Analysis of Recent Requirement to File Form MSME-I By Specified Companies under Companies Act — An Initiative of Govt to Support the Growth of MSME
With a view to assess the overall financial health of MSME sector and the promptness of payments to MSME suppliers, the Ministry of Corporate Affairs had directed specified companies under Section 405 of the Companies Act, 2013 to file Form MSME-I. This requirement is applicable only to “Specified Companies” as defined under MCA notification for Companies which get supplies of goods and services from Micro and Small enterprises and whose payments exceed 45 days from the date of acceptance or the date of deemed acceptance of the goods or services as per provisions of Section 9 of the Micro Small and Medium enterprises Development Act, 2006 (MSMED Act) This article provides an overview and related interpretations of the concept from professional perspective.
Legislative Background/Requirement
The Ministry of Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSME) had vide notification dated 2nd November 2018 directed all companies
- who get supplies of goods and services from micro and small enterprises and,
- whose payments to micro and small enterprise suppliers exceed 45 days from the date of acceptance or deemed acceptance
to file a half yearly return with the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (“MCA”) stating the amounts due and the reasons for delay.
Subsequently, the MCA had vide notification dated 22nd January 2019 (hereinafter referred to as “MCA Notification”) directed all specified companies to file form MSME-I (hereinafter referred to as “the Form”). The aforesaid requirement is applicable only to “Specified Companies” as defined under MCA notification: –
- Companies which get supplies of goods and services from Micro and Small enterprises and
- Whose payments exceed 45 days from the date of acceptance or the date of deemed acceptance of the goods or services as per provisions of Section 9 of the Micro Small and Medium enterprises Development Act, 2006 (MSMED Act)
The MCA notification requires the following:–
- One time return within 30 days of notification to be filed by Specified Companies.
- Half yearly return by the end of the month succeeding the end of half year. The half year for this purpose shall be April to September and October to March and the due dates shall accordingly be 31st October and 30th April respectively.
Analysis
A. It may be pertinent to note that only the details of outstanding dues to Micro and Small enterprises (MS Suppliers) are required to be filed and not details of outstanding dues to medium enterprises.
It may be pertinent to note that only the details of outstanding dues to Micro and Small enterprises (MS Suppliers) are required to be filed and not details of outstanding dues to medium enterprises. It may further be noted that the wordings of the MCA notification indicate that once a Company falls under the category of a Specified Company as per this notification, the details of all outstanding dues are required to be disclosed in the Form.
B. It may further be noted that the wordings of the MCA notification indicate that once a Company falls under the category of a Specified Company as per this notification, the details of all outstanding dues are required to be disclosed in the Form. For instance, if the Company has outstanding dues to 10 MS suppliers and the dues to one supplier is outstanding for more than 45 days and the dues to balance nine suppliers is outstanding for less than 45 days, then the details of outstanding dues to all the 10 MS suppliers would have to be filed. However, if the dues to all 10 suppliers are outstanding for less than 45 days, then the Company would not be classified as a “specified company” for the purposes of this notification and hence the Form would not have to be filed.
C. The relevant dates for assessment of outstanding amount shall be 22 January 2019 (one-time) and 30th September and 31st March of each half year respectively. In other words, if any dues to MS supplier is outstanding for beyond 45 days as on relevant date (say 30th September) and even if the payment has been made (say by 15th October) before the due date of filing the form (say 31st October), the details of outstanding dues would still have to be filed in the Form.
D. Further the assessment of applicability shall be done as at each half year end. Accordingly there could be scenarios, where the Company might be a “specified company” as at a particular half year end and will end up filing the Form whereas it may not be a “specified company” as at subsequent half year end and hence would not be required to file the Form.
E. Further, Section 9 of the MSMED Act quoted in the MCA notification appears to be incorrect since Section 9 provides general powers to the Central government to take measures for promotion and development of MSME Sector and does not define the date of acceptance or deemed acceptance.
F. It would also be relevant to analyse certain provisions of MSMED Act in this regard:–
-
Day of acceptance has been defined under Section 2 of the MSMED Act to be the –
- date of actual delivery of goods or rendering of services,
- where any objection is made in writing by the buyer regarding acceptance of goods or services within 15 days from the day of the delivery of goods or the rendering of services, the day on which such objection is removed by the supplier.
- Day of deemed acceptance has also been defined under Section 2 of MSMED Act to mean the day of actual delivery of goods or services if no objection is made in writing by the buyer regarding the acceptance of goods or services within 15 days of delivery of goods or services.
- Appointed day has been defined as the day immediately after the expiry of 15 days from the date of acceptance or date of deemed acceptance.
- As per Section 15 of MSMED Act, if the payment terms are not agreed in writing, the appointed day shall be the due date for payment.
- Even if the payment terms are agreed in writing, it shall not exceed 45 days from the date of acceptance or deemed acceptance. In other words, the payment terms for the purpose of computation of interest under Section 16 of the MSMED Act shall be based on the agreed days or 45 days whichever is lower.
Let us understand the aforesaid by means of an illustration
| Particulars | Scenario 1 | Scenario 2 | Scenario 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Company | X Ltd | Y Ltd | Z Ltd |
| Date of PO/Agreement | 30-Nov-18 | 30-Nov-18 | 30-Nov-18 |
| Date of delivery | 05-Dec-18 | 05-Dec-18 | 10-Dec-18 |
| Agreed credit period after removal of objection, if any | 30 days | 75 days | Not agreed |
| Date of objection raised in writing | 10-Dec-18 | 30-Dec-18 | No objection raised |
| Date of removal of objection (deficiency) by supplier based on buyers’ communication | 20-Dec-18 | 10-Jan-19 | Not applicable |
| Date of acceptance/Deemed Acceptance | 20-Dec-18 | 05-Dec-18 | 10-Dec-18 |
| Appointed day | 04-Jan-19 | 20-Dec-18 | 25-Dec-18 |
| Payment due date as per agreement | 19-Jan-19 | 26-Mar-19 | Not applicable |
| Payment due date as per Section 15 of MSMED Act | 19-Jan-19 | 19-Jan-19 | 25-Dec-18 |
| Actual Payment date | 28-Jan-19 | 28-Jan-19 | 28-Jan-19 |
| Whether requirement to pay interest under Section 16 of MSMED Act | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Whether outstanding as at 22 Jan 2019 | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Whether 45 days elapsed as on 22 Jan 2019 (being date of notification) from the date of acceptance or deemed acceptance | No | Yes | No |
| Whether Company is a specified Company | No | Yes | No |
| Whether requirement to file Form MSME-1 will apply | No | Yes | No |
| Remarks | Note (i) | Note (ii) | Note (iii) |
Notes:
In other words, this could also result in a scenario, where a Company may be required to pay interest under Section 16 of the MSME Act (if the agreed credit period is below 45 days) but may not be required to disclose the same in Form MSME-1 (assuming the payment has been made within 45 days but beyond the agreed credit period).
b) Though the payment due date as per the agreement is 26th March 2019 (75 days from 10th Jan 2019), since the same exceeds the maximum cap of 45 days under Section 15 of MSMED Act, the trigger for payment of interest will arise along with requirement to disclose in Form MSME-1.
The aforesaid tabular analysis has been done in a simple scenario where the company deals only with a single MS supplier. The aforesaid assessment will have to be done for each and every MS supplier individually.
G. Further, the assessment would have to be done for each supplier individually. For instance, if there is due to MS supplier for ₹ 10,000 against a particular invoice which is outstanding for beyond 45 days and there is an advance of ₹ 15,000 paid to the same supplier for another supply against which the goods have still not been received, the Company would still fall under the definition of Specified Company and would be required to file the Form.
H. There are scenarios in which a portion of the amount payable is generally withheld as retention money in accordance with the contract, without any specific objection as regards the quality of goods or services, which is released after the satisfactory performance of the goods or services up to a period specified in the contract (say 6 months or one year etc.). The literal interpretation of the MSMED Act and the notification appears to include even such amounts for the purpose of computation of interest as well as disclose the same in the Form though they may strictly not be due as per the contract.
I. Additionally, the MSMED Amendment Bill 2018 proposes to change the criteria of classification of MSME enterprises as given below:–
| Types of Enterprises | Existing MSME 2006 Act | Proposed MSME Amendment Bill 2018 (Turnover limits) |
|
|---|---|---|---|
| Manufacturing Sector (Investment in Plant and Machinery) |
Services Sector (Investment in Equipment) |
||
| Micro | ≤ 25 Lakh | ≤ 10 Lakh | ≤ 5 Crore |
| Small | 25 Lakh < Investment ≤ 5 Crore | 10 Lakh < Investment ≤ 2 Crore | 5 Crore < Turnover ≤ 75 Crore |
| Medium | 5 Crore < Investment ≤ 10 Crore | 2 Crore < Investment ≤ 5 Crore | 75 Crore < Turnover ≤ 250 Crore |
Consequences of Non-Compliance with the Aforesaid Provisions
The order to file Form MSME-1 has been given under section 405 of the Companies Act which empowers the central government to direct companies to furnish information or statistics.
Further the said section prescribes that “If any company fails to comply with an order made, or knowingly furnishes any information or statistics which is incorrect or incomplete in any material respect, the company shall be punishable with fine which may extend to twenty-five thousand rupees and every officer of the company who is in default, shall be punishable with imprisonment for a term which may extend to six months or with fine which shall not be less than twenty-five thousand rupees but which may extend to three lakh rupees, or with both”.
Section 405 of the Companies Act prescribes that “If any company fails to comply with an order made, or knowingly furnishes any information or statistics which is incorrect or incomplete in any material respect, the company shall be punishable with fine which may extend to twenty-five thousand rupees and every officer of the company who is in default, shall be punishable with imprisonment for a term which may extend to six months or with fine which shall not be less than twenty-five thousand rupees but which may extend to three lakh rupees, or with both”
Concluding Remarks
Form MSME-1 is an addition to the already existing plethora of forms and compliances required under the Companies Act, 2013 increasing the burden of compliance and reducing the ease of doing business.
Further, there appears to be a slight conflict between the empowering notification issued by MSME Ministry and the implementing notification issued by MCA. While the former required only amounts due for more than 45 days and the reasons for the delay, the latter defines the same as applicability condition and requires details of all outstanding dues to be filed upon the notification being applicable. Moreover, since the e-Form has not yet been uploaded on the website of MCA, there are possibilities of the due date for one-time compliance being extended from “30 days from the date of notification” to “30 days from the date of deployment of the form in the MCA website” as was done in the case of Form NFRA-1.
It is recommended that the Government explicitly clarifies open/ambiguous issues such as applicability of the aforesaid to outstanding dues to medium enterprises, whether all dues or only dues for greater than 45 days are required to be disclosed, the position under MSMED Act w.r.t retention money etc. It is also recommended that the MCA synchronises the due date as the due date under section 15 of MSMED Act rather than having a separate threshold of 45 days for the limited purpose of the Form. It is also recommended that the one-time compliance for status as on 22nd January 2019 is completely done away with and only the half-yearly compliance is retained considering the fact that Companies generally do not have processes and systems to support for information required in a regulatory filing for an odd date or period and are better equipped for furnishing information as at particular month-end.
“We come nearest to the great when we are great in humility.”