“Accounting Profession is passing through challenging times on account of drastic changes in the regulatory landscape and also due to the failure of many corporate entities arising out of either mis-management of funds or adoption of fraudulent practices. The Government is currently seized of the disciplinary proceedings against audit firms’ alleged role in the IL&FS episode. Another alarming fact is that a substantial number of audit firms have tendered mid-term resignations from the position of statutory auditors of listed entities in the recent past. During these testing times, it is imperative that we certain robust measures to strengthen the ethical fabric of the profession, enhance the core competence of its members and promote awareness among stakeholders,” says the author as he analyses the Indian accountancy profession in the age of new India. Read on…

Author: CA. T.N. Manoharan, Padma Shri
Designation: Past President of ICAI and Chairman of Canara Bank
Contact: tnmanoharan@gmail.com or eboard@icai.in
Published In: The Chartered Accountant, July 2019, Vol. 68, No. 1, pp. 91–93 (VISION— Past Presidents)

Challenging Environment

With the passage of time, business practices are getting complicated and the environment is quite challenging. The business methodologies and practices are becoming vulnerable for manipulations and the individual value system is degenerating due to greed resulting in many frauds and scams. Cases of mis-management and flouting of governance norms are getting reported in the corporate world, where it is least expected. This also leads to widening the gap between expectations of the stakeholders as against performance by an auditor.

Beginning with Satyam case, followed by many other scams including Nirav Modi’s case associated with Punjab National Bank and the current on-going investigation in IL&FS group cases, the accountability of auditor who has attested the financial statements has been subject matter of scrutiny. In Satyam case, the auditor was banned by SEBI from auditing listed entities for two years. The Companies Act, 2013 (ACT) and the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949 provide for stringent consequences if an auditor is found guilty in discharging his onerous task. The Act has vested the right of class action suits in favour of the shareholders, exerting pressure not only on management but on auditor as well. Hitherto, only a signing partner was liable for any consequence for misdeed, but now, even the firm can suffer the consequences for lapses in the discharge of the audit function- Sec.147(5).

Expectation Gap

In order to reduce the expectation gap between the stakeholders and the profession, besides other measures, we may consider taking the following steps:

  1. Organise collaborative programs with CII, FICCI, ASSOCHEM so as to create awareness among stakeholders on the scope and objectivity of audit and assurance function.
  2. Continuously have dialogue with Government and Regulatory agencies to keep them abreast of the measures taken to empower and regulate the profession.
  3. Periodically interact with the media and brief them on the initiatives taken by the ICAI and showcase the good work done by its Members. CA profession, by this process, would often be in the news for good reasons.

Digitisation

Digitisation can disrupt accounting opportunities as automation can easily take over that function. But audit cannot be substituted by mechanised systems as technology can support and supplement audit but can’t substitute for audit. In fact, digitisation would facilitate enhanced accuracy of data and seamless flow of information during audit function. With the advent of technological innovations, audit firms can scale up, improve efficiency, draw analysis & findings expeditiously and above all achieve cost competitiveness. In any case, Auditor’s scepticism, diligence and professional judgement cannot be replaced by automation under any circumstances. These aspects and related virtues ultimately enable comprehensive reporting and appropriate disclosures to the stakeholders comprising of shareholders, investors, depositors, lenders including banks and financial institutions, regulators and Governments. Consequently, digitisation or no digitisation, audit function would sustain itself for ever.

“Audit cannot be substituted by mechanised systems as technology can support and supplement audit but can’t substitute for audit. Digitisation or no digitisation, audit function would sustain itself for ever.”

Capacity Building

We should focus on capacity building in CA profession which involves empowering the Small and Medium Practitioners to undertake works which otherwise they may not be in a position to handle by themselves. The following measures may be considered in this regard:

  1. Along with every large firm, one SMP may be considered for appointment as joint auditors for listed companies above a certain threshold of turnover.
  2. One knowledge portal can be developed and access can be provided to SMPs so that they can be guided to handle any new area evolving;
  3. Workshops with intensity can be organised on select areas to impart practical knowledge providing them with check lists and templates by way of handholding.
  4. Mergers and Network arrangements can be encouraged by removing the disadvantages associated with such growth strategies.

Similarly, we must take initiatives to enable Indian Forms to go global. In fact, many Firms are ready to expand and position in overseas jurisdictions either directly or through a network mechanism, but our regulatory framework needs to undergo suitable changes and shackles emanating therefrom ought to be done away with. If any Indian firm wants to expand and grow in any overseas location, it must be facilitated smoothly. Similarly, if any Indian firm is part of a global network only for knowledge sharing, it must be encouraged. If there is no capital infusion by a foreign entity into the Indian Firm, no control exercised and if there is no repatriation of profits, then such affiliation must be facilitated.

“We must take initiatives to enable Indian Forms to go global. In fact, many Firms are ready to expand and position in overseas jurisdictions either directly or through a network mechanism, but our regulatory framework needs to undergo suitable changes and shackles emanating therefrom ought to be done away with.”

Further, an Indian firm should be enabled to pioneer and establish a global network of professional firms originating from India to rope in foreign firms operating in different countries for knowledge sharing. As the Hon’ble Prime Minister suggested on CA Day celebrations during 2017, that we must endeavour that at least 4 Indian CA firms join the Big 8 league globally.

Women CAs’ Empowerment

Data reveals that the enrolment of girl students (about 40% of the students’ population) during the last one decade has seen phenomenal increase and so is the strength of women CAs. Women CAs were numbering 7826, constituting 8% of total number of CAs in the year 2000 whereas in 2018 the strength has grown to 69,647 accounting for 24.6%. The Companies Act and SEBI guidelines mandate listed companies to have at least one women director on the Board. ICAI should conduct on-going certification courses to train members with mock board meetings and particularly empower women CAs with proper skill orientation so that companies prefer to appoint a women CA as an independent director on the board and also as a chairperson or a member of the Audit committee.

ICAI to Expand Horizon

ICAI is a regulatory body quite larger when compared to other regulatory bodies governing other corporate professionals such as Company Secretaries and Cost Accountants. Strategically, ICAI needs to demarcate exclusive areas wherein its members alone have the core competency and domain expertise to deliver services and preserve them as a forte not to be encroached by any other corporate professionals. Auditing and assurance function related to financial statements under the Companies Act and audits under revenue legislations fall within this parameter. There are many other areas, such as tax advisory or representation up to tribunal or management consultancy services where our profession competes with others. In those areas, ICAI would do well to periodically review the curriculum, offer specialised courses, conduct orientation & training workshops, hold CPE programs to empower members with updated and upgraded knowledge so that service seekers would, on criteria of competency and capability, prefer a CA against other competing professionals.

India has all along been a service sector driven economy and now the focus is shifting to manufacturing sector. Make in India and Start Up India are all measures that would gain momentum in the years to follow. Manufacturing sector would, after a few decades, turn out to be a dominant contributor to the GDP and the professional arena of costing and management accounting would gain significance.

Conclusion

No doubt, the present business environment is transforming into a VUCA world, implying that there is Volatility, Uncertainty, Complexity and Ambiguity (VUCA). In such an environment, it is truly a challenge for a member of our profession to discharge the duties associated with assurance function by upholding standards and values as the risk matrix is escalating. Nevertheless, we must believe that challenges are given only to those who have the ability to handle them and give our best to deliver timely and quality services. A profession like ours owes it to the society to possess the courage of conviction to perform our role as an auditor in the best interest of the stakeholders in order to establish unblemished track record for the posterity to inherit. We should partake, participate and partner in the process of Nation Building. We must collaborate with the Government in building credible economy in this incredible India. If this approach is adopted, we need not worry about the future of our profession. It would, indeed, become the profession of the future.

“There is Volatility, Uncertainty, Complexity and Ambiguity (VUCA). In such an environment, it is truly a challenge for a member of our profession to discharge the duties associated with assurance function by upholding standards and values as the risk matrix is escalating.”

“Thousands of candles can be lighted from a single candle, and the life of the candle will not be shortened.” — Buddha