Audit Expectation Gap
The recent corporate frauds in India have once again brought the limelight on the audit profession. This time around, however, in so far as the auditors are concerned, there is a dangerous trend from the regulators, media, and the public asking “Where were the auditors?” and accusing the auditors of being hand in glove with the perpetrators of such wrongdoings. A shift from being accused of professional negligence to nothing less than criminal conspiracy.
It is evident that the Expectation Gap, i.e., the mismatch between the roles and responsibilities of the auditors vis-à-vis what the regulators and the society, at large, understand or expect from them, has anything but abated. In fact, it seems more tectonic now. This Article dwells on the Expectation Gap in the context of audit of the financial statements of a company. However, the context may also be extended to audits of other entities as well. Read on to know more…
As a prerequisite to discussing the “Expectation Gap, one needs to understand as to what is an audit of financial statements, its objectives, nature and scope, as also the respective roles and responsibilities of the management, the directors and those charged with governance vis a vis those of the auditors appointed under the Companies Act, 2013 (“the Act”) and the Standards on Auditing (SAs), issued by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) and specified under section 143(10) of the Act.
Audit of Financial Statements– Objective, Nature and Scope
Requirements of Standards on Auditing (SAs)
Paragraph 3 of SA 200, “Overall Objectives of the Independent Auditor and the Conduct of an audit in accordance with Standards on Auditing” provides that “the purpose of an audit is to enhance the degree of confidence of intended users in the financial statements. This is achieved by the expression of an opinion by the auditor on whether the financial statements are prepared, in all material respects in accordance with the applicable financial reporting framework. In the case of most general purpose frameworks, that opinion is on whether the financial statements are presented fairly in all material respects, or give a true and fair view in accordance with the framework.”
Paragraph 4 of the SA 200 provides that “the financial statements that are subject to audit are those of the entity prepared and presented by management of the entity with oversight from those charged with governance. However, an audit, in accordance with SAs is conducted on the premise that management and, where appropriate those charged with governance have responsibilities that are fundamental to the conduct of the audit.” These responsibilities include their responsibility for preparation and presentation of financial statements that comply with the applicable financial reporting framework; and design, implementation and maintenance of internal controls over preparation and presentation of financial statements to ensure that they are free from any material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error. This also constitutes the basic premise on which an audit is conducted.
Further, the objective of an auditor in an audit of financial statements is to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the financial statements as a whole are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error, thereby enabling the auditor to express an opinion on those financial statements. (Paragraph 11 of SA 200)
The SAs further provide that in carrying out an audit, the auditor undertakes procedures to provide a basis for identification and assessment of risks of material misstatements in the financial statements. Once the risks are so identified and assessed, the auditor obtains sufficient appropriate audit evidence therefor by designing and implementing appropriate responses thereto, including substantive procedures as well as test of control.
Requirements of the Act
Section 143(2) of the Act contains the responsibilities of the auditors in respect of reporting on the true and fair view of the state of the company’s affairs as at the end of its financial year and profit or loss and cash flow for the year and such other matters as are prescribed.
Further, in terms of Section 143(9) of the Act read with the proviso thereto, the auditors are, presently, required to comply with and carry out an audit of the financial statements in accordance with the SAs issued by ICAI.
Also, Section 134(5) of the Act casts responsibility on the Directors of the company, inter alia, with respect to the preparation of the annual accounts in accordance with the applicable accounting standards, taking proper care in the maintenance of adequate accounting records in accordance with the provisions of the Act for safeguarding the assets of the company and for preventing and detecting frauds and other irregularities.
Domain of Auditor’s Report and Auditor’s Responsibilities
Flowing from the above, following important aspects about the auditor’s responsibilities may be noted:
(i) The auditor provides an opinion on the financial statements
The term opinion is not defined either in the Act, 2013 or in the SAs. The Oxford Advanced Learners’ Dictionary, however, defines the term “Opinion” as “belief or judgement not founded on complete knowledge.” The Black’s Law Dictionary defines the term “opinion” as:
“In the law of evidence, Opinion is an inference or conclusion drawn by a witness from facts some of which are known to him and others assumed, or drawn from facts which, though lending probability to the inference, do not evolve it by a process of absolutely necessary reasoning…..”1
(ii) The audit procedures carried out in terms of SAs are designed to enable the auditor to provide only reasonable assurance
The term “Reasonable Assurance”, in the context of assurance engagements, including audit engagements, and quality control, means a high, but not absolute level of assurance2. This entails the use of judgements and estimates, existence of the inherent limitations of any internal control system, the use of test check and the fact that the audit evidence is persuasive and not conclusive in nature and, hence, the fact that audit risk can never be brought to zero. This is a nationally as well as internationally accepted position. In fact, while “reasonable assurance” is the highest level of assurance that can be provided, in India, however, in an alarming number of instances, audit is wrongly perceived to provide an absolute assurance by the various stakeholders.
(iii) True and Fair View vs. True and Correct
The auditor’s opinion mentions that the accounts of the company provide a true and fair view of the state of affairs of the company as at the balance sheet date and the profit and loss and cash flows for the period ended on that date. The concept of true and fair was inserted by the Companies Act, 1956 in place of true and correct, as required under the Companies Act, 1913. There was a view that “True and Correct” implied an assertion by the auditor that the financial statements represented an actual state of affairs, truly and correctly. However, since neither the 1956 Act nor the 2013 Act provides a definition of true and fair view, it may be inferred that the financial statements should not only be made out correctly but should also convey the information in the manner required. Hence, the Accounting Standards, including the presentation and disclosure requirements therein, and also the specific additional financial reporting requirements under the Act and other laws are minimum benchmarks that support “fairness” aspect of the financial statements. These factors, along with other qualitative aspects of the financial statements become important considerations for “true and fair view”.
(iv) Management’s Responsibilities
The responsibility for the preparation and presentation of the financial statements, including the design of the internal control relevant to the preparation and presentation of the financial statements rests with the management, under the supervision of those charged with governance. The auditor is neither responsible nor does he prepare the financial statements to be audited. In fact, the Code of Ethics issued by ICAI prohibits the auditor to undertake/be involved in the preparation and presentation of the financial statements that would be subjected by him/her to audit, since it would give rise to a self-review threat.
Thus, an auditor examines the financial statements, which are prepared by the management, in accordance with the audit procedures prescribed by the SAs and provides his/her professional opinion. An audit, however, is not a guarantee as to the efficiency and effectiveness with which the management of the entity has managed the affairs of the entity. It is also not a guarantee as to the future viability of the company or that the financial statements are free from fraud/error. An opinion may be correct or incorrect but, at the end of the day, it is an opinion only.
Auditor’s Responsibility relating to Detection of Frauds in Financial Statements
SA 240, The Auditor’s Responsibilities Relating to Fraud in an Audit of Financial Statements, paragraph 5 recognises that “owing to the inherent limitations of an audit, there is an unavoidable risk that some material misstatements of the financial statements may not be detected, even though the audit is properly planned and performed in accordance with the SAs”. These inherent limitations of an audit arise from nature of financial reporting, nature of audit procedures and the need for the audit to be conducted within a reasonable time and cost and result in much of the audit evidence being persuasive rather than conclusive in nature.
Further, paragraph 6 of SA 240 mentions that “…the potential effects of inherent limitations are particularly significant in the case of misstatement resulting from fraud. The risk of not detecting a material misstatement resulting from fraud is higher than the risk of not detecting one resulting from error. This is because fraud may involve sophisticated and carefully organised schemes designed to conceal it, such as forgery, deliberate failure to record transactions, or intentional misrepresentations being made to the auditor.”
Further, paragraph 7 of SA 240 mentions that “Furthermore, the risk of the auditor not detecting a material misstatement resulting from management fraud is greater than for employee fraud, because management is frequently in a position to directly or indirectly manipulate accounting records, present fraudulent financial information or override control procedures designed to prevent similar frauds by other employees”
Thus, the SAs while providing guidance to the auditor in carrying out the audit also recognize that it is not the primary duty of the auditor to identify/detect frauds and the reasons why it is difficult to detect frauds.
Role of Professional Skepticism
The auditor, however, is required to plan and perform an audit with professional scepticism, recognising that circumstances may exist that may cause the financial statements to be materially misstated. Professional skepticism has been defined in SA 200 as “an attitude that includes a questioning mind, being alert to conditions which may indicate possible misstatement due to error or fraud, and a critical assessment of audit evidence.” The auditor is also required to exercise professional judgment in all aspects of audit, be it planning, risk assessment, designing and performing risk response procedures, etc.
“Professional skepticism has been defined in SA 200 as ‘an attitude that includes a questioning mind, being alert to conditions which may indicate possible misstatement due to error or fraud, and a critical assessment of audit evidence.’”
It may be relevant to also focus on the responsibility of the management and those charged with governance with regard to design of internal control system and prevention and detection of frauds. In this regard reference may be drawn to paragraph 4 of SA 240:
“The primary responsibility for the prevention and detection of fraud rests with both those charged with governance of the entity and management. It is important that management, with the oversight of those charged with governance, place a strong emphasis on fraud prevention, which may reduce opportunities for fraud to take place, and fraud deterrence, which could persuade individuals not to commit fraud because of the likelihood of detection and punishment.”
This, in essence, means that in the ordinary course of audit, though the auditor is required to maintain an attitude of professional skepticism, however, he is not required to treat the audit engagement as an investigation. An audit engagement has a specified purpose as defined in the Act and articulated well in the SAs. An Investigation on the other hand is a detailed exercise with the objective of obtaining conclusive evidence as opposed to persuasive evidence in the case of audit. It also requires skill sets different from a normal audit. The focus area could also be different and the time and the cost would also different from an audit.
Section 143(12) of the Act which casts a responsibility on the auditors to report to the Central Government on frauds also envisages such reporting only “in the course of the performance of his duties as an auditor”. The phrase “in the course of his duties as an auditor” is construed as the duties that an auditor performs in accordance with the SAs.
It can be concluded that, as per the present scope of audit, an auditor is not required to carry out an investigation. However, one needs to recognise that in case the auditor has been negligent in the carrying out his duties as an auditor, which has resulted in material misstatement/s, whether due to fraud or error, remaining undetected in the financial statements, then he cannot escape liability for professional negligence. But in no case, should he be faulted for not detecting a fraud/error or being complicit in fraud merely on the ground that he has carried out the audit.
Judicial Doctrines and Landmark Case Laws
1. Kingston Cotton Mill Company (1896) – Watchdog vs. Bloodhound
At this juncture, it would be relevant to mention the landmark British Common Law case of Kingston Cotton Mill Company, 1896 that had repercussions for external auditors throughout the English-speaking world. In a rather quaint language of the day, the case’s judicial description of external auditors as “watchdogs” rather than “bloodhounds” established the principle that auditors’ duties involve the exercising of reasonable professional care:
“What is reasonable skill, care and caution must depend on the particular circumstances of each case. An auditor is not bound to be a detective.”
The legal framework of external auditing has changed significantly since the Kingston Cotton Mill case, but its judicial reasoning can be interpreted as an early articulation of the existence of the expectations gap.
2. Tri-Sure India Ltd. – Justice M. L. Pendse
A similar sentiment was also echoed by Justice M L Pendse in the Tri-Sure India Ltd.’s case too. In his judgment, the Honourable judge had observed that:
“The auditor is required to employ reasonable skill and care, but he is not required to begin with suspicion and to proceed in the manner of trying to detect a fraud or a lie, unless some information has reached which extends suspicion or ought to excite suspicion in a professional man of reasonable competence………… he is not required to perform the functions of a detective.”
3. Securities Appellate Tribunal (SAT) Ruling in Price Waterhouse Coopers (PWC)
The recent Securities Appellate Tribunal’s (SAT) Judgement in the case of Price Waterhouse Coopers (PWC) can be considered another landmark judgment on the role and responsibilities of the auditors (extract below):
“..The user, however, should not assume that the auditor’s opinion is an assurance as to the future viability of the enterprise or the efficiency or effectiveness with which management has conducted the affairs of the enterprise. The auditor’s work involves exercise of judgement, for example, in deciding the extent of audit procedures and in assessing the reasonableness of the judgements and estimates made by management in preparing the financial statements. Furthermore, much of the evidence available to the auditor can enable him to draw only reasonable conclusions therefrom. Because of these factors, absolute certainty in auditing is rarely attainable. In forming his opinion on the financial statements, the auditor follows procedures designed to satisfy himself that the financial statements reflect a true and fair view of the financial position and operating results of the enterprise. The auditor recognizes that because of the test nature and other inherent limitations of an audit, together with the inherent limitations of any system of internal control, there is an unavoidable risk that some material misstatement may remain undiscovered. While in many situations the discovery of a material misstatement by management may often arise during the conduct of the audit, such discovery is not the main objective of audit nor is the auditor’s programme of work specifically designed for such discovery. The audit cannot, therefore, be relied upon to ensure the discovery of all frauds or errors but where the auditor has any indication that some fraud or error may have occurred which could result in material misstatement, the auditor should extend his procedures to confirm or dispel his suspicion.
The auditor’s opinion on the financial statements is based on the concept of obtaining reasonable assurance; hence, in an audit, the auditor does not guarantee that material misstatements, whether from fraud or error, will be detected. Therefore, the subsequent discovery of a material misstatement of the financial statements resulting from fraud or error does not, in itself, indicate:
- (a) failure to obtain reasonable assurance,
- (b) inadequate planning, performance or judgement,
- (c) absence of professional competence and due care, or,
- (d) failure to comply with auditing standards generally accepted in India.
This is particularly the case for certain kinds of intentional misstatements, since auditing procedures may be ineffective for detecting an intentional misstatement that is concealed through collusion between or amongst one or more individuals in the management. Whether the auditor has performed an audit or not in accordance with auditing standards generally accepted in India is determined by the adequacy of the audit procedures performed in the circumstances and the suitability of the auditor’s report based on the result of these procedures. However, unless the audit reveals evidence to the contrary, the auditor is entitled to accept records and documents as genuine. Accordingly, an audit performed in accordance with auditing standards generally accepted in India rarely contemplate authentication of documentation, nor are auditors trained as, or expected to be, experts in such authentication.”
The Way Forward
The recent SAT order has amply clarified the role and responsibility of the auditor within the context of the SAs and the Act and distinguishes between a case of professional negligence vis-à-vis a criminal conspiracy related to fraud.
In discussions with Regulators earlier, at least some of them have acknowledged that while the auditors are not expected to detect frauds, however, they should not remain silent in case they suspect something. Especially so, where they have been associated with companies for a longer period of time. The real test lies in drawing that fine distinction.
However, it now seems that the expectation of the Regulators and the other stakeholders from the auditors is not only that there is adequate compliance of what is already provided in the SAs and the Act, but something beyond that. The ICAI needs to engage in a broad-based dialogue and debate with the Regulators, the Government, and other stakeholders, including the auditors themselves, on understanding the changing expectations and how best these can be addressed in an attempt to bridge the expectation gap. The dialogue/debate should also explore how best to guide and equip the profession and the auditors and whether using emerging tools of data analytics and artificial intelligence in audit could provide a solution or whether there is a requirement to reskill and reorient auditors more towards fraud identification / detection. The engagement cost and timelines for completion of the audit exercise in such situation would also be an important issue as also the fact that the nature of the engagement would then shift towards more investigation oriented one. Another option which could be explored is to supplement the existing audit engagements with forensic engagements in select cases based on certain pre-defined criteria. More solutions may also emerge during the course of such discussions. However, in none of the dialogues and debates sight should lose the fact that “absolute assurance” is just not achievable, even perhaps hypothetically, and that “reasonable assurance” would be the highest that the Profession would be able to provide in any circumstances.
The role of the management and those charged with governance in the preparation of financial statements and preventing detection of frauds needs to be reiterated. There needs to be a creation of an environment where there is a better trust by the Regulators and the society in the auditors and a system whereby early warning signals can be provided to the auditors in case of suspected frauds. The Government and the Regulators also need to appreciate whether in a situation where large scale frauds have occurred, there is a case of auditor negligence or culpability. Necessary disciplinary action is definitely warranted within the existing disciplinary framework in both the cases. However, putting the preparers of financial statements and auditors on the same footing and in turn, banning the entire audit Firm may not be a real solution. For example, one does not hear of an entire hospital being shut down on account of the negligence of one or two doctors.
Last but not least, while all the debate and dialogue will take its own time to reach fruition, the auditors should continue to exercise professional skepticism and be alert to how and when frauds could occur.