Audit of Foreign Exchange Business
During Bank Branch Audits, various areas are verified having more focus on loans and advances. Some branches also cater to customers who are carrying out international trade transactions. These branches provide services like Inward / Outward Remittances, Letter of Credit, Bank Guarantee, Negotiation of Export / Import Bills. This business of the Branch is categorised as International Trade Finance. Trade Finance is the method by which the Banks finance commercial businesses through the issuance of a short-term loan facility which is backed by the underlying trade documents. In this background, this article focuses on various aspects of audit of foreign exchange business. Read on…
Regulatory Framework
Trade Finance contributes a significant part of the interest and fee income earnings within Transaction Banking. International Trade Finance business is regulated by various Reserve Bank of India guidelines and also adhere to Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999. The important regulatory guidelines are as under:
- Master Directions & Notifications issued by the Reserve Bank of India
- The Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 (FEMA)
- The Indian Contract Act, 1872
- The Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881
- Trade Practices & Conventions like UCPDC (The Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits)
- Foreign Exchange Dealers Association of India Rules
- National Trade Policy
In addition to the above, the Bank has its internal guidelines and procedures to be adhered to. These may be related to sectoral exposures, interbank limits, customers’ limits etc.
SWIFT Message Categories in Trade Finance
As mentioned above trade finance involves various products. Each product is peculiar in nature depending on requirement of the customers. However, every product has lifecycle, which is generally shorter than a Term Loan or Cash credit. The international trade finance transactions are executed through an electronic platform provided by The Society for Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecommunication (SWIFT). On this platform the transactions are executed through text messages. The SWIFT message types have been categorised for transaction for each product. The details are as under:
| SWIFT Category | Message Identifier | Description / Product Scope |
|---|---|---|
| Category 1 | MT1xx | Customer Payments & Cheques |
| Category 2 | MT2xx | Financial Institution Transfers |
| Category 3 | MT3xx | Treasury Markets, to handle Foreign Exchange, Money Markets and Derivatives |
| Category 4 | MT4xx | Collection & Cash Letters |
| Category 5 | MT5xx | Securities Markets |
| Category 6 | MT600 | Treasury Markets |
| Category 7 | MT7xx | Documentary Credits & Guarantees |
| Category 8 | MT8xx | Travellers Cheques |
| Category 9 | MT9xx | Cash Management & Customer Status |
Common Verification Points in International Trade Finance
Certain common verification points in respect of International Trade Finance are as under:
- Whether goods exported or imported are permitted for export / import under the prevailing Foreign Trade Policy (FTP) of India as on the date of shipment and all the rules, regulations and directions applicable to export and import?
- Whether KYC of customer is carried out including line of business of the customer?
- In case of credit facilities extended, whether detailed credit appraisal has been carried out and facilities are sanctioned by the Competent Authority? Whether the credit appraisal for non-fund-based facilities is carried out as diligently as fund-based facilities?
- Whether the trade is genuine and the branch has obtained adequate evidences like evidence of exports/imports?
- Whether all charges are collected as specified in sanction letter or standard rate? In case of any deviation whether approval is obtained?
- Whether masters in core banking system (CBS) are correctly created for all customers and transactions?
- Whether the branch has process to reconcile all ‘swift’ messages sent from the Branch with the CBS and vice versa?
- If Branch is maintaining manual register for issuance of LCs, BGs, etc., then check whether the same is reconciled with the CBS?
- Whether the Branch received duly filled / completed and signed application letter from the customer for each transaction?
- In case of walk in customers, whether branch has taken due care for checking genuineness of the transaction?
- Normally the Branch maintains a checklist for documents to be obtained for each product, please check whether all documents are obtained as per checklist?
- Whether description of goods is consistent in all documents?
Product Descriptions and Detailed Verification Guidelines
The brief description of various products and important verification points are as under:
1) Letters of Credit (LC)
Documentary Credits, more commonly known as letters of credit are a widely used method to effect payments in domestic and international trade. The payment is made under conditions stated in the undertaking. Documentary Credits can be either sight or Usance depending on whether credit period is extended to the buyer by the seller. Sight credit states that the payment would be made by the Issuing Bank at sight, on demand or on presentation. In case of usance credit, drafts are drawn on the issuing bank or the correspondent bank at specified usance period.
Points to be verified normally for LC:
- Whether Letter of Credit is expired prior to presentation of documents?
- Whether Bill of Lading evidences shipment after the date range stated in the credit?
2) Standby Letters of Credit (SBLC)
These credits are generally used as a substitute for performance guarantee or for securing loans. The Standby Letter of Credit (SBLC) is an irrevocable documentary commitment, separate from the sales contract, issued by the bank to a third-party beneficiary and promising to pay on behalf of the originator a specific sum of money against delivery of documents satisfying the terms and conditions of the SBLC.
Points to be verified normally for SBLC:
- Whether Due diligence including KYC / Status reports on buyer / applicant as well as the seller / beneficiary has been carried out?
- Whether confirmation from the applicant that he is aware of the provisions under which SBLC has been issued?
- Whether implications of invocation of SBLC and resultant payment by the customer has been properly explained and recorded?
- Whether usage of SBLC is in line with the activities of the customers?
- Whenever SBLC is established through SWIFT, whether a separate clause is appearing that SBLC is subject to the provisions of ISP 98 or UCP 600?
3) Bank Guarantees (BG)
Bank Guarantee (BG) is an agreement between 3 parties viz. the bank, the beneficiary, and the applicant. The beneficiary is the one in whose favour the guarantee is issued and the applicant is the party who request the bank guarantee from the bank.
Points to be verified normally for BG:
- Whether the branch has obtained adequate margin as stipulated in sanction terms?
- Whether the guarantees issued are in standard format approved by Legal Department? If the beneficiary has specified format, then whether branch has taken approval for the same from competent authority?
- In the case of performance guarantee, whether branch has exercised due caution and have sufficient experience with the customer to satisfy themselves that the customer has the necessary experience, capacity and means to perform the obligations under the contract?
- Where guarantees are invoked, payment should be made to the beneficiaries without delay and demur?
- Whether bank guarantees have been issued in serial number?
- Whether prior approval of RBI has been obtained by the Bank for issue of performance bonds/ guarantees in respect of caution-listed exporters.
- Whether the Branch has issued any open-ended guarantee not having fixed term or guarantee with automatic renewal clause? In such case the same should be reported.
4) Imports
The Banks allow remittance for making payments for imports into India, after ensuring that all the requisite details are made available by the importer and the remittance is for bona fide trade transactions as per applicable laws in force. Except for goods included in the negative list which require license under the Foreign Trade Policy in force, AD Category - I banks may freely open letters of credit and allow remittances for import.
Points to be verified for Import Documents:
Whether the Branch has process to exercise due diligence while handling import documents on collection basis on behalf of importer customers with reference to:
- financial standing
- frequency of import and
- the genuineness of the import
5) Merchanting Trade
For a trade to be classified as Merchanting Trade following conditions should be satisfied:
- Goods acquired should not enter the Domestic Tariff Area, and
- The state of the goods should not undergo any transformation.
The commencement of Merchanting Trade would be the date of shipment / export leg receipt or import leg payment, whichever is first. The completion date would be the date of shipment / export leg receipt or import leg payment, whichever is the last.
Important verification points in Merchanting Trade:
- Whether both the legs of a Merchanting Trade Transaction are routed through the same bank.
- Whether the entire Merchanting Trade Transactions is completed within an overall period of nine months and there should not be any outlay of foreign exchange beyond four months.
- In case advance against the export leg is received by the Merchanting Trader, Whether the Branch has ensured that the same is earmarked for making payment for the respective import leg.
- Whether Branch has ensured one-to-one matching in case of each Merchanting Trade transaction and report defaults in any leg by the traders to the concerned Regional Office of RBI, on half yearly basis within 15 days from the close of each half year, i.e. June and December.
- Whether defaulting Merchanting Traders, whose outstanding reach 5% of their annual export earnings, are caution-listed.
- Whether the Branch has confirmed genuineness of traders and not mere financial intermediaries. Whether confirmed orders have been received by them from the overseas buyers.
6) High Sea Sale (HSS)
High Sea Sale (HSS) is a sale carried out by the consignee of a shipment to another buyer while the goods are still on high seas or after their dispatch from the port/airport of origin and before their arrival at the port/airport of destination. HSS contract/agreement should be signed after dispatch of goods from origin & prior to their arrival at destination. The agreement should be on stamp paper. The word ‘Sea’ appearing in HSS should not be taken by its literal meaning. As long as the sale is formalised after dispatch from port of origin and before arrival at the first port of discharge at destination, such sale is considered as HSS. The custom document i.e. bill of entry is either filed in the name of the high sea sale buyer or such bill of entry has an endorsement indicating the high sea sale buyers name. Bank may accept such bill of entry as sufficient entry of import provided all other details agree. The title of goods transfers to high sea sale buyer prior to entry of goods in territorial jurisdiction of India. The delivery from customs is, therefore, on account of high sea sale buyer.
7) Export
It is obligatory on the part of the exporter to realise and repatriate the full value of goods / software / services to India within a stipulated period from the date of export, as under:
- The period of realisation and repatriation of export proceeds shall be nine months from the date of export for all exporters including Units in Special Economic Zones (SEZs), Status Holder Exporters, Export Oriented Units (EOUs), Units in Electronic Hardware Technology Parks (EHTPs), Software Technology Parks (STPs) & Bio-Technology Parks (BTPs).
- For goods exported to a warehouse established outside India, the proceeds shall be realised within fifteen months from the date of shipment of goods.
Receipt of advance against exports:
- Where an exporter receives advance payment (with or without interest), from a buyer outside India, the exporter shall be under an obligation to ensure that the shipment of goods is made within one year from the date of receipt of advance payment;
- The documents covering the shipment are routed through the AD Category – I bank through whom the advance payment is received.
Provided that in the event of the exporter’s inability to make the shipment, partly or fully, within one year from the date of receipt of advance payment, no remittance towards refund of unutilised portion of advance payment or towards payment of interest, shall be made after the expiry of the said period of one year, without the prior approval of the Reserve Bank.
Important points for verification:
- Whether the branch has process to track the outstanding advance receipts?
- In case where advance against exports are out standing for more than one year, whether Branch has taken adequate steps like intimating customers, reminders, etc.
Export bills for collection:
Export Documents can be sent on collection basis without negotiating / purchasing / discounting. In this case the Bank is not exposed to any credit risk, however the goods exported through bill should be permitted category.
8) Export Credit – Pre-shipment Credit / Packing Credit
Pre-shipment credit/ Packing Credit means any loan / advance granted / any other credit provided by a bank to an exporter for financing the purchase, processing, manufacturing or packing of goods prior to shipment / working capital expenses towards rendering of services.
Pre – Shipment Export Finance features:
- Can be order based or running account basis
- Can be availed in FCY or in INR
- Proceeds cannot be credited to EEFC account
- Generally, for a permissible period of 360 days
- Liquidation from Export proceeds, EEFC balances & Rupee resources and in running accounts by marking individual bills on FIFO basis
Ordinarily, each packing credit sanctioned should be maintained as separate account for the purpose of monitoring period of sanction and end-use of funds. In running account facility, the method of liquidation of packing credit shall be on “first in- first out” basis.
Points to be verified normally for Packing Credit:
- Firm order or irrevocable LC placed/ opened by the overseas buyer.
- The confirmed order received from the overseas buyer should reveal the information about the full name and address of the overseas buyer, description, quantity and value of goods (FOB or CIF), destination and the last date of payment.
- All costs before shipment would be eligible for being financed under the packing credit.
- Packing Credit advance should be liquidated from export proceeds only.
- The quantum of Finance is fixed based on the FOB value of contract / LC or on the domestic value of goods, whichever is lower.
- In cases where exports do not take place within 360 days from the date of pre-shipment advance, such credits will be termed as ‘ECNOS’ (Export Credit Not Otherwise Specified) and Bank may charge interest rate prescribed for ‘ECNOS’ pre-shipment from the very first day of the advance.
- Before any disbursal is made under packing credit, it is very essential to see that the total of outstanding under packing credit (both in INR as well as FCY) is within the overall pre-shipment export credit limit of the exporter and the proposed disbursal falls within the limit.
9) Export Credit – Post Shipment Credit
Post-shipment Credit means any loan or advance granted or any other credit provided by a bank to an exporter of goods / services from India from the date of extending credit after shipment of goods / rendering of services to the date of realisation of export proceeds as per the period of realisation prescribed by RBI, and includes any loan or advance granted to an exporter, in consideration of, or on the security of any duty drawback allowed by the Government from time to time.
Post-shipment finance can be short term or long term, depending on the payment terms offered by the exporter to the overseas buyer. The maximum period allowed for realisation of exports proceeds is as stipulated by RBI for various category of exporters.
Form of Post-shipment advances:
Export Bills Purchased / Discounted / Negotiated (DP and DA Bills):
Export bills (Non-L/C Bills) representing genuine international trade transactions, strictly drawn in terms of sale contract/live firm contract/ order may be discounted or purchased by the bank. Proper limit has to be sanctioned to the exporter for purchase/ discount of export bill facility. If the export is not covered under L / C, risk of non-payment may arise. The risk is more pronounced in case of Documents under Acceptance.
Important Points to be verified in Post Shipment Credit:
- Invoice
- Shipping Documents like Airway Bill or Shipping Bill.
- License issued by DGFT if the goods to be exported fall under the restricted or canalised category
- If the item falls under quota system, proper quota allotment proof needs to be submitted.
- If advance is against LC, then check whether LC is valid till due date and the same is confirmed by issuing bank.
- Whether Ports of loading and destination not as specified in the LC?
Advance Against Export on Consignment Basis:
Goods exported on consignment basis are at the risk of the exporter. Eventual remittance of sale proceeds is made by agent/consignee. The interest rate up to 180 days from the date of advance will be the rate applicable for usance bills for period up to 180 days. Beyond 180 days from the date of shipment, banks are free to decide on the rate of interest. In case the sale proceeds are not realised within the sanctioned period, the higher rate of interest as applicable for ‘ECNOS’-post-shipment will apply for the entire period beyond 180 days.
Advance Against Undrawn Balance on Exports:
In certain lines of export trade, it is common practice to leave a certain amount as undrawn balance. Adjustments are made by buyer for difference in weight, quality etc., ascertained after arrival and inspection of goods. The exporter has to give an undertaking that he shall surrender or account for the balance of the proceeds within a period prescribed for realisation. Such advances can be provided at a concessional rate up to a maximum period of 90 days only. For the period beyond 90 days, the rate of interest specified for the category Export Credit Not Otherwise Specified (ECNOS) at post-shipment stage may be charged.