Enabling Growth Through Tax Reforms
The authors are members of the Institute. They can be reached at aseem.schawla@gmail.com and eboard@icai.in
In 2017, the Government of India (GOI) formed a task force to draft tax legislation or code (direct tax code) to replace the existing 50-year-old Income Tax Act. The task force submitted its report to the Union Finance Minister on Monday, August 19, 2019.
Corporate Tax Rates slashed to 22 % from 30 % for existing companies and to 15 % from 25 % for new manufacturing companies
In 2015-16, the then Finance Minister announced that the basic Corporate Income Tax (CIT) rate would be reduced to 25 %. But follow up progress on the same was slow. The immediate reforms go beyond this by lowering the basic rate to 22 % for domestic companies and 15 % for new manufacturing companies. The cess and surcharges however continue. While availing this lower rate, the companies will have to forego the benefits of any tax exemptions and deductions.
The impact of the changes in corporate tax rates equally depends on how the tax benefits will be utilised by the corporate sector. If the additional profits are utilised to increase capital expenditure, corporate investment will go up and spur production in the future years. On the other hand, if the benefits are converted into some form of incremental dividends, it should have a demand-side effect. There will be a pick-up in demand, and this may have more immediate effect. However, it is difficult to estimate what impact it will have in the current year.
Overall, the CIT reforms are supply-side reforms aimed at increasing the profitability and productivity of investment. India’s CIT rates have now become globally competitive. There is intra-sectoral neutrality across industry and services except for new manufacturing which has got an added boost. Supply-side reforms take time to work themselves out.
Going ahead, a fresh look is needed over the continuance of cess and surcharges. Perhaps, Government must also move forward towards abolishing the option of two rates and have only one rate with no exemptions.
E-Proceeding Facility
In the budget speech (2018-19) the then Finance Minister Arun Jaitley had promised faceless assessment. “I propose to amend the I-T Act to notify a new scheme for assessment where the assessment will be done in electronic mode which will almost eliminate person-to-person contact leading to greater efficiency and transparency”, he had proposed.
The Finance Act, 2016 had introduced enabling as provision that “hearing” includes communication of data and documents through electronic mode, except for the search related assessments, which shall be continued to be made through traditional/ manual mode.
E-Assessment Scheme for Faceless Scrutiny of Income Tax Returns
The Finance Ministry vide Notification No. 61/2019 dated September 12, 2019 has notified the E-Assessment scheme 2019 for faceless scrutiny of Income Tax returns. Under the scheme all the communication between the taxpayer and the Assessing officer will be purely electronic, communications to be digitally authenticated and above all the Assessee’s will not be required to make personal appearance before assessing officer. The foremost objective of the scheme is to reduce the interface between the taxpayer and the tax department and to impart greater transparency & accountability.
The scheme involves creation of E-Assessment Center’s at national and regional levels. The basis of allocation of cases amongst the Center’s will be automatic. The Assessment will be governed by certain predetermined risk assessment criteria and other pre-fixed broad parameters by the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT).
(a) The important aspects of the E-Assessment scheme are summarised below:
- Under the scheme, the scrutiny notice will be issued to the individual under section 143(2) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, if he has under-reported his income or over-stated losses.
- The individual will have to reply within 15 days from the date of receipt of notice. The notice issued will be sent electronically on the taxpayer’s account on the e-filing website, to the registered email address of the taxpayer or on the mobile app of the income tax department which has the registered mobile number.
- Individual will be required to respond to the notice or order received through the registered account only. The response shall be considered successfully submitted once individual has received the acknowledgement from the National E-Assessment Centre (NEAC).
- Individual taxpayers would not be required to appear either personally or through authorised representative in relation to the proceedings related to the scheme before income tax authority, NEAC or Regional E-Assessment Centre (REAC) or any unit set up under the scheme.
- All the communication between the department and taxpayer would be done electronically. Even all the internal communication within the income tax department will be electronic.
- The e-assessment scheme will be fully automated. Under the scheme, NEAC can assign the scrutiny case to any REAC through an automated allocation system.
- If the regional assessment unit wants further information or documents from the taxpayer, then such request to be made to NEAC.
- The regional assessment unit will make a draft assessment order and send it to NEAC.
- The NEAC will examine the draft received in accordance with the risk management strategy specified by the CBDT.
After the finalisation of assessment electronic file will be handed over by NEAC to the jurisdictional Assessing Officer.
(b) Important Aspects of E-Assessment are highlighted as under:
- Penalty proceedings can be initiated by the assessment unit through NEAC in case of non-compliance of any notice, direction or order.
- All the above communication shall take place through electronic communication which will be served either in the electronic portal or e-mail id or mobile app and a real time alert.
- There is no personal appearance in the process, but an Assessee can request for personal hearing of the same. Personal hearing shall take place through video conference, through a software which would enable video telephony.
- Further Video conference facilities shall be established at such locations for the Assessee to visit and attend video conference, even though he may not have video conference facilities at his place.
- E-assessment is not a special type of assessment. All the current assessments can be carried out in an electronic manner following the procedure mentioned above.
- Interestingly, re-assessment under section 147 has not been covered and that has to happen through offline mode.
- Appeals under section 246A shall remain lie with the jurisdictional Commissioner (Appeals).
(c) Powers of Jurisdictional Assessing Officer:
After the file gets transferred to the Assessing Officer, he would have powers only for the following:
- Imposition of penalty;
- Collection and recovery of demand;
- Rectification of mistake;
- Giving effect to appellate orders;
- Submission of remand report, or any other report to be furnished, or any representation to be made or any record to be produced before the Commissioner (Appeals), Appellate Tribunal or Courts, as the case may be;
- Proposal seeking sanction for launch of prosecution and filing of complaint before the court;
- However, NEAC may at any stage of the assessment, if considered necessary, transfer the case to the Assessing Officer having jurisdiction over such case.
(d) Observations of the scheme:
The new scheme notified by the CBDT will change the way of scrutiny of the Income Tax return. It will bring more transparency, efficiency and improved monitoring etc. Earlier, the Income Tax return was scrutinised by the Assessing Officer of the taxpayer through online mode.
However, under the new scheme not only the assessment will be faceless but the taxpayer is also not required to meet any Assessing Officer during the continuation of proceedings.
The taxpayer will need to submit a detailed explanation/documentation regarding the tax position in his/her matter. Technical glitches can also be expected during the initial phase of the faceless assessment.
The scheme was announced in budget and notified in the month of September 2019 and the department has selected 58,322 cases for scrutiny under the new scheme and the e-notices have been served before September 30, 2019, for the cases of Assessment Year 2018-19.
Introduction of Documentation Identification Number (DIN) for every type of communication
In order to provide for a transparent and recorded communication & also to increase trust of the taxpayers in the system of tax collection and communication, the CBDT has launched a computer-generated documentation identification number (DIN) system.
From October 1 onwards, every CBDT communication, will be required to have a DIN. Any communication without a computer-generated DIN will be invalid.
On the very first day of its launch 17500 DIN’s were issued. “The system would ensure greater accountability and transparency in tax administration,” finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman had tweeted.
Way forward
Introducing faceless E-assessment scheme is welcome move, the administration should also focus on reduction of arbitrary litigation being pursued by the Income Tax Department. Currently, the Income Tax Department is one of the top litigants in the country. Even though the appeal filing limits have been increased recently, the Government should look at taking more intensive measures to reduce such forced litigation upon the taxpayer.
The way forward could be to develop an Artificial Intelligence-based interactive website/program, where small taxpayers can resolve their routine queries. All in all, India is moving towards digitisation and we may see further improvements on this front.
The new direct tax code will try to bring more assessees into the tax net, make the system more equitable for different classes of taxpayers, make taxpayers more competitive by lowering the corporate tax rate and phase out the remaining tax exemptions that lead to litigation.
The direct tax code offered indexation benefits for equity investments. Indexation adjusts the purchase price of an asset with inflation during the holding period, thus reducing the capital gains and tax payable on this. Also, investors could carry forward losses and adjust them against future gains.
The move is rightly aimed at raising the profitability and productivity of investment. Tax cuts, however, in the present case have more of a reform flavour.
Concluding Remarks
The aim of the Government is to bring more transparency & minimising the interface between the taxpayer’s and the tax officials which would increase the confidence, trust of the taxpayer’s in the system of tax collection by the government with the faceless e-assessment scheme. Introducing DIN and enabling assessments through e-proceedings facility will help in achieving the objectives viz-à-vis transparency, minimising interface between taxpayers and tax officers of the government. Reduced rates of CIT will have little impact in the short run but could have a significant positive impact on growth in the medium term.