“The concept of ‘insider trading’ is not new in India and one may also be aware of the regulations framed by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) for prevention of insider trading which are in place for more than a decade. Certain recent sweeping changes in the insider trading laws have vastly increased the ambit of coverage and some of these changes may have specific impact on Chartered Accountants as an employee or a partner working in a professional services firm. Read on to know more…”
Author: CA. Vinay K Nayak
Credentials: Member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
Contact: vinayknayak@gmail.com and eboard@icai.in
Published In: The Chartered Accountant, November 2019, Vol. 68, No. 5, pp. 67–71 (659–663)
The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) brought about significant updates in the insider trading regulations in December 2018 vide the SEBI (Prohibition of Insider Trading) (Amendment) Regulations, 2018 (w.e.f. April 01, 2019) (the ‘Regulations’). While these updates overhauled the Regulations in various aspects including but not limited to obligations of listed companies, amongst the most significant changes relevant for practicing chartered accountant professionals were the changes in relation to formalising the obligations of any professionals rendering services to listed companies such as auditors, accountancy firms, consultants etc. The purpose of this article is to attempt to give you an overview of the significant changes with regard to obligations of ‘fiduciaries’ with respect to preventing, controlling and monitoring of potential violations of the Regulations.
Let us begin by looking at the relevant clauses in this regard in the Regulations. Kindly draw your attention to the following clause which defines ‘fiduciaries’:
Explanation to Clause 9(2):
“Professional firms such as auditors, accountancy firms, law firms, analysts, insolvency professional entities, consultants, banks etc., assisting or advising listed companies shall be collectively referred to as ‘fiduciaries’ for the purpose of these regulations.”
While the erstwhile Regulations always did exercise jurisdiction over professional firms such as auditors, accountancy firms, consultants etc., assisting or advising listed companies, the obligations imposed were to an extent limited.
So What’s New?
Let us now look at how do the Regulations impact you or your professional services firm while rendering services to listed companies or other capital market participants.
a) Updated requirements for Code of Conduct (‘CoC’)
The first and foremost changes in the Regulations are in relation to the CoC. While the erstwhile Regulations did mandate persons ‘other than listed companies or market intermediaries’ to formulate a CoC governing trading in securities by their employees, the amended Regulations stretch these obligations to a considerable extent. The amended Regulations place an obligation on ‘fiduciaries’ to frame a CoC to not only govern trading in securities by their employees, but also specifically provide minimum standards to regulate, monitor and report trading by their ‘Designated Persons’ as further explained in Schedule C to the amended Regulations.
What are the aspects that the CoC needs to address:
- (i) Appointment of a Compliance Officer for prevention of insider trading.
- (ii) Establish clear protocols to ensure that all information is handled on a need to know basis.
- (iii) Extend the applicability of the CoC to even immediate relatives of ‘designated persons’.
- (iv) Pre-clearance of trades of ‘designated persons’ by the Compliance Officer after obtaining necessary declarations.
- (v) Sanctions and disciplinary actions for violations of the CoC.
- (vi) Disclosure of certain information by ‘designated persons’.
As one can see from the above, the minimum requirements for CoC by a fiduciary have been clearly enumerated in the amended Regulations. While the erstwhile Regulations mandated even agencies such as professional firms to adopt the same standards for the CoC as listed companies, the amended Regulations have laid out a clear distinction between CoC for listed companies and CoC for fiduciaries. While there is an element of overlap between the minimum standards for both the CoC, there is an element of distinction as well considering the different nature of listed entities versus the entities that render services to these listed entities. It is also pertinent to note that the CoC is intended to, and rightly so, establish a clear tone at the top to deter insider trading and deter dissemination of information which could potentially be misused by anyone else either within or outside the organisation to indulge in insider trading.
“It is also pertinent to note that the CoC is intended to, and rightly so, establish a clear tone at the top to deter insider trading and deter dissemination of information which could potentially be misused by anyone else either within or outside the organisation to indulge in insider trading.”
b) So who is a Designated Person?
You may have noticed that the phrase ‘designated person’ has been emphasised in several instances in the above paragraphs; and may be wondering what the relevance of the same is. Let us understand the term ‘designated person’ a little better.
The concept of ‘designated person’ was brought about for the first time in these Regulations w.e.f. April 1, 2019. While the erstwhile Regulations defined ‘insiders’ and ‘connected persons’, the updated Regulations chose to enhance the span of its coverage beyond ‘insiders’ and ‘connected persons’ by defining ‘designated persons’ as follows [Reference Clause 9(4)]:
Employees of such fiduciary who would have access to unpublished price sensitive information (UPSI) would be considered as ‘designated persons’. In addition, the following would also be considered as ‘designated persons’ for a fiduciary:
- All promoters who are individuals or investment companies.
- Employees can be designated persons on the basis of their functional role.
- CEO and employees up to two levels below CEO of fiduciary irrespective of their functional role or access to UPSI.
- Any support staff such as IT staff or secretarial staff who have access to UPSI.
Decision Logic: Ascertaining a ‘Designated Person’
For a fiduciary, obtaining a clear understanding of which individuals are considered as designated persons is of paramount importance, since a critical part of the compliance obligations in the amended Regulations, as applicable to a fiduciary, are defined with reference to designated persons and hence, any potentially incorrect exclusion of any individuals from being considered as designated persons may put the fiduciary at a significant risk of non-compliance with the Regulations. Organisations (fiduciaries) with a conservative mindset, may even consider it prudent to err on the side of caution and consider a more inclusive policy while determining individuals to be considered as designated persons.
Some Points to Ponder:
1) Application to Limited Liability Partnership (LLP) Firms:
As you have seen above, the CEO and employees up to two levels below CEO of the fiduciary irrespective of their functional role in the entity or ability to have access to unpublished price sensitive information are to be considered as designated persons. Considering the structure in a chartered accountancy limited liability partnership (LLP) firm, where the firm is constituted by individuals as partners, the concept of a CEO may not apply in its true sense.
In this scenario it may be relevant to divert our attention to the provisions of the Limited Liability Act, 2008 (the LLP Act) which defines a ‘designated persons’ (not to be confused with designated persons as defined under the Regulations). The LLP Act prescribes that every limited liability partnership shall have at least two designated partners who are individuals and also states that a designated partner shall be responsible for all acts, matters and things as are required to be done by the limited liability partnership in respect of compliance of the provisions of the LLP Act. In the absence of a ‘CEO’, should a designated partner of a LLP firm be considered as ‘CEO equivalent’; and consequently should the requirement for employees at ‘two levels below the CEO’ be considered accordingly? The Regulations do not clarify the position at the moment.
2) Ring-Fencing of Teams in Multi-Client Practice Firms:
Another relevant aspect worth exploring is to examine the scenario of a chartered accountancy firm rendering professional services such as audit or consultancy to its various listed clients. It is not unusual to find that in case of audit firms, teams working on either a particular client or a particular industry are segregated by specialisation of skillsets and typically would not have access to UPSI related to projects in which they are not involved. In such a scenario, it is worth questioning whether these individuals would be considered as designated persons even for those listed clients for whom they do not have access to UPSI merely because of the fact that they are up to two levels below the ‘CEO’ level.
“A new clause 9A (Institutional Mechanism for Prevention of Insider Trading) has been inserted by the amended Regulations which elaborate on the various forms of internal control mechanisms expected from a listed company, intermediary or a fiduciary.”
c) Implement Internal Controls to Prevent Insider Trading
Now we come to another one of the critical requirements with regard to implementation of internal controls by a fiduciary. A new clause 9A (Institutional Mechanism for Prevention of Insider Trading) has been inserted by the amended Regulations which elaborate on the various forms of internal control mechanisms expected from a listed company, intermediary or a fiduciary.
Certain obligations have been placed on fiduciaries to put in place internal controls to ensure compliance with regulations including the following:
- (i) Identification of all unpublished price sensitive information and maintaining its confidentiality;
- (ii) Placing restrictions on communication of UPSI;
- (iii) Confidentiality agreements with employees having access to UPSI;
- (iv) Periodic review of these internal controls;
- (v) Governing body of such fiduciary to ensure compliance with all the provisions of the Regulations and shall review compliance of such internal control system.
The Regulations also place certain additional responsibilities for an internal control system on the listed company which, for some reason, have not been made applicable to the fiduciary namely (i) formulation of policies and procedures of conducting inquiries into leakage of UPSI; and (ii) establishing a whistle-blower policy to enable employees to report instances of leakage of UPSI.
Certain Good Practices to Consider While Implementing an Internal Control System:
The following examples may be helpful for a fiduciary to consider while implementing an internal control system in order to comply with the Regulations:
- (i) Considering extending the code of conduct to third parties or contract staff working with the fiduciary as long as they have access to UPSI;
- (ii) Consider implementing information technology based monitoring controls which help in detecting sharing of information by employees to external storage medium or personal email domains;
- (iii) Annual training to all employees and contract staff on prevention of insider trading;
- (iv) Embed confidentiality clauses as part of all employment contracts;
- (v) Roll-out periodic communication campaigns to reinforce the requirements of the Regulations;
- (vi) Consider performing periodic verification of employee’s securities trading records on a sample basis to ensure that the employees have not undertaken any trading in securities of listed companies for which they have had access to UPSI;
- (vii) Emphasise the importance of maintaining a clean-desk policy which will reinforce messages on securing and taking care of electronic assets such as laptops and portable storage medium and physical papers; and
- (viii) Strict disciplinary policy to deal with any exceptions.
d) Implement ‘Digital Database’ for Information on Designated Persons
The Regulations w.e.f. April 1, 2019 has mandated every listed company to maintain a structured ‘digital database’ containing certain information (names and PAN) of such persons or entities with whom UPSI is shared under the Regulations. SEBI has now revised the ‘Guidance Note on SEBI (Prohibition of Insider Trading) Regulations, 2015’ on July 5, 2019 to clarify that this requirement of digital database shall now also apply to fiduciaries (which was not hitherto the case).
Let us now contrast this with another similar requirement applicable to a fiduciary, under the Regulations (Schedule C), which require all designated persons of the fiduciary to disclose the following to the fiduciary on an annual basis or as and when information changes:
- (i) Names of educational institutions from which the designated person has graduated;
- (ii) Names of past employers of the designated person;
- (iii) Name and PAN of immediate relatives of the designated person;
- (iv) Name and PAN of persons with whom a material financial relationship is shared;
- (v) All phone numbers of the above two categories of persons.
In light of this requirement, it becomes imperative for a fiduciary to have a robust digital system to capture all of the above information on a timely basis and also ensure that the digital data is not tampered with and has adequate audit logs enabled.
Some Clarifications:
- 1) Presumption Regarding Spouse: A spouse, even if he/she is financially independent and does not consult the designated person while taking trading decisions, is presumed to be an ‘immediate relative’, unless rebutted so [qs.11 in the Guidance Note issued by SEBI dated 24 August 2015].
- 2) Absence of Lower Age Limit: The Regulations also do not seem to provide any lower age limit to be considered by designated persons while disclosing name, PAN or contact numbers of designated persons. Hence, this disclosure requirement may also be applicable to minor dependents of the designated persons.
- 3) Due Notice under Clause 3(2B): Clause 3(2B) of the Regulations require that all listed companies are now required to give ‘due notice’ to all insiders to maintain confidentiality of UPSI. It does not seem to be clear at this moment as to what should be the approach adopted by a fiduciary with respect to ascertaining designated persons when a listed company for any reasons fails to provide a due notice to the fiduciary.
- 4) Point-in-Time Declaration: It is also pertinent to note that the declaration with regard to UPSI is not specific to any financial year and is at a ‘point in time’ irrespective of the financial year to which the information relates – with the only condition being that the information should constitute UPSI.
“Ensure that information with respect to designated persons to be maintained by the fiduciary (e.g. PAN, mobile number, etc.) is revisited at annual interval or at every occasion of change.”
9-Pronged Approaches for Fiduciaries under the Regulations
To summarise this article, the following 9 pronged approaches may be helpful for a fiduciary to appropriately frame a response to its obligations under the Regulations:
- a) Implement a comprehensive code of conduct for prevention of insider trading and consider making it applicable for third party contractors working with the fiduciary and who will have access to UPSI;
- b) Roll out a clearly defined policy for ascertaining who are designated persons with well laid out parameters;
- c) Ensure a well-controlled mechanism for dissemination of information considered as UPSI;
- d) Do keep an eye out for new team members inducted on a sensitive project (entailing access to UPSI) and subsequently ensure that these newly on-boarded team members are appropriately considered as designated persons;
- e) Consider appointing a single point of contact within the project team who will be responsible for ensuring that the list of designated persons for any project is kept current and updated;
- f) Ensure that information with respect to designated persons to be maintained by the fiduciary (e.g. PAN, mobile number etc.) is revisited at annual interval or at every occasion of change;
- g) Ensure a comprehensive training to all staff on the insider trading provisions;
- h) Encourage project team members to be vigilant in the course of their work to any instances of potential leakage of UPSI;
- i) Consider implementing an automated mechanism for obtaining confirmations from employees on an annual basis that they have complied with all provisions of the Regulations and that the declarations provided by them continue to be current.
“We shall never know all the good that a simple smile can do.” — Mother Teresa