ACCOUNTING STANDARDS • LEASE CAPITALISATION The Chartered Accountant • December 2022 • Vol. 71 • pp. 107–111 (Journal pp. 687–691)

Impact of Ind AS 116 on Aviation sector: A case study of Indigo Airlines

IA
Saumya Jain & Prof. C.P Gupta
Authors are academicians in University of Delhi. They may be reached at eboard@icai.in

Executive Summary & Research Highlights

“This article provides a brief overview of Ind AS 116 (Leases) introduced in India w.e.f 1st Apr, 2019 and its impact on the market leader of the aviation industry i.e InterGlobe Aviation Ltd. (Indigo Airlines). Ind AS 116 introduces a single lease accounting model doing away with the traditional classification of Operating & Finance Lease for the lessee. This standard is expected to have a significant impact on companies that have sizeable proportion of operating leases and hence, this study presents an analysis of the impact of this standard on key financial statement items & ratios of Indigo Airlines for the first-year post adoption of this standard i.e financial year (fy) 2019-20. The results show substantial impact on financial metrics with EBITDA rising by 398% & EBIT by 345% from previous financial year (pfy). Amongst the ratios analysed, the highest impact is found on Debt-Equity Ratio (284%) followed by Return on Equity (-288%).”

1. Introduction to Ind AS 116 (Leases)

Lease refers to a contract where one party (lessor) grants another party (lessee) the right to use an asset for a specific period of time in return for some consideration. Leasing is a commonly used financing solution which offers users flexibility in using assets without actually owning them. Lessees account for leases in their financial statements in accordance with the applicable accounting standard. Till 31st March, 2019, the applicable accounting standard for lease accounting in India was Ind AS 17, which required companies to classify leases as Operating or Finance, with the former being recognised in the financial statements of the lessee as lease rentals and the latter being capitalised.

The Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) notified Ind AS 116, the new lease accounting standard, and certain other amendments to Indian Accounting Standards (Ind AS) on 30th March 2019, coming into force on 1st April 2019. This standard is aligned with IFRS 16 and replaces the previous guidance under Ind AS 17 (Leases).

Ind AS 116 defines a lease as “a contract, or part of a contract, that conveys the right to use an asset (the underlying asset) for a period of time in exchange for consideration.” Crucially, Ind AS 116 eliminates the distinction between an operating lease and a finance lease for a lessee. Under Ind AS 116, lessees are required to recognise:

  • A Lease Liability: Reflecting the present value of future lease payments on the Balance Sheet.
  • A ‘Right-of-Use’ (ROU) Asset: Representing the right to use the underlying leased asset over the lease term.

This is a profound departure from Ind AS 17, under which lessees maintained operating leases completely off the Balance Sheet. In the Statement of Profit and Loss, lessees must now present depreciation on the ROU asset and interest expense on the lease liability, replacing the former single line item of operating lease rent expense.

In the Cash Flow Statement, cash payments for the principal portion of the lease liability and its related interest are classified within financing activities. Ind AS 116 does not substantially alter lessor accounting, retaining the operating versus finance classification. It also provides optional recognition exemptions for short-term leases (tenure of 12 months or less) and leases of low-value items.

2. Comparative Differences: Ind AS 116 vs. Ind AS 17

The following comparative framework outlines the core structural differences between Ind AS 116 and Ind AS 17:

Basis Ind AS 116 (Current Standard) Ind AS 17 (Superseded Standard)
Lessee Accounting Ind AS 116 does away with the distinction of operating & finance lease. It requires all leases with a lease term of more than 12 months to be recognised as ‘right of use’ asset and lease liability representing corresponding lease obligations. Ind AS 17 requires leases to be classified as operating or finance lease based on transfer of risk & rewards incidental to ownership of the leased asset.
Recognition of Expenses Under Ind AS 116, the lessee recognises depreciation on ROU assets & interest on lease liability in the Statement of Profit & Loss. Under Ind AS 17, a lessee recognises lease rentals on operating leases on straight line basis in the Statement of Profit & Loss.
Disclosure for Lessees Ind AS 116 requires detailed disclosure for lessees as compared to Ind AS 17. Ind AS 17 requires less disclosure for lessees as compared to Ind AS 116.
Lessor Accounting Requirements for lessor accounting are similar to guidance contained in Ind AS 17. A lessor continues to classify leases as operating lease and finance lease. A lessor continues to classify leases as operating lease and finance lease.
Disclosure for Lessors Ind AS 116 contains detailed disclosure requirements for lessor such as selling profit or loss, lease income on finance lease & additional qualitative & quantitative information about leasing activities. Ind AS 17 required less disclosure for lessors.

Global Macro Impact: It is estimated that listed companies worldwide using IFRS or US GAAP had almost US$3 trillion of off-Balance Sheet lease commitments. The need for this standard was felt owing to acute concerns relating to lack of transparency and disclosures. Capitalization enables investors and analysts to directly compare companies utilizing leasing models against those borrowing funds to acquire assets.

Figure 1: Lease Identification Procedure under Ind AS 116 (MCA Appendix B)
  1. Identified Asset Check: Is there an identified asset? If No → Contract does not contain a lease. If Yes → Proceed to benefit check.
  2. Economic Benefits Check: Does the customer have the right to obtain substantially all economic benefits from use throughout the period? If No → Contract does not contain a lease. If Yes → Proceed to direction check.
  3. Right to Direct Use: Who has the right to direct how and for what purpose the asset is used throughout the period?
    • If Customer → Contract contains a lease.
    • If Supplier → Contract does not contain a lease.
    • If Neither (predetermined) → Does customer operate the asset or did customer design the asset? If Yes → Contract contains a lease; if No → Contract does not contain a lease.

3. Aviation Sector Dynamics & Profile of InterGlobe Aviation Ltd. (IndiGo)

The global initiative to develop a new leases standard famously dates back to the statement by Sir David Tweedie, former Chairman of the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB), who quipped that “he wanted to fly in an aircraft that actually existed on an airline’s Balance Sheet.” In the airline industry, financing aircraft through off-Balance Sheet operating lease structures was an entrenched, universal practice. In addition, airport facilities essential to daily flight operations are typically leased from airport operators.

Under Ind AS 116, substantially all lease contracts must be brought onto the Balance Sheet. Furthermore, because many airline lease commitments are denominated in foreign currency (principally US-Dollars), airlines are exposed to significant foreign exchange volatility directly within their Profit and Loss statements.

Profile of Case Candidate: InterGlobe Aviation Ltd. (IndiGo)

  • Market Dominance: Domestic low-cost carrier operating since 2006; holds a commanding 53.5% passenger market share (as of October 2021).
  • Fleet Size: India’s largest airline with 279 aircraft as of August 2022.
  • Brand Standing: Ranked 33rd amongst India’s top 100 brands in FY 2021 by Campaign India.
  • Market Capitalization: Went public in 2015; free float market capitalization stood at Rs. 19,428.55 crore as on December 31, 2021.
  • Liquidity Buffer: Maintained a strong cash position of Rs. 1,70,679 million (including Rs. 56,207 million in free cash) as on June 30, 2021.
  • Pandemic Turbulence: Reported net loss of Rs. 31,742 million and negative EBITDAR of Rs. 13,602 million for the quarter ended June 2021 due to the second wave of COVID-19.

4. Standalone Balance Sheet & Profit & Loss Impact on IndiGo (FY 2019-20)

The company’s leased assets primarily encompass aircraft, spare engines, ground handling equipment, leasehold land, and corporate buildings. First-time adoption in FY 2019-20 triggered immediate structural shifts:

Standalone Balance Sheet Adjustments

  • Additional Lease Liabilities: Rs. 1,46,320.72 million recognized (an 81% surge from previous year).
  • New Right of Use (ROU) Assets: Rs. 93,942.04 million recognized on balance sheet (a 38% increase in total assets from PY).
  • Retained Earnings Hit: Reduced by Rs. 6,180.47 million representing the cumulative retrospective transition adjustment.

Standalone Statement of Profit & Loss Adjustments

  • Depreciation & Amortization: Increased by Rs. 32,140.33 million (a massive 423% increase from PY).
  • Finance Costs: Increased by Rs. 12,677.43 million due to interest accrued on lease liabilities (a 249% increase from PY).
  • Forex Revaluation Loss: Recognized Rs. 15,296.92 million loss on foreign-currency-denominated lease liabilities.
  • Operating Rental Savings: Aircraft, engine, and other rental expense dropped by Rs. 43,222.68 million due to capitalization.
  • Net Loss Before Tax Impact: Stood at Rs. 15,934.17 million directly attributable to Ind AS 116 (a 249% rise in pre-tax loss).

5. Empirical Findings: Key Variables & Ratios (FY 2018-19 to FY 2019-20)

The complete empirical dataset demonstrating the percentage changes in key financial variables and operational ratios from FY 2018-19 to FY 2019-20 is set out below:

Financial Statement Item / Ratio FY 2019-20 (Rs. Mn) FY 2018-19 (Rs. Mn) Percentage Change (%)
EBIT 16,007.82 3,599.16 +345%
EBITDA 55,743.95 11,194.96 +398%
Depreciation & Amortization (D&A) 39,736.13 7,595.80 +423%
Interest Expense 18,545.55 4,933.18 +276%
Capital Employed 2,48,270.13 1,25,263.52 +98%
Total Assets 4,20,484.56 2,50,117.34 +68%
Current Liabilities 1,64,105.12 79,984.43 +105%
Non-Current Liabilities 1,97,755.05 1,00,685.02 +96%
Net Worth 58,624.39 69,447.89 -16%
Operating Cash Flows 69,433.01 31,599.97 +120%
Financing Cash Flows -24,074.84 -5,921.58 +307% (outflow)
Current Ratio 1.37 2.26 -40%
Interest Coverage Ratio 0.86316232 0.729582136 +18%
Debt-Equity Ratio 3.23492901 0.843108264 +284%
Return on Assets (ROA) 0.03806994 0.014389886 +165%
Return on Equity (ROE) -0.0423303 0.022482325 -288%
Return on Capital Employed (ROCE) 0.06447743 0.028732707 +124%
Asset Turnover Ratio 0.85035229 1.139336121 -25%

6. In-Depth Analysis of Metric & Ratio Drivers

EBITDA & Operating Profit:

EBITDA rose 398% and EBIT rose 345% due to the reclassification of erstwhile operating lease rentals into depreciation (non-operating) and finance costs.

Debt-Equity Ratio (+284%):

Jumped from 0.84 to 3.23. Recognition of Rs. 1,46,320.72 million in lease liabilities combined with retrospective equity reduction inflated leverage dramatically.

Return on Equity (-288%):

Plunged from +2.25% into negative territory (-4.23%) driven by elevated net losses after tax caused by front-loaded interest and forex revaluation charges.

Operating vs Financing Cash Flows:

Operating cash flows rose 120% as lease rental outflows were moved to financing activities, causing financing cash outflows to expand by 307%.

Current Ratio (-40%):

Declined from 2.26 to 1.37 due to the inclusion of current lease liabilities payable within 12 months in current liabilities.

Asset Turnover (-25%):

Fell from 1.14 to 0.85 as total assets expanded by 68% following the on-balance-sheet capitalization of ROU assets.

7. Conclusion & Key Industry Takeaways

As evidenced by the analysis, Ind AS 116 fundamentally altered the balance sheet and profit and loss profile of Indigo Airlines. In FY 2018-19, prior to transition, operating lease aircraft rentals recognized in P&L stood at Rs. 49,994.49 million, representing 17% of total company expenses, while aircraft on finance lease recognized on the Balance Sheet amounted to Rs. 31,984.71 million (13% of Total Assets).

Following the mandatory adoption of Ind AS 116:

  • Right of Use Assets: Now constitute approximately 34% of Total Assets of the company.
  • Financial Liabilities Expansion: The proportion of financial liabilities to total liabilities escalated from 31% in 2018-19 to 52% in 2019-20.
  • Equity Depletion: Transition adjustments resulted in a 23% reduction in retained earnings.

“Thus, the analysis shows that capitalization of erstwhile operating leases changed the face of the balance sheet of the airlines which is the market leader in the aviation sector in India. The users of financial statements can now appreciate the full extent of future commitments of the company and compare it with other companies in the same sector irrespective of their financing structure for aircrafts and other facilities.” ■■■

References:
  1. (2016). Effects Analysis: IFRS 16 Leases. International Financial Reporting Standards Board (IASB).
  2. (2019). A study on the impact of lease capitalisation. PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC).
  3. (2019). Ind AS 116: Leases. Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA), Government of India.
  4. (2016). Ind AS 17: Leases. Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA), Government of India.
  5. IndiGo Investor Relations Reports & Official Annual Reports (FY 2018-19 & FY 2019-20).