Impact Analysis of Reduction in Corporate Tax Rates
The Hon’ble Finance Minister announced substantial reduction in the tax rates applicable to Domestic Companies. Post announcement by the Finance Minister, the Taxation Laws (Amendment) Ordinance, 2019 has been promulgated by the President proposing various amendments in the Income-tax Act, 1961 as well as the Finance (No.2) Act, 2019. These reduction in tax rates will go a long way in attracting various multinational companies to shift manufacturing base in India. India will now be able to take advantage of the global trade issues and promote itself as manufacturing capital of the World.
The effective tax rate of 17.16% for manufacturing companies is quite competitive or even better than the other competing economies of the South East Asia such as China, Thailand, Indonesia, Vietnam, Singapore, Hong Kong etc. The growth in economy and the job creation due to this will be far more beneficial as compared to any Revenue which is being forgone by this reduction in the tax rate. The amendments made by this Ordinance are analysed below. All the amendments (except the amendment in section 115QA) are to be effective from assessment year 2020-21 i.e., relating to income earned in financial year 2019-20.
A. New Corporate Tax Rates vis-à-vis Existing Rates
1. Concessional Tax Rate of 22% to apply to Domestic Companies
The Taxation Laws (Amendment) Ordinance, 2019 has inserted a new section 115BAA in the Income-tax Act, to provide an option to all domestic companies to pay tax at concessional rate of 22% with fixed surcharge of 10% and health and education cess of 4%. Thus, the effective tax rate for domestic companies will be 25.17%.
There is no condition/limitation on account of turnover, whether such company is engaged in manufacturing or not, the type of business or activity of the company or the date when the company was incorporated. Thus, all existing as well new domestic companies are eligible to avail this concessional rate of tax. Further, it is to be noted that this provision is applicable to domestic companies. Tax rates in respect of other entities such as partnership firm, LLP, Individuals, HUF, etc. shall continue to be as notified in the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2019.
2. Comparison with Rates in Force prior to the Ordinance
Prior to insertion of above section 115BAA, there were existing broadly two tax brackets that were applicable in respect a domestic company i.e. 25% and 30%. Companies whose turnover in previous year 2017-18 did not exceed ₹ 400 crores were liable to pay tax at 25% plus surcharge and health and education cess as applicable. Domestic companies whose turnover exceeded ₹ 400 crores in previous year 2017-18 were liable to pay tax at 30% plus surcharge and health and education cess as applicable.
Further, there is another section 115BA that provide an option to pay tax at concessional rate of 25% to domestic companies set up and registered on or after 31st March 2016 that are engaged solely in the business of manufacturing or production of any article or thing and research in relation to, or distribution of such article or thing manufactured or produced by it. Under this provision, option to pay concessional rate of tax of 25 percent is available irrespective of the turnover of the company but with the condition that such company will not claim any exemption/incentive. While such option was available to the above said manufacturing companies irrespective of their turnover, such option was not available to such companies if these were incorporated prior to 31st March 2016.
Now, after the introduction of section 115BAA in the Act by this Ordinance, all domestic companies have been given an option to pay tax at concessional rate of 22% (effective tax rate of 25.168%) without benefit of any exemption/incentive. Thus, the benefit to the companies whose turnover does not exceed ₹ 400 crores in previous year 2017-18 will only be of 0.832% in case where income of such company does not exceed ₹ 1 crores. In the case of such companies where income exceeds ₹ 1 crore but does not exceed ₹ 10 crore, the benefit will be 2.65%. In the case of companies whose turnover exceeds ₹ 10 crores, the benefit will be of 3.952% as is evident from the below table and that too after sacrificing benefit of various exemption/incentive as stated herein below, if any available to such companies:
| Category of taxpayers | Domestic Companies whose turnover in Previous Year 2017-18 does not exceed ₹ 400 crores | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Tax liability under normal provisions | Tax liability under section 115BAA | Net saving in taxes (in %) | |
| Income Upto ₹ 1 crore | 26.00% | 25.17% | 0.83% |
| Income more than ₹ 1 crore but upto ₹ 10 crores | 27.82% | 25.17% | 2.65% |
| Income more than ₹ 10 crores | 29.12% | 25.17% | 3.95% |
These companies constitute 99.3% of the total companies. The real gainers of new provision introduced by this Ordinance will be the companies whose turnover exceeded ₹ 400 crores in previous year 2017-18 i.e. the remaining 0.7% companies as can be seen from the following table:
| Category of taxpayers | Domestic Companies whose turnover in Previous Year 2017-18 exceeds ₹ 400 crores | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Tax liability under normal provisions | Tax liability under section 115BAA | Net saving in taxes (in %) | |
| Income Upto ₹ 1 crore | 31.20% | 25.17% | 6.03% |
| Income more than ₹ 1 crore but upto ₹ 10 crores | 33.38% | 25.17% | 8.21% |
| Income more than ₹ 10 crores | 34.94% | 25.17% | 9.77% |
Thus, the biggest gainer with this amendment will be companies having turnover of more than ₹ 400 crores and income above ₹ 10 crores. Such companies will save 9.77% which means saving of about 28% (9.77/34.94*100) of present tax liability.
B. Concessional Rate of Tax for New Companies engaged in Manufacturing and Production
1. Tax Rate of 15% (Effective Tax Rate of 17.16%)
The Taxation Laws (Amendment) Ordinance, 2019 has inserted another section 115BAB, to boost manufacturing in India, providing an option of concessional rate of tax of 15% to new domestic companies set up and registered on or after 1st October, 2019 and engaged solely in the business of manufacturing or production of any article or thing and research in relation to, or distribution of such article or thing manufactured or produced by it. This benefit will be available to all such domestic companies which commence manufacturing on or before 31st day of March, 2023. Thus, the concessional rate is not for short term but applicable for all such companies which are set up and registered and commence manufacturing during the period spread over from 1st October 2019 to 31st March 2023 i.e. three and a half years. The surcharge applicable on such tax shall be 10 percent irrespective of the income of the company with health and education cess at the rate of 4%. Thus, the effective tax rate will be 17.16%.
2. Eligibility Criteria to opt for Concessional Rate of Tax Under Section 115BAB
It is to be noted that this provision is applicable to domestic companies. It is to be noted that this benefit is available only to such companies which have been set up and registered on or after 1st October, 2019 and accordingly the existing companies cannot be used for setting up a new business. A new company needs to be incorporated so that its date of registration is also on or after 1st October, 2019 and such company needs to commence manufacturing on or before 31st March, 2023. Further, such company cannot be formed by splitting up or reconstruction of a business already in existence. Also, such companies cannot use any machinery or plant previously used for any purpose. However, a company may use previously used plant and machinery as long as its value does not exceed 20% of the total value of the plant and machinery of the company.
3. Concessional Rate under New Section 115BAB is Assessee based not Manufacturing Unit based
This new section 115BAB provides for concessional rate of 15% on total income of a domestic company set up and registered on or after 1st October 2019. Hence, this deduction will not be available to an existing company even if it sets up a new unit of manufacturing or production. Thus, the existing company in case it intends to avail benefit of this concessional rate, need to set up a separate company may be a subsidiary company. It would have been ideal if this benefit would have been extended in respect of income derived from a new industrial undertaking /unit set up on or after 1st October 2019 from the business of manufacturing or production of any article or thing.
4. Challenges in opting Concessional Rate of 15% Under Section 115BAB
There is no condition/limitation on account of turnover under section 115BAB but the company should not be engaged in any business other than business of manufacturing or production of any article or thing and research in relation to, or distribution of such article or thing manufactured or produced by it. This clause apparently is very restrictive. There may be a question raised in case such company does some trading of the items it is engaged in manufacturing or production to meet the business requirement or provide some services. There may be a question raised that the company has failed to meet the condition prescribed which is worded negatively i.e. ‘not engaged in any business other than the business of manufacturing or production’.
Further, there may also a question raised as to whether a company that is engaged in the business of generation of power can be said to be eligible to opt for the concessional rate of 17.16% under section 115BAB as there have been disputes in the past on the issue as to whether the generation of power means production of an article or thing.
Further, there may be a question on the income such companies may have from interest in respect of surplus money or accumulated profits. It may have some rental income in respect of assets owned by it or capital gain arising from the sale of assets or investments held by it. There is no clarity whether in such case company will lose benefit of concessional rate of 15% or only such income which is not from the business of manufacturing or production will be taxed at a rate other than the 15%. As noted earlier, sub-section (1) of this section 115BAB states that ‘Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act but subject to provisions of this chapter….. income tax payable in respect of the total income of a person shall at the option of such person be computed at the rate of 15%’. Meaning of this will be that the total income of such company will be taxed at the rate of 15%. The total income of such company obviously will include income by way of interest, rent, etc. if any. Apparently, earning such income by way of interest or rent etc. do not violate the above condition since earning interest income and rental income does not mean carrying on or engagement in any other business. Income from interest/dividend from investments is normally chargeable as income from other sources and income from rent in respect of land and building is normally chargeable as income from house property. Thus, earning such income is not likely to be seen as a violation of such condition.
5. Consequences of Indulging in any other Business other than Manufacturing or Production
As pointed out earlier, this benefit of concessional tax is available only to such companies which are not engaged in any business other than the business of manufacturing or production. Thus, such companies need to ensure that it does not carry on any other business even trading or providing services for all times to come. In case such company inadvertently in some subsequent year does some activity or carry on business which is beyond the business permissible, then it may not be eligible to claim the concessional rate of tax of 15%. At the same time, this may give an option to the company to exit this provision by committing default which exit as explained above is otherwise prohibited.
In case a company engages in any business other than the business of manufacturing or production in any subsequent year, then it may opt to pay tax for such year at the concessional rate of tax of 22% (effective tax rate of 25.16%) under section 115BAA. Such option will have to be exercised on or before the due date of furnishing of return of income under section 139(1) of such year. It is relevant to point out that there is no condition prescribed under section 115BAA that the option to pay tax is to be exercised in the first year itself. Thus, such option may be exercised in the subsequent years as well. However, once this option has been exercised for any year, it cannot be subsequently withdrawn for the same or any other assessment year.
It is relevant to point out that in case a company pays tax at the concessional rate of 17.16% under section 115BAB for any year and subsequently, during the assessment proceedings, it is disputed by the Assessing Officer that the company is engaged in any business other than the business of manufacturing or production, then such company will not have the option to pay tax at the concessional rate of 25.16% under section 115BAA. This is because the option to pay tax at concessional rate under section 115BAA is to be exercised on or before the due date of furnishing the return of income under section 139(1) of the Act which will obviously not be the case. Such company will accordingly be required to pay tax at the rates specified in the First Schedule to the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2019 i.e. 25% (plus surcharge and cess as applicable) in case the turnover does not exceeds Rs. 400 crores in previous year 2017-18 or 30% in case the turnover exceeds ₹ 400 crores (plus surcharge and cess as applicable).
6. Applicability of Transfer Pricing Provisions
It is to be noted that provision of section 92BA are being amended so as to apply transfer pricing provision on the business of new companies covered under section 115BAB. In this regard, a new clause (va) has been inserted in section 92BA to apply specified domestic transfer pricing provision in respect of any business transacted between such company and any other person with which the company has close connection.
C. Option to Pay Tax at Concessional Rates Under Section 115BAA and 115BAB Need to be Exercised before Furnishing Returns of Income and cannot be Subsequently Withdrawn
For claiming concessional rate of 22% under section 115BAA, company shall be required to exercise the option before the due date of furnishing the return under section 139(1) of the Act. However, there is no restriction that such option is to be exercised in the current year itself. Such option can be exercised in the subsequent years as well. As against this, under section 115BAB, the option to pay tax at concessional rate of 15% is to be exercised before filing the first return of income under section 139(1). In case such company does not exercise its option in the very first year, it will lose the benefit of exercising such option for all times. Thus, a company has to make a choice in the very first year.
However, under both the sections 115BAA and 115BAB, it has been provided once this option has been exercised for any year it cannot be subsequently withdrawn for the same or any other assessment year. Thus, option once exercised under this section will be applicable in perpetuity in all subsequent assessment years.
D. Evaluation of Tax Liability under Existing Rates and Newly Inserted Section 115BAA
The option to pay tax at concessional rate of 22% under section 115BAA will ideally suit by and large all companies particularly those providing services, engaged in trading except a few companies which are eligible to claim deduction under section 10AA in respect of special economic zone, or which are eligible to claim deduction under section 80IA, 80IB etc. or companies which have acquired or installed new plant and machinery and accordingly the claim of initial depreciation of 20% in respect of such new plant & machinery acquired is substantial. However, as pointed out earlier, even such companies who are claiming the said deductions and exemptions have the option to pay tax under this newly inserted section 115BAA from subsequent year when it has exhausted the benefit of deduction/incentive under above provisions. Accordingly, it will be advisable to work out the tax liability under the existing provision i.e. at the rate of 25% in case turnover during financial year does not exceed ₹ 400 crores and 30% in case where turnover exceeds ₹ 400 crores (plus surcharge and health and education cess as applicable) and after claiming various deductions/incentives and the option given under this newly inserted section 115BAA i.e. at the rate of 22 percent (plus surcharge and health and education cess as applicable).
In case it is found that the tax liability under this new provision consequent to denial of various deductions/exemptions is more than the tax liability under the normal provision, then the company may not opt for this reduced rate and may opt for this new provision in subsequent year when tax liability under this new provision is less than the normal provision. However, it should be noted that once an option is exercised under this new provision it will be applicable for subsequent years as well. Thus, this exercise need to be carried out keeping in mind the future deduction/incentive, if any, to which such company may be eligible to claim.
E. Deductions/Incentives to be forgone in Case Company opts to Pay Tax at Concessional Rate Under Section 115BAA or Under Section 115BAB
Companies, who opt to pay tax at concessional rates under section 115BAA or 115BAB, while computing the total income have to forego deduction on account of SEZ under section 10AA, additional initial depreciation allowable at the rate of 20% under section 32(1)(iia), investment allowance in respect of new plant and machinery under 32AD, Tea Development Benefit under section 33AB, Site Restoration benefit under section 33ABA, Scientific Research benefit under section 35, accelerated capital deduction for specified business under section 35AD, agricultural extension project benefit under section 35CCC, skill development project under section 35CCD and the benefit available under provisions of Chapter VI-A under the heading “C-Deductions in respect of certain incomes” i.e. 80IA, 80IB, 80IC, etc.. However, deduction under section 80JJAA in respect of employment of new employees will be available to such companies.
Further, such companies shall not be eligible to set off any loss carried forward from any earlier assessment year if such loss is attributable to any of the above deductions/incentives. Accordingly, if there is any carried forward loss, the same has to be adjusted by ignoring the deduction/incentives, if any, claimed under any of the above clauses. It may be noted that though section 115BAB also provides for restricting carried forward loss without deduction and incentive, however, considering the fact that such companies are new and are required to exercise the option under this section in the very first year of the return of income, practically there will be no such carried forward loss which will be attributable to any of the restricted deduction/incentive.
F. No Liability to Pay Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT) If Company opts to Pay Tax at Above Concessional Rate Under Section 115BAA or Under Section 115BAB
The companies having opted for concessional rate of 22% under newly inserted section 115BAA or 15% under newly inserted section 115BAB will have an additional benefit as there will be no liability to pay minimum alternate tax (MAT) under section 115JB. The Ordinance has amended section 115JB by inserting a new sub clause (ii) in sub section (5A) to provide that section 115JB shall not be applicable to a company which has exercised the option to be taxed at concessional rate under this new section 115BAA or 115BAB.
The above benefit of exemption from paying MAT in substance may not be much beneficial as with the prohibition of exemption/deductions in respect of income of SEZ allowable under section 10AA, Chapter-VIA heading C and other incentives, the difference in the book profit and the income computed under normal provision may not be much. The difference now in such cases will be mainly in the method/rate of depreciation charged under the Companies Act and the rate prescribed under the Income Tax Rules, disallowances or deductions under section 43B, 40(a)(i), 40(a)(ia), etc. Thus, such companies will not normally otherwise be liable for MAT. However, non-applicability of MAT will certainly have some other benefits as discussed hereunder:
a. No liability under MAT if there is no capital gain after indexation
Presently, a company is required to pay MAT on the amount received by it in respect of sale of capital asset if such amount is more than the cost of acquisition despite the fact that there is no capital gain after taking into account indexed cost of acquisition. With the abolition of MAT in respect of those companies which have opted for this new provision, there will be no liability to pay MAT in respect of such difference. Further, long term capital gains are chargeable to tax at 20% with the benefit of indexation available in respect of cost of acquisition and cost of improvement. Such tax amount, if computed as a percentage of the gain amount without applying indexation, it may fetch a number below 15%. In such cases as well, the companies will benefit from non-applicability of MAT.
b. No liability under MAT in respect of income chargeable to tax at rate lower than rate of MAT
A company which is liable to pay tax in respect of any income which is chargeable to tax at special rates under Chapter XII, which are less than the rate of MAT, then such companies will benefit from such amendment. For instance, long term capital gain on sale of equity shares, unit of an equity oriented fund and unit of a business trust are liable to tax at the rate of 10% under section 112A. Such gains are otherwise chargeable under MAT at 18.5% (15% now). In such cases, the companies will benefit from non-applicability of MAT.
c. Credit of brought forward MAT credit
Another issue in respect of existing domestic companies who now opt to pay tax at concessional rate of 22% under section 115BAA will be of carried forward MAT credit. As per the existing provision of section 115JAA, credit is allowed of tax paid under MAT i.e. section 115JB of the difference between the tax payable by the assessee on his total income in the subsequent year and the MAT liability of that subsequent year. With the non-applicability of MAT provision, there will be no MAT liability in subsequent year and hence such company who opt for this new provision shall be in a position to claim credit of brought forward MAT against its entire current tax liability. Thus, it can be a big bonanza of zero tax for such companies which are having substantial amount of brought forward MAT credit. It is to be noted that amendment has been made only in section 115JB to provide that this section will not be applicable and there is no amendment in section 115JAA under which credit of brought forward MAT is allowed against regular tax liability.
d. Aggregate of brought forward loss and unabsorbed depreciation will be available for deduction against income computed under the normal provisions
Another benefit with the non-applicability of MAT will be on account of brought forward loss. Under MAT provisions, lower of unabsorbed depreciation or business loss is allowed to be set off while computing book profit liable for MAT whereas in the normal computation, aggregate of brought forward loss and unabsorbed depreciation is allowed to be set off.
e. Principal and/or interest waiver to Non-performing assets (NPAs) will not attract MAT
In case of NPAs, if a debt restructuring measure is implemented, the outcome of compromise or such measure is likely to result in a situation where substantial part of debt owed by the borrower company may be waived by the lenders. The borrowing companies may consequently write back such liabilities in their books by credit to Profit & Loss statement as required by applicable Accounting Principles. Once such liabilities are written back in the books of account by credit to the profit and loss account, the same becomes part of the book profit and hence attracts MAT despite having huge carried forward unabsorbed depreciation and business losses which are allowed to be adjusted under MAT only to the extent of lower of the two and that too as per the books of accounts. This has been causing great hardship to such companies as such companies were required to pay MAT despite being in heavy losses in the year of settlement with the bank/financial institution on the amount waived. Consequent to the abolition of MAT in respect of companies who opt to pay tax under this newly inserted section 115BAA, MAT provisions will not be applicable and consequently, the income will be computed under normal provisions where full benefit of aggregate of brought forward unabsorbed depreciation and business losses computed as per income tax provisions will be eligible for set off against the income computed under the normal provisions.
G. Capital Gain Taxable under Section 111A, 112 and 112A to Continue to be Taxed at Rates Prescribed under Such Sections
It is relevant to point out that sub-section (1) of this section 115BAA states that ‘Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act but subject to provisions of this chapter…..income tax payable in respect of the total income of a person……… shall at the option of such person be computed at the rate of 22%’. Similarly, sub-section (1) of this section 115BAB states that ‘Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act but subject to provisions of this chapter…..income tax payable in respect of the total income of a person……… shall at the option of such person be computed at the rate of 15%’. It is to be noted that the total income of the company is taxable at 22% under section 115BAA and 15% under section 115BAB. However, it is to be noted here that tax rate of 22% under section 115BAA and the tax rate of 15% under section 115BAB are subject to the provisions of this chapter i.e. Chapter XII. Concessional rate on Capital gain in respect of STT paid short term capital gain is prescribed at the rate of 15% under section 111A, long term capital gain tax rate of 20% after benefit of indexation prescribed under section 112 and tax on STT paid long term capital gain in respect of sale of equity/ units of mutual funds post 1st April 2018 chargeable at the rate of 10% without indexation under section 112A fall under this chapter. Thus, income by way of such capital gain will be chargeable at the above appropriate rate prescribed under these sections and not at the rate of 22% under section 115BAA or 15% under section 115BAB, as the case may be.
However, tax on other short term capital gain which is chargeable under the normal provisions does not fall under this chapter and the strict interpretation of total income will mean that such short term capital gain will also be chargeable at the concessional rate of 22% or 15% under section 115BAA or 115BAB, as the case may be.
H. Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT) Rate Reduced from 18.5% To 15%
Taxation Laws (Amendment) Ordinance, 2019 has reduced the MAT rate from 18.5% to 15%. The net savings in taxes that arises to different category of domestic companies, based on the amount of book profit, which do not opt for concessional rate of tax under section 115BAA or 115BAB in view of the exemption/incentives available to such companies and hence, continue to pay taxes as per the First Schedule to the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2019 will be 3.64% in case its book profits does not exceed ₹ 1 crores, 3.89% in case its book profit exceeds ₹ 1 crores but does not exceed ₹ 10 crores and 4.08% in case its book profit exceeds ₹ 10 crores.