The Chartered Accountant • Journal of ICAI June 2022 • Vol. 70 • No. 12 • pp. 62–69 (Journal pp. 1498–1505)
CAPITAL MARKET • ECONOMETRIC RESEARCH

Impact of COVID 19 on Global Capital Markets

*Dr. Mitrendu Narayan Roy and **Prof. (Dr.) Siddhartha Sankar Saha

*Dr. Mitrendu Narayan Roy is an academician and financial researcher specializing in capital markets and financial economics.

**Prof. (Dr.) Siddhartha Sankar Saha is Professor and academician in financial markets and econometric modeling.

Authors can be reached at mitrenduroy@gmail.com, drsiddharthasxc@gmail.com, and eboard@icai.in.

1. Background of the Research

A few notable epidemics/pandemics to date that have shaken the world are ‘The Black Death’ plague (1347–1351); bleeding fever (Mexico - 1545–1548); cholera (1899–1923); Acute Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS) (Cameroon – 1908); Spanish flu (1908); Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS) (Asia and Canada – 2002-03), etc. A new addition to the list is the COVID-19 coronavirus pandemic (2019-nCov). It first appeared in December 2019 in Wuhan city of Hubei province, China (Estrada et al., 2020). The first death from the virus was reported on 11 January 2020 (Pharmaceutical Technology, 2020). On 12 March 2020, the World Health Organisation (WHO) declared it a pandemic. By then the number of deaths from COVID-19 had crossed 20000. There was a serious increase in the number of cases in Italy, the United Kingdom (UK), Germany and a few other European countries due to initial laxity from the Government and citizens.

Later, the United States (US) had drawn the world’s attention in terms of the number of cases and deaths as well. On the other hand, the outbreak started much later in India (end-March 2020). However, the number of confirmed cases rose to a considerable extent within no time due to a high population density. As a measure of a solution, the Governments of different countries had immediately cancelled all international flights, postponed all forms of international meets, prohibited any form of social congregations and set a complete quarantine in motion. Some countries even had declared a state of emergency to manage the situation (Ayittey et al., 2020).

2. Research Problem

“Due to COVID-19, stock returns across the world started projecting a declining trend since February 2020. Naturally, the question arises whether stock returns of major global economies have responded negatively to COVID-19.”

Though containment achieved its desired effect of capping number of cases, the pandemic and subsequent lockdown completely stalled global trade and productions (John Hopkins University, 2020). Transportation and tourism business took a major hit which also caused decline in exchange rate. Manufacturing sectors had to stop production due to absence of labour. The only sector that thrived was public health and pharmaceuticals due to an absolute desire of a vaccine at the earliest.

All these unfortunate yet unavoidable circumstances ultimately started to reflect in the stock market performances. Truly speaking, stock market returns is considered to be a barometer of economic growth and is influenced by other macro-economic variables (Saha, 2021). However, due to COVID-19, stock returns across the world started projecting a declining trend since February 2020. Naturally, the question arises whether stock returns of major global economies have responded negatively to COVID-19.

3. Review of Literature

With a view to addressing the problem identified above, a few research studies are reviewed here:

Ahmar and Val (2020)

Ahmar and Val (2020) predicted the movement of returns of IBEX (Spain) in the back of COVID-19 using the Sutte ARIMA method.

Al-Awadhi, et al. (2020)

Al-Awadhi, et al. (2020) investigated the impact of COVID-19 on Chinese stock market returns using panel data regressions. The results indicated a significant relationship between COVID-19 and stock market returns.

Baker et al. (2020a)

Baker et al. (2020a) analysed the impact of natural disasters, terrorist attacks and political stocks on stock market performance using panel data regression. The results suggested a robust short-term impact on stock market growth.

Baker et al. (2020b)

Baker et al. (2020b) explained the unprecedented stock market reaction to the COVID-19 pandemic by considering stock market volatilities since 1985. The evidence suggested that Government restrictions amid this pandemic were possibly the main reason behind such reaction.

Baker et al. (2020c)

Baker et al. (2020c) assessed the macroeconomic impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic based on three uncertainty measures (stock market volatility, newspaper-based uncertainty and subjective uncertainty in business expectation surveys). The results implied that half of the total contraction in the US-GDP was made due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

Dietrich et al. (2020)

Dietrich et al. (2020) documented the consumers’ perception of the US stock markets’ reaction to the COVID-19 pandemic. The results suggested that the rise in consumers’ uncertainty accounted for 2/3rd of the total GDP drop.

Liu et al. (2020)

Liu et al. (2020) evaluated the impact of COVID-19 on the stock market returns of select affected countries, like Japan, Korea, the US, Germany, Singapore, and the UK using the event study method and panel fixed effect regressions. The results indicated high abnormal returns in the Asian market due to pessimistic investor sentiments.

Liu and Hu (2020)

Liu and Hu (2020) used the neoclassical economic growth model in explaining how COVID-19 promoted China’s savings rate leading to long term growth in their GDP.

Sansa (2020)

Sansa (2020) investigated the impact of COVID-19 on the stock markets of China (Shanghai Stock Exchange) and the USA (Dow Jones) based on the data from 1 – 25 March 2020 using the simple regression technique. The study revealed a positive significant relationship between COVID-19 confirmed cases and stock market growth.

Zeren and Hizarci (2020)

Zeren and Hizarci (2020) revealed the possible reaction of confirmed cases and deaths from COVID-19 on major stock market returns using Maki’s cointegration test. Confirmed cases of infection and deaths in China, Korea and Spain had a cointegrating relationship with their stock market returns.

4. Research Gap & Objectives

4.1 Research Gap

None of the studies reviewed, so far, had taken an attempt to explore the correlation between confirmed cases of infection and deaths from COVID-19 with stock market returns in the top five economies in the globe. Keeping this gap in view, the current study attempts to address the following objectives.

4.2 Objectives of the Study

The objectives of the current study are as follows:

  1. To enquire into the growth of confirmed cases and deaths from COVID-19 and stock market returns in five major economies in the Globe during the study period (Refer to Section 5.1);
  2. To measure the underlying characteristic of the data representing the growth of confirmed cases and deaths from COVID-19 and stock market returns (Refer to Section 5.2);
  3. To explore the impact of the growth of confirmed cases and deaths from COVID-19 on stock market returns (Refer to Section 5.3).

5. Data and Methodology

5.1 Sample Selection

With a view to analysing the correlation between stock market returns and COVID-19, stock markets representing the top five developed and developing economies across the globe based on their nominal gross domestic product (GDP) by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) (IMF, 2019) have been sampled out. They are USA, China, Japan, Germany and India. Now, the largest stock exchange in each country has been selected based on its market capitalisation (World Federation of Exchanges (WEF), 2019). Accordingly, New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) in the US; Shanghai Stock Exchange (SSE) in China; Tokyo Stock Exchange (TSE) in Japan; Frankfurt Stock Exchange (FSE) in Germany; and Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE) in India are selected. One representative stock index having worldwide recognition and prominence has then been selected for the study. Thus, Standard & Poor’s (S&P) 500 (NYSE, USA); SSE Composite Index (SSE, China); Nikkei 225 (Nikkei) (TSE, Japan); DAX 30 (DAX) (FSE, Germany); and Sensitivity Index (SENSEX) (BSE, India) are the stock indices, which are selected for the calculation of stock returns.

5.2 Period of Study

To capture this entire recession in the stock market that was caused due to the first wave of COVID-19, the study considers it appropriate to consider the period of study from 1 February 2020 to 30 April 2020.

5.3 Collection of Data and Data Mining

The data on indices values of five select stock indices during the study period have been collected from Yahoo Finance, while data on daily cases of infection and death from COVID-19 in five select countries during the study period are collected from the World Health Organisation (WHO) COVID dashboard.

Since all the select stock markets do not perform on the same dates due to weekends or public holidays in different countries, the index with the least number of days of operation has been considered as a base and data on additional days of operation of other stock indices have been removed until all the stock indices conform to exactly same operational dates. Finally, the study is made with 50 observations uniform for all the markets.

It is significant to note that while the data related to the number of cases and deaths due to COVID-19 are available in each day from 1 February 2020 to 30 April 2020, data related to stock indices of all five countries in each day from 1 February 2020 to 30 April 2020 are not available because of non-operation of the markets. Hence, with a view to bring uniformity to the data related to the variables, like number of cases, number of deaths and value of stock indices of all the five countries, appropriate data mining technique has been applied and the study has been conducted with comparable data of number of cases, number of deaths and stock market indices on uniform dates in all the five countries.

5.4 Analytical Tools & Mathematical Formulations

The returns of stock indices values and growth in the number of daily cases and deaths from COVID-19 on final selected dates have been calculated. The country-specific data is, then, graphically represented using a line chart plotting the values on the vertical axis and time on the horizontal axis.

The descriptive statistics comprise varied statistical measures in understanding the nature of the data. It includes:

  • Mean: [ 1/n × ∑ Yt ] (from t=1 to n)
  • Median: Positional middle value of ordered observations
  • Extreme Values: Maximum and Minimum recorded values
  • Standard Deviation (S.D.): [ √( 1/(n-1) × ∑ (Yt - Ȳ)2 ) ] (from t=1 to n)
  • Sum of Squared Deviation (SS): [ ∑ (Yt - Ȳ)2 ] (from t=1 to n)
  • Skewness: Degree of distortion from a symmetrical normal distribution. While a normal distribution has skewness ranging between -0.5 to 0.5, skewness greater than 0.5 represents a positively skewed distribution and vice versa. If skewness is greater than 1, the distribution is highly positively skewed and vice versa.
  • Kurtosis: Measure of outliers present in the distribution. A distribution with kurtosis equal to 3, less than 3, and greater than 3 are Mesokurtic (normal), Platykurtic (low on outliers), and Leptokurtic (high on outliers) respectively.
Jarque-Bera (JB) Normality Test

Null hypothesis (H0): JB statistic = 0
Alternate hypothesis (H1): JB statistic ≠ 0

Formula: JB = [(n - k + 1) / 6] × [S2 + ¼ (C - 3)2], where n = number of observations (50); k = number of regressors (1); S = sample skewness; C = sample kurtosis. At n degrees of freedom and 5% level of significance, if p < 0.05, H0 is rejected.

Pearson’s Correlation Coefficient (r) & t-Test

Null hypothesis (H0): r = 0
Alternate hypothesis (H1): r ≠ 0

The correlation among stock returns, growth of COVID cases, and growth of COVID deaths is tested at (n - 2) = 48 degrees of freedom at 5% significance level. If p < 0.05, the correlation is statistically significant.

6. Results and Analysis

6.1 Growth of Confirmed Cases and Death from COVID-19 and Stock Market Returns

“Growth of cases and deaths due to COVID-19 in all the five countries were more volatile than their stock market returns. Stock markets in almost all the countries projected negative returns in early-February.”

It has been observed (Chart 1) that growth of cases and deaths due to COVID-19 in all the five countries were more volatile than their stock market returns. Stock markets in almost all the countries projected negative returns in early-February. However, it became volatile when the spread began to rise in mid-February. By the end of February, the volatility was tamed to some extent. The curve representing growth of deaths moved coherently to the curve representing growth of cases in all the five countries. In the USA, growth in the number of daily cases surged in the beginning of March followed by sudden growth of deaths.

Chart 1: Movement of Stock Returns with Growth of New Cases and New Deaths
Panel A: Stock Return of S&P 500 (SP_R), Growth of New Cases in the US (USCC_G) and Growth of New Deaths in the US (USCD_G)
Panel B: Stock Return of SSE Composite Index (SSE_R), Growth of New Cases in China (CHINACC_G) and Growth of New Deaths in China (CHINACD_G)
Panel C: Stock Return of NIKKEI (NIKKEI_R), Growth of New Cases in Japan (JAPANCC_G) and Growth of New Deaths in Japan (JAPANCD_G)
Panel D: Stock Return of DAX (DAX_R), Growth of New Cases in Germany (GERMANYCC_G) and Growth of New Deaths in Germany (GERMANYCD_G)
Panel E: Stock Return of BSE SENSEX (SENSEX_R), Growth of New Cases in India (INDIACC_G) and Growth of New Deaths in India (INDIACD_G)

(Source: Compiled based on Secondary Data using MS Excel)

In China, the growth of daily cases and deaths suddenly jumped in mid-February 2020. However, after that, for quite some time, it projected negative growth. The growth of cases and deaths in China rose again in mid-March 2020 and once again in end-April 2020. Growth in number of cases in Japan was higher from mid-February to mid-March 2020. Death rate in Japan followed the rate of cases. In early-March 2020, growth of new cases and deaths were negative in Germany. It mainly surged at the end-February followed by an increase in death rate. However, towards the end of April 2020, it is again showing a negative growth. In India, growth of cases were almost nil till the beginning of March, 2020. It started to increase from middle of the month. In the beginning of April 2020, growth of new deaths has reached an exorbitant level.

6.2 Underlying Characteristics of the Data

Underlying characteristics of the data representing growth of confirmed cases and deaths from COVID-19 and stock market returns are represented through descriptive statistics. It is observed that barring SSE Composite Index, all other indices reported negative returns during the period (Table 1). Among them, the SENSEX projected the lowest return. In terms of median return too, the SSE was at the top position followed by the DAX, while the SENSEX was at the bottom of the chart. In terms of maximum and minimum values, SD and sum of squared deviation, the S&P 500 and the DAX were the two most volatile indices during the period.

Table 1: Descriptive Statistics of Stock Market Indices
Parameters S&P 500 SSE Composite Nikkei DAX SENSEX
Mean -0.161688 0.055849 -0.259846 -0.310276 -0.372426
Median 0.065206 0.180931 -0.592039 0.101501 -0.382140
Maximum 9.382774 3.146437 8.038101 10.97590 8.974906
Minimum -11.98406 -3.711597 -6.080833 -12.23861 -8.177789
Std. Dev. 4.273521 1.439420 2.863170 3.691717 3.469425
Skewness -0.285601 -0.361952 0.695388 -0.206920 -0.053876
Kurtosis 3.742767 3.351235 4.114851 5.681452 3.679801
Jarque-Bera 1.829115 1.348753 6.619059 15.33635 0.986959
Sig. 0.400694 0.509474 0.036533 0.000467 0.610498
Sum -8.084422 2.792457 -12.99229 -15.51382 -18.62131
Sum Sq. Dev. 894.8860 101.5246 401.6895 667.8101 589.8085

(Source: Compilation based on Secondary Data using EViews 9.0)

However, the SSE was comparatively less volatile during the period. From the results of skewness, it is observed that distributions of all the stock returns barring that of Nikkei were negatively skewed (skewness < 0.5). Results of kurtosis (kurtosis > 3) denote the presence of outliers in all the distributions. Results of the JB test proved that apart from the Nikkei and the DAX, returns of other stock indices followed a normal distribution.

Table 2: Descriptive Statistics of Growth of Individual Cases of COVID-19
Parameters USA China Japan Germany India
Mean 45.92422 22.01844 181.8661 18.27986 18.89092
Median 0.000000 -11.15196 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000
Maximum 2100.000 649.3571 2800.000 520.0000 228.5714
Minimum -100.0000 -95.45455 -100.0000 -100.0000 -100.0000
Std. Dev. 309.6745 136.0987 618.7303 87.64985 66.32218
Skewness 6.039869 3.626223 3.182397 3.833781 1.113106
Kurtosis 40.36334 16.47938 11.72502 22.84267 4.514488
Jarque-Bera 3212.374 488.1079 242.9928 942.7563 15.10352
Probability 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000525
Sum 2296.211 1100.922 9093.305 913.9931 944.5462
Sum Sq. Dev. 4699016. 907620.2 18758535 376442.3 215532.9

(Source: Compilation based on Secondary Data using EViews 9.0)

It is evident (Table 2) that the average growth of daily cases during the period was highest for Japan and least for Germany. However, the median growth of new cases in all the countries was zero except China. In terms of volatility in the growth of new cases, Japan topped the list while India was at the bottom of the chart. The distributions representing growths of new cases in five countries were highly positively skewed (skewness > 1) and leptokurtic. The skewness and kurtosis were highest for USA and least for India. Results of the JB test showed that none of the distribution follows normality.

Table 3: Descriptive Statistics of Growth of Individual Cases of Deaths
Parameters USA China Japan Germany India
Mean 24.67507 3.827105 49.80059 9.037145 20.45881
Median 0.000000 -3.786816 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000
Maximum 700.0000 653.8462 733.3333 237.5000 600.0000
Minimum -100.0000 -100.0000 -100.0000 -100.0000 -100.0000
Std. Dev. 118.9114 105.3595 175.4768 47.11002 103.8822
Skewness 3.973858 4.825637 2.667706 2.349935 3.990197
Kurtosis 22.48121 30.39871 9.933605 13.18018 21.58198
Jarque-Bera 922.2576 1757.992 159.4614 261.9267 852.0347
Probability 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000
Sum 1233.753 191.3553 2490.030 451.8572 1022.941
Sum Sq. Dev. 692856.1 543930.2 1508814. 108748.4 528783.9

(Source: Compilation based on Secondary Data using EViews 9.0)

Corresponding to the results of the growth of new cases, the average growth of new deaths in Japan was the highest, while it was the least for Germany (Table 3). The median growth of new deaths was zero in all the countries barring China. While growth deaths were highly volatile in Japan, it was not all so in Germany. All the distributions were high on the right tail (positively skewed) and with a high number of outliers (leptokurtic). Skewness and kurtosis were highest in China, while it was least in Japan. Results of JB tests suggest that the growth of new deaths in none of the countries followed a normal distribution.

6.3 Correlation between Stock Market Returns and Growth of COVID Cases and Deaths

In this section, an attempt has been made to calculate the Pearson’s correlation coefficient (r) and its relative significance among the stock returns, growth of new cases and growth of new deaths in the countries under consideration (Table 4).

Country / Variable Pearson’s Correlation Coefficient (r) Significance of r (p-Value)
New Cases New Deaths New Cases New Deaths
USA (S&P 500)
New Deaths -0.151419 1.000000 0.2939 —
Stock Return -0.186437 0.170571 0.1949 0.2363
CHINA (SSE Composite Index)
New Deaths 0.141105 1.000000 0.3284 —
Stock Return -0.092245 0.078779 0.5240 0.5866
JAPAN (Nikkei 225)
New Deaths -0.082640 1.000000 0.5683 —
Stock Return -0.063942 -0.119488 0.6591 0.4085
GERMANY (DAX 30)
New Deaths -0.068132 1.000000 0.6383 —
Stock Return 0.217533 0.128658 0.1291 0.3732
INDIA (BSE SENSEX) • Statistically Significant
New Deaths 0.360650 1.000000 0.0101* —
Stock Return -0.350003 -0.087035 0.0127* 0.5478

(Source: Compilation of the Secondary Data using EViews 9.0; * denotes statistically significant correlation at 5% level)

Based on the results obtained, it may be inferred that only in India, the stock return had significant correlation (P-value < 0.05) with growth in COVID cases. However, in other countries, the association between stock return, growth of new cases and deaths were not significant (P-value > 0.05). For all the countries under consideration barring Germany, the stock return was negatively correlated with growth of new cases (r < 0). However, apart from Japan and India, the stock return was positively correlated (r > 0) with the growth in number of deaths. Out of all the five countries, only in India stock market returns responded significantly to the growth in number of cases due to COVID-19.

It is important to note that the Indian stock market was projecting positive growth in the pre-pandemic era. However, the pandemic and its far-reaching impacts on the US and European economies had made the foreign investors pull out funds from the Indian market which perhaps resulted in a sudden drop in Indian stock market returns.

7. Conclusion

“India was the worst sufferer of the shock in terms of average stock market return. However, the market significantly responded to the growth in number of cases in India. While the mortality of the disease was comparatively low, it posed a great threat to the economic stability and stock market growth.”

While the outbreak of COVID-19 began at different points of time in different countries, it mainly loomed across the five countries under the current study during mid-February 2020 to early-April 2020. Out of the five countries, the average growth and volatility in terms of number of cases and deaths from COVID-19 was highest in Japan. While the mortality of the disease was comparatively low, it posed a great threat to the economic stability and stock market growth.

The recession in stock market began since early-February 2020 in all the countries. Moreover, the market started to correct itself from mid-April 2020. While the outbreak first started in China, its stocks seem to have been least affected by this unprecedented shock as evidenced from the average return. India was the worst sufferer of the shock in terms of average stock market return. However, the market significantly responded to the growth in number of cases in India, while the relationship between COVID-19 and stock market return became negative but was not significant in other countries.

References

  1. Ahmar, A., and Val, E. (2020). SutteARIMA: Short-term forecasting method, a case: Covid-19 and stock market in Spain. Science of the Total Environment, 729, 138883.
  2. Al-Awadhi, A., Alsaifi, K., Al-Awadhi and A. Alhammadi, S. (2020). Death and contagious infectious diseases: Impact of the COVID-19 virus on stock market returns. Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Finance, 7, 100326.
  3. Ayittey, F., Ayittey, M., Chiwero, N., Dzuvor, C. (2020). Economic Impacts of Wuhan 2019-nCov on China and the World. Journal of Medical Virology, 1-3.
  4. Baker, S., Bloom, N. and Terry, S. (2020a). Using disasters to estimate the impact of uncertainty. Available at: http://people.bu.edu/stephent/files/BBT.pdf.
  5. Baker, S., Bloom, N., Davis, R., Kost, K., Sammon, M. and Viratyosin, T. (2020b). The unprecedented stock market impact of COVID-19. Working paper 26945. National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.
  6. Baker, S., Bloom, N., Davis, S. and Terry, S. (2020c). Covid-induced economic uncertainty. Working paper 26983. National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.
  7. Dietrich, A., Kuester, K., Muller, G. and Schoenle, R. (2020). News and uncertainty about COVID-19: Survey evidence and short run economic impact. Working Paper 20-12. Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland.
  8. Enders, W. (2004). Applied Econometric Time Series (2nd Ed.). USA: John Wiley and Sons.
  9. Estra, M., Park, D., Koutronous, E., Khan, A. and Tahir, M. (2020). The Impact of Massive Infections, and Contagious Diseases and its Impact on the Economic Performance. Available at: http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3527330.
  10. IMF (2019). World economic outlook. Available at: https://www.imf.org/external/datamapper/datasets/WEO/1.