakes the following objectives:
- To ascertain the efficiency of the shares of selected ADRs.
- To identify Indian ADRs as an innovative global investing tool.
- To examine the movements of selected Indian ADRs concerning the US market.
Data and Methodology
- Data Type and Source: The present study is based on secondary data. The ADRs listing information is collected from NASDAQ, NYSE, and investing.com. The financial data of companies taken from their respective annual reports, and the Prowess database has been used to extract the information. Relevant books have been consulted to build the conceptual framework, and research articles were also consulted to make the theoretical background for the study.
- Sample Selection: The study sample comprises level 2 and 3 ADRs of 7 major Indian companies listed on NYSE and NASDAQ. The companies have been selected based on their market capitalisation because they influence investors’ decisions. Thus these 7 companies are chosen based on their market capitalisation displayed in NYSE and NASDAQ exchanges retrieved on 26/01/2022.
- Sample Period: Data for Earning per share is collected for the financial year 2020-2021 because the investors decide based on the latest EPS. The ADR price data for the return calculation is taken from 2020 to 2021 for 1-year return and years ranging from 2018-2019 to 2020-2021 to analyse 3-year return.
- Data Analysis Tool: The data have been analysed using different financial tools like ratio and, percentage. Further, the statistical tools mean, variance and, covariance are also used. The daily closing price of the ADRs is used to calculate the return as it is assumed that the closing price is the sensation of the complete day. Earnings per share, price to earnings ratio and a beta of the ADRs are considered, which are factors that help the investors decide on investment.
- Methodology: In the present study, the beta value is calculated for the ADRs of each selected country to ascertain the movement of ADRs in terms of markets. EPS and P/E Ratio are calculated to check the stability of these ADR in a long time to help the investors in decision making.
Results and Discussion
The relevant data of selected companies have been analysed, keeping the study’s objective in mind. First of all, market capitalisation of the selected ADRs have been calculated to ascertain the company’s worth determined by the stock market.
Market capitalisation is a helpful statistic in choosing which companies you are interested in and diversifying your portfolio with firms of various sizes. Companies are classified based on their market capitalisation as:
- Large-cap Firms: $10 billion or more
- Mid-cap Firms: $2 billion to $10 billion
- Small-cap Firms: $300 million to $2 billion
Table 1. Major Indian ADRs with a market capitalisation (as on 26/01/2022)
| Name of ADRs | Market Capitalisation (in billion) |
|---|---|
| Infosys Ltd. | 96.25 |
| ICICI Bank Ltd. | 74.00 |
| Wipro Ltd. | 41.20 |
| HDFC Bank Ltd. | 108.45 |
| Tata Motors Ltd. | 12.33 |
| Reddy’s labs Ltd. | 9.72 (Mid-cap) |
| Vedanta Ltd | 51.59 |
Source: ADR prices (nasdaq.com)
Table 2. Major Indian ADRs with Revenue (as on 31/03/2021)
| Name of ADRs | Revenue (in billion) |
|---|---|
| Infosys Ltd. | 15.540 |
| ICICI Bank Ltd. | 10.040 |
| Wipro Ltd. | 10.010 |
| HDFC Bank Ltd. | 10.450 |
| Reddy’s labs Ltd. | 2.730 |
| Vedanta Ltd | 5.370 |
Source: Annual report of companies (2021)
Table 1 shows the mid-cap and large-cap firms based on their market capitalisation. Among the mentioned firms, all except one are large-cap where the value of market capitalisation lies between 9.72 to 108.45 billion. Table 2 lists the companies based on their revenues, 15.540 billion being the highest and 2.730 billion being the lowest.
Valuation Efficiency: EPS and P/E Ratio Analysis
For checking the efficiency of the ADRs for these companies, the EPS and P/E ratio is calculated:
EPS and P/E ratios are the two most essential tools for a stock’s valuation and help investors in deciding the valuation of stocks in terms of overvalued and undervalued. Earnings per share is an important metric to look at when assessing a company’s financial performance on an absolute scale. It is also a big aspect of figuring out the price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio. A stock’s worth may be computed by dividing its stock price by its profits per share to see how much the market is willing to pay for each dollar of earnings. Because it reflects how much money a company makes for each share of its stock, EPS is an often-used measure for determining corporate value. If investors feel a company’s profits are greater than its share price, they will pay more for its stock; hence, a higher EPS indicates better value. Table 3 shows that the highest EPS is 3.9 followed by 2.38 indicating that these companies are attractive to investors and show these firms’ better value.
A higher Price-to-earnings ratio indicates that a company’s stock is overvalued or that investors anticipate higher future growth rates. A low P/E ratio might suggest that its present stock price is undervalued compared to earnings. The highest P/E ratio belongs to the health care sector which when compared to other companies’ ADRs, shows that the investor’s expectations are higher from this company. Covid-19 can also be one of the reasons for the higher P/E ratio for this company. Despite of the highest EPS, the automobile sector has the lowest P/E ratio which shows the lower expectation of investors to the future growth of ADRs in this segment.
Table 3. Major Indian ADRs earning per share (as on 26/01/2022)
| Name of ADRs | EPS | P/E Ratio |
|---|---|---|
| Infosys Ltd. | 0.68 | 32.12 |
| ICICI Bank Ltd. | 0.81 | 24.81 |
| Wipro Ltd. | 0.30 | 24.05 |
| HDFC Bank Ltd. | 2.38 | 27.39 |
| Tata Motors | 3.90 | 8.43 |
| Reddy’s Labs Ltd. | 1.57 | 35.42 |
| Vedanta Ltd | 1.63 | 10.13 |
Source: Prowess Database (retrieved on 26/01/2022)
Return Analysis: 1-Year and 3-Year Horizons
The next objective focus is on ADRs as an innovative investment tool. The last year’s return and the return for the past three years are being calculated. Returns for all the companies have been positive in the past three years, showing excellent returns, which show why the ADRs are one of the most innovative tools for global investment.
Table 4. Major Indian ADRs returns (on 31/12/2021)
| Name of ADRs | 1 Year Return | 3 Year Return |
|---|---|---|
| Infosys Ltd. | 28.52% | 117.44% |
| ICICI Bank Ltd. | 41.83% | 111.96% |
| Wipro Ltd. | 17.59% | 86.31% |
| HDFC Bank Ltd. | -7.34% | 36.34% |
| Tata Motors | 70.79% | 154.73% |
| Reddy’s labs Ltd. | 14.01% | 57.36% |
| Vedanta Ltd | 83.54% | 49.05% |
Source: ADR prices (nasdaq.com)
Market Movements & Beta Evaluation
To explore the movement between Indian ADRs regarding the U.S. market, we have calculated the beta value for each ADR. Here, the beta is calculated as:
Covariance measures how the stock moves together, while variance measures the relative movement of the stock from its mean. The stock whose movement is more than the market has a greater beta of more than 1, while stocks that move less than the market have less than 1. High beta stocks are riskier and provide better and higher returns while stock with low beta poses less risk and gives a lower return. That is why the beta is an essential measure while examining the risk-return ratio because it helps investors to determine the balance. Table 5. shows the beta value of ADRs in terms of the U.S. market. Tata Motors has the highest beta value, i.e., 1.9, which shows that Tata Motors poses a higher return in terms of the market. It is observed with the return table, followed by Vedanta Ltd. and ICICI Bank, whose Beta value is also greater than 1 representing higher volatility and better return compared to the market. Reddy’s Lab has the lowest beta among all i.e., 0.56 showing that the stock is less volatile concerning the market and possesses a lower return.
Table 5. Beta Value of ADRs (as on 26/01/2022)
| Name of ADRs | Beta |
|---|---|
| Infosys Ltd. | 0.95 |
| ICICI Bank Ltd. | 1.06 |
| Wipro Ltd. | 0.84 |
| HDFC Bank Ltd. | 0.73 |
| Tata Motors | 1.90 |
| Reddy’s labs Ltd. | 0.56 |
| Vedanta Ltd | 1.80 |
Source: Prowess Database (retrieved on 26/01/2022)
Conclusion
The present study finds the ADRs to be an innovative instrument for global investing. The returns of the ADRs are significantly positive and gave an excellent return in the past one year and the past three years despite the stock market shock due to Covid-19. In the past three years, Tata Motors, Infosys, and ICICI Bank ADRs had given exceptional returns, making it a lucrative asset in global investing. The movement of ADRs concerning the US market is also an essential criterion for knowing the volatility. Beta value helps the investors to make an alignment between the risk and reward. ADRs having more than one beta, are risky and gives investors a chance for higher returns than the market.
In contrast, ADRs having a less beta are less volatile and gives safer and likely low returns. While diversifying the portfolio, investors also decide whether to invest in Large-Cap, Mid-Cap, or Small-Cap companies. Apart from Reddy’s Labs Ltd., a mid-cap firm based on its market capitalisation, all other companies are large-cap. EPS and P/E ratios are essential criteria for the company’s stock valuation and profitability measurement and help the investors decide whether to invest in a particular company. It is found in the study that Tata Motors and HDFC Bank have the highest EPS, i.e., 3.9 and 2.38, respectively, showing that these companies are attractive to investors and shows the better value of these firms. Reddy’s Lab has the highest P/E ratio compared to other companies’ ADRs, indicating that the investor’s expectations are very much higher from this company. Covid-19 can also be one of the reasons for the higher P/E ratio for this company, followed by Infosys, ICICI Bank, Wipro and HDFC Bank. Tata Motors has the lowest P/E ratio despite the highest EPS, showing the lower expectation of investors to the future growth of ADRs as the company deals with Automobile’s segment.
Thus, it can be concluded with the analysis and above discussion that the ADRs are a safe and innovative investment avenue for the investors for global investing. As in the study, the included variables are Market Capitalisation, Revenue, EPS, P/E ratio, and Beta value, which are important criteria for deciding while investing in a particular asset. But some limitations of the present study, without which the discussion is incomplete, must also be reported. There are many factors apart from the companies’ financials and market fluctuations responsible for volatility in ADRs, i.e., exchange rate fluctuations, political risk, and underlying stock prices movements. Thus, addressing these issues will help to further improve the results.
References
- ADR Prices 2022. National Association of Securities Dealers Automated Quotations, Retrieved on 26/01/2022, from https://www.nasdaq.com/.
- Amary, B., & Ottoni, O. (2005). ADR Arbitrage Opportunities for Dummies. BEATRIZ AMARY OTAVIO OTTONI ADREATRIZ AMARY OTAVIO OTTONI, 29.
- Beckmann, K. S., & Ngo, T. (2020). ADR and Domestic Equity Offer Performance of Identical Firms. Journal of Accounting and Finance, 20(3).
- Bhatnagar, V. K., & Khan, J. (2015). Effect of Foreign Exchange Rate on ADR Returns: An Indian Evidence. Pacific Business Review International, 7(9), 59–64.
- Foerster, S. R., & Karolyi, G. A. (1999). The effects of market segmentation and investor recognition on asset prices: Evidence from foreign stocks listing in the United States. Journal of Finance, 54(3), 981–1013. https://doi.org/10.1111/0022-1082.00134.
- Grossmann, A., & Ngo, T. (2020). Economic policy uncertainty and ADR mispricing. Journal of Multinational Financial Management, 55, 100627. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mulfin.2020.100627.
- M.Punitham. (2015). A Study on Cross Co Integration of Indian ADRs Between BSE & NYSE. Review of Research, 4(11–5), 2015. http://ror.isrj.org/UploadedData/1797.pdf.
- Saxena, S. (2006). PREMIA IN THE INDIAN ADR MARKET: An Analysis of Trends and Causes. Glucksman Institute for Research in Securities Markets.
- Visalakshmi, S., Lakshmi, P., Shanmugam, K., & Prasad, K. K. (2016). A cointegration analysis of price diffusion amid ADRs and dually listed Indian stocks. International Journal of Business Innovation and Research, 11(3), 345–362. https://doi.org/10.1504/IJBIR.2016.078871.
- Xuechun, Z., Ruihui, X., & Xue, L. (2020). AH and A-ADR Premiums (2020/9; The People’s Bank of China Working Paper Series).