Legal Update

Delhi Tax Tribunal Rules on Applicability of Indirect Transfer Tax Provisions

CA. Sahil Gupta • The Chartered Accountant, August 2019 • pp. 115–119 (Journal pp. 279–283)
The author is a member of the Institute. He can be reached at sahilgupta93@gmail.com and eboard@icai.in

After the Apex Court, in case of Vodafone, refused to read the provisions of Section 9 of Income-tax Act, 1961 to cover indirect transfer of shares of foreign company having underlying assets in India, the Indian government moved retrospective amendment by Finance Act, 2012 to bring such cases to tax. Basis these amendments, the Indian Revenue Authorities had raised a demand of INR 10,000 crores on Cairn UK. The issue had gathered much spotlight amidst growing concerns among foreign investors about the retrospective nature of amendments. The Delhi Tribunal, in a detailed decision, has decided the matter in favour of Indian Revenue Authorities and confirmed the demand raise. Meanwhile, Cairn has also initiated arbitration under the India-UK bilateral investment treaty, the outcome of which is expected by end of 2019. Read on to know more…

Introduction and background

The indirect transfer tax provisions were introduced in (Indian) Income-tax Act, 1961 (“ITA”) by Finance Act, 2012. This was one of the fallout of the Supreme Court decision in case of Vodafone International Holdings BV vs UOI and others (2012) 6 SCC 613. In that case, the Apex Court held that transfer of shares of a foreign company between two non–resident taxpayers is not liable to tax in India. Following important principles were also laid down by the Supreme Court:

  • Shares of a foreign company cannot be deemed to be situated in India merely because all the assets of the foreign company are situated in India;
  • A controlling interest is not an identifiable or distinct capital asset independent of the holding of shares. Hence, a transaction of sale of shares simpliciter cannot be ‘look through’ and dissected. Rather, a ‘look-at’ approach needs to be adopted; and
  • Under section 9(1)(i) of ITA, word ‘indirect’ is used in relation to the word ‘income’ and not ‘transfer’. Hence, while indirect income from a transfer may become liable to tax in India; indirect transfer per se is not liable to tax in India.

The Finance Act, 2012 inserted Explanation 4 and 5 to Section 9(1)(i) of ITA and also amended the definition of ‘capital asset’ under section 2(14) of the ITA. All these amendments were inserted as clarifications and made applicable with retrospective effect from April 1, 1961. In summary, these amendments sought to tax transfer of ‘share’ or ‘interest’ in a foreign company deriving substantial value from assets located in India. There was a lot of ambiguity around application of these provisions. For instance, the manner of computation of capital gains was not provided, the meaning of terms like ‘share’, ‘interest’ and ‘substantial’ was not defined.

In 2014, the Delhi High Court in case of DIT vs Copal Research Limited [2014] 49 taxmann.com 125 (Delhi) held that ‘substantial’ would necessarily have to be read as synonymous to ‘principally’, ‘mainly’ or at least ‘majority’. Thus, this should represent more than 50% threshold. Hence, transfer of shares of a foreign company can be brought to tax in India only in case such shares derive more than 50% of their value from assets located in India. Subsequently, Finance Act, 2015 inserted Explanation 6 and 7 to Section 9(1)(i) of ITA clarifying the indirect transfer provisions and provided power to government to notify Rules for determining fair market value (“FMV”) for application of indirect transfer tax provisions. Pursuant to this, Central Board of Direct Taxes (“CBDT”) has notified detailed rules for computing FMV of shares of foreign company and Indian company in cases of indirect transfer of shares of a foreign company deriving substantial (i.e.; 50% or more) value from Indian assets.

While the Delhi High Court decision (in case of Copal Research Limited) was the first judicial pronouncement after introduction of indirect transfer tax provisions under the ITA, the analysis therein was limited to interpretation of the term ‘substantially’. Now the Delhi bench of Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (“Tribunal”) in case of Cairn UK Holdings Limited vs. DCIT (ITA No 1669/Del/2016) has analysed these provisions in detail and ruled in favour of Indian Revenue Authorities (“IRA”). This has been discussed in detail below.

Facts of the case

A survey was conducted under section 133A of ITA on premises of Cairn India Limited (“CIL”), an Indian company. From the premises of CIL, certain documents pertaining to Cairn UK Holdings Ltd (“CUHL”), the Appellant, were obtained by the IRA. Basis the information/documents gathered from the premises of CIL, reassessment proceedings were initiated on CUHL, the holding company of CIL.

Cairn Energy PLC (“CEP”), a company incorporated in Scotland was holding various oil and gas assets in India through its direct/indirect foreign subsidiaries. In the year 1995, CEP acquired participating interest in the underlying Indian assets. The shares of these companies were transferred initially to UK and then Jersey and finally to India. A sequence of date and events and diagrammatic presentation of the structure is depicted below:

Date Description of event
June 26, 2006 CUHL was incorporated in the United Kingdom as a 100% subsidiary of CEP.
June 30, 2006 CUHL issued 22,14,44,034 ordinary shares of face value of £1 each to CEP in exchange for the entire issued share capital of the subsidiaries of CEP which owned Indian assets in the form of Oil and Gas blocks.
August 2, 2006 CUHL incorporated another 100% subsidiary Cairn India Holdings Ltd (“CIHL”) which was registered in Jersey, Channel Islands.
August 7, 2006 CUHL transferred its entire shareholding in the above-mentioned 26 companies to CIHL. In return, CIHL issued 22,14,44,034 ordinary shares of £1 each to CUHL.

CUHL increased its authorised share capital to 25,15,00,000 £1 ordinary shares and further issued 2,97,80,710 £1 ordinary shares at par to CEP pursuant to a debt conversion agreement between CEP, CUHL, CIHL and Cairn Energy Hydrocarbons Limited (a subsidiary of Cairn India Holdings at this time).

In summary, this agreement provided that £2,97,80,710 due to CEP from Cairn Energy Hydrocarbons Limited was assigned to CUHL in exchange for an issue of shares. CUHL subsequently assigned the debt to CIHL in exchange for 2,97,80,710 £1 ordinary shares in CIHL.

The debt amount of £2,97,80,710 became due to CIHL from Cairn Energy Hydrocarbons Ltd. Thus as on September 1, 2006 CUHL was holding 22,14,44,034 + 2,97,80,710 = 25,12,24,744 ordinary shares of £1 each of CIHL.

Date Description of event
September 15, 2006 CUHL entered into a subscription and share purchase agreement with CIHL and CIL with CEP as the Guarantor. The Subscription and Share Purchase Agreement provided for CIL to acquire approximately 21.85% of share capital of CIHL in two tranches.
October 12, 2006 Another Share Purchase Deed was signed and the entire remaining shareholding of CIHL (ie, 78.15%) was acquired by CIL, from CUHL. Out of this, 53.84% was acquired through a share for share exchange and 24.31% was acquired for cash. Total cash proceeds were approximately GBP 677 M.

CIL divested 30.5% of the stake to general public and institutional investors. Part of the purchase price of the share of INR 6,101 crores were paid out of the proceeds of the public issue by CIL to the Appellant.

Basis the retrospective amendment made by Finance Act, 2012, the assessing officer passed a draft assessment order and held that transfer of shares of CIHL by Appellant to CIL is liable to tax in India. This is because the shares of CIHL derive their value substantially from assets located in India. The draft assessment order was confirmed by the Dispute Resolution Panel. Aggrieved, CUHL preferred an appeal before the Tribunal.

Decision of the Tribunal

Note: The Appellant also challenged reopening of assessment proceedings before the Tribunal, which was rejected by the Tribunal after elaborate discussion in the order. For the sake of brevity, that aspect has not been discussed in this article.

1. Constitutional Validity of Retrospective Amendments to Section 9(1)(i)

Contention of the Appellant: Amendments made to Section 9(1)(i) of ITA by Finance Act, 2012 are bad in law and ultra vires the Constitution of India.

Decision of Tribunal: An authority constituted under a statute cannot adjudicate on the constitutional validity of provisions of that statute. For this purpose, reliance was placed on the decision of Supreme Court in case of L Chandra Kumar vs UOI (2002-TIOL-159-SC-CB).

2. Internal Reorganisation and Capital Asset Definition under Section 2(14)

Contention of the Appellant: The series of transactions through which shares of Indian subsidiaries were transferred to CIL involved only Cairn group entities. There was no change in controlling interest as a result of these internal reorganisations and there is no increase in the wealth of the group. Hence, no capital gains tax can be levied.

Decision of the Tribunal: As per amendment made to the definition of ‘capital asset’ by the Finance Act, 2012, ‘property’ includes (with retrospective effect) ‘any rights in or in relation to an Indian company, including rights of management or control or any other rights whatsoever’. In the instant case, shareholders of 9 companies situated in India which controls the oil and gas sector in India are having the ‘property’ of the right to manage and control that business by virtue of shareholding and further such rights are ‘rights in or in relation to an Indian company’. CIHL is the holding company of those subsidiary companies and Appellant is holding company of CIHL. Therefore, it is apparent that the Appellant is holding rights in control and management of the shares of the 9 Indian subsidiary companies engaged in the business of oil and gas sector through holding subsidiary structure. Further, CUHL has divested 30% of its shareholding in CIL to general public in the IPO and therefore, value is definitely derived by Cairn group and the Appellant through these series of transactions.

3. Step-up of Cost of Acquisition under Sections 48, 49 and 55

Contention of the Appellant: While computing the capital gains, the cost of acquisition should be stepped up to the fair value of the shares of CIHL on the date of acquisition.

Decision of Tribunal: On conjoint reading of provisions of Section 48, 49 and 55 of ITA, it is apparently clear that property held by Appellant and its mode of acquisition do not fall in any of the clauses which provides for taking the cost of acquisition in its hands in these transaction being cost to the previous owner. There is no merit in the contention of the Appellant that as there is no timing difference between the acquisition and disposal of shares, the full value of consideration and the cost of acquisition is the same. Provision of Section 48, 49 and 55(2) of ITA do not allow such treatment. Therefore, the computation of capital gain in the hands of Appellant is required to be made by deducting from the full value of consideration, cost of acquisition incurred for acquisition of the shares of CIHL.

4. Interplay between Retrospective Domestic Tax Law and India-UK DTAA

Contention of the Appellant: Article 14 of Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (“tax treaty”) between India and UK provides that each contracting state may tax capital gain in accordance with the provision of its domestic tax law. Further, the India-UK tax treaty was notified on February 11, 1994. For the purpose of taxability of capital gains, the domestic law should be seen as it was in existence on the date on which India-UK tax treaty was notified. In other words, on the date of notification of India-UK tax treaty, the retrospective amendment to Section 9 made by Finance Act, 2012 was not in existence and therefore, as the Appellant is eligible for benefit of tax treaty, the domestic tax law is required to be read ignoring such retrospective amendment. For this purpose, the Appellant also relied on the recent decision of Delhi High Court in case of DIT vs New Skies Satellite BV [2016] 68 taxmann.com 8 (Delhi).

Decision of Tribunal: The provisions in a tax treaty cannot make the domestic tax law static with respect to taxability of a particular income when unequivocally both states have left it to the domestic laws of the countries. For instance, in case there is an exemption provided with retrospective effect under the domestic tax law, then a non-resident taxpayer cannot be denied the benefit as it was also not the law at the time of notification of tax treaty.

The Tribunal also distinguished the reliance placed by taxpayer on the decision of Delhi High Court in the case of DIT vs New Skies Satellite BV. The Tribunal held that the decision of Delhi High Court is not relevant in the instant case as the issue before the High Court was whether in view of Article 3(2) of tax treaty, the meaning of royalty can be ascertained from the domestic tax law where such term is already defined in the tax treaty.

5. Levy of Advance Tax Interest under Sections 234A and 234B

Contention of the Appellant: Interest under section 234A and 234B of the ITA (on failure to pay advance tax) should not be levied due to tax demand being based on retrospective amendment.

Decision of Tribunal: The Appellant could not have visualised its liability for payment of advance in the year of transaction. Therefore, there cannot be any interest payable by the Appellant under section 234A and 234B of the Act. Further, the Supreme Court in case of Ian Peter Morris vs ACIT (2016) 389 ITR 501 (SC) held that when the salary income payable to a non-resident is subject to tax withholding under section 192 of ITA, question of payment of advance tax do not arise and consequently, provisions of Section 234B and 234C also have no obligation. Similar has been held by the Delhi High Court in the case of DIT vs GE Packaged Power Incorporation (373 ITR 65). Hence, interest under section 234A and 234B of ITA cannot be levied in the instant case.

Conclusion

While the decision is well written and the various contentions of the taxpayer and the reason for rebuttal have been elaborately discussed, it is interesting to note that the Appellant did not challenge the retrospective applicability of the amendments made by the Finance Act, 2012 to Section 9(1)(i) of ITA. Albeit these amendments have always been portrayed by the government as a mere clarification and applicable from April 1, 1961, the Shome committee after analysing various provisions of the ITA, had concluded that it was never the intention of ITA to bring to tax transfer of shares of a foreign company having no presence but only underlying assets in India. It would be interesting to see whether this argument is taken by Cairn before the Delhi High Court, in case of a further appeal.

Although the Tribunal has adjudicated the matter in favour of IRA; the final word on the issue is yet to come. With tax demand of INR 10,000 crores, the Cairn group is likely to approach Delhi High Court and the matter would, in all likelihood, reach the Apex Court before attaining finality.

Meanwhile, Cairn also initiated arbitration under article 9 of the agreement between government of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland and the government of India for the promotion and protection of the investment and the proceedings are currently in progress. According to news reports, an international arbitration tribunal had in August, 2018 concluded main court hearings in Cairn Energy’s challenge to the Indian government using retrospective legislation to seek INR 10,247 crore in taxes. The tribunal was supposed to give an award by February 2019 but the same is now expected not before the end of the year. Outcome in this regard would be keenly watched by international investor community.

“In three words I can sum up everything I’ve learned about life: it goes on.”
– Robert Frost