The Chartered Accountant • Journal of ICAI March 2022 • Vol. 70 • No. 9 • pp. 67–78 (Journal pp. 1107–1118)
Union Budget 2022-23

Personal and Corporate Taxation Proposals of Budget 2022

BB

CA. B D Bhide

Member of ICAI • Contact: bdbhide@gmail.com

KP

CA. Kishor Phadke

Member of ICAI • Contact: eboard@icai.in

“This note takes cognizance of certain amendments proposed by Finance Bill 2022 to existing provisions of Income Tax Act particularly those affecting the corporates. It doesn’t deal with amendments applicable to corporates who are registered with CIT(Exemption) U/Sec.12AA/ 12AB of the Income Tax Act. Read on…”

This exhaustive critique explores 29 vital corporate and personal tax amendments across substantive, procedural, withholding, and dispute resolution provisions, examining their underlying rationale, drafting implications, and contentious legal friction points.

1. Virtual Digital Assets / Crypto Currency: Section 2(47A) & Section 115BBH

Section 2 deals with definitions of terms referred to in the Income Tax Act under various sections. A new clause, sub-section 2(47A), has been inserted with effect from 1st April 2022, defining “Virtual Digital Asset” (VDA), generally known in popular parlance as ‘Crypto Currency’. Income from such VDAs is to be taxed at a flat rate of 30% (plus applicable surcharge and cess) under newly inserted Section 115BBH.

Recognition of an evolving asset class is a typical welcome measure. Yet, a separate, segregated taxation mechanism leads to serious conceptual and equity challenges:

  • Redundancy of Complex Definition: “Property” is a word of widest import under jurisprudence and general law. A VDA is fundamentally a form of property. Was there any real legal necessity to enact a convoluted definition under Section 2(47A)?
  • Past Taxability Uncertainty: Does the enactment of a separate statutory taxation regime now imply that VDA transfers were free from taxation in yester-years?
  • Harsh Disallowance of Intra-Asset Loss Set-Off: Loss incurred in one VDA deal ought to be eligible for set-off against gains in another VDA deal, at least within the same financial year! Denying intra-asset set-off violates the core canon of horizontal equity.
  • Exclusion of Capital Gain Concessions: VDAs are removed from the beneficial ambit of Long Term Capital Assets (Sections 112 and 112A), denying indexation benefits. Transfers are subject to 1% TDS under Section 194S w.e.f. 1st July 2022, posing grave compliance friction when counterparty identity is unknown.

2. Amendment to Section 14A: Overruling the “No Exempt Income, No Disallowance” Doctrine

Section 14A restricts the scope of expenditure incurred for earning exempt income (incomes dealt with under Section 10). The section has been a perpetual hotbed of tax litigation since its inception. With prior legislative amendments abolishing dividend exemptions and taxing long-term capital gains on listed equities, the practical field of triggering Section 14A had substantially narrowed.

The Non-Obstante Amendment & Judicial Overrule

The proposed amendment begins with a non-obstante clause and provides that no deduction of expenditure shall be allowed in respect of exempt income whether such income has accrued, arisen, or been received, or not received during the relevant financial year.

This legislative insertion directly overrules a long line of binding High Court and Supreme Court judgments which settled that if no exempt income was actually earned or received during the year, no notional disallowance under Section 14A could be made. Proposed to operate from AY 2022-23 onwards, it departs from the stated sovereign policy of avoiding retrospective or retroactive tax burdens.

Key Issue Arising: Is this amendment to be applied where there is miniscule exempt income, or strictly restricted to scenarios where there is zero exempt income at all?

3. Amendment to Section 37: Disallowance of Freebies, Foreign Violations & Compounding Fees

Section 37(1) grants deduction of general business expenditure not covered under Sections 30 to 36, barring personal expenses, capital CSR outlays, and expenses incurred for any purpose which is an offence or prohibited by law.

Enlarged Scope of Deemed Offences under Explanation 3 to Section 37(1)

Pending extensive constitutional and appellate litigation on what constitutes an ‘offence’, Finance Bill 2022 injects an aggressive framework:

  • Deemed Offences: Medical freebies, gifts, travel, and hospitality extended by pharmaceutical and allied healthcare companies to medical practitioners (in breach of Medical Council regulations) are statutorily deemed as prohibited offences.
  • Extraterritorial Application: Expenditure incurred in violation of any foreign law or regulation is explicitly brought within the disallowance net.
  • Compounding Fees Disallowed: Settlement sums or compounding amounts paid under statutory provisions to compound offences are categorized as prohibited expenditure.

Critical Legal Friction: Authors observe: Can something be deemed an offence for tax disallowance when regulatory enactments are silent or treat it as a curable administrative irregularity? How can the lawful compounding of an offence be equated with the offence itself?

4. Amendment to Section 40(a)(ii): Retrospective Disallowance of Education Cess from 2005

Section 40(a)(ii) provides that any rate or tax levied on profits or gains of business shall not be deductible. In recent years, multiple High Courts and Appellate Tribunals upheld that ‘Education Cess’ and ‘Secondary & Higher Education Cess’ did not constitute ‘tax’ and were therefore allowable business deductions under Section 37(1).

Insertion of Explanation 3 with Retrospective Effect from 1st April 2005

Finance Bill 2022 inserts Explanation 3 to Section 40(a)(ii) stating that “for the removal of doubts, it is hereby clarified that the term ‘tax’ shall include and shall be deemed to have always included any surcharge or cess, by whatever name called, on such tax”.

The Constitutional Dilemma: This amendment operates with massive retrospective effect from 1st April 2005. Under the parent section, tax is not eligible for deduction because it is assessed as a proportion of profits. Education cess is assessed as a percentage of tax, not profits. Furthermore, past appellate decisions granting deduction up to AY 2021-22 will face reopening or rectification proceedings.

5. Amendment to Section 43B: Conversion of Interest into Debentures Deemed Non-Payment

Section 43B restricts deductions to actual payment. Explanations 3C, 3CA, and 3D provide that conversion of unpaid interest into a loan or borrowing does not constitute payment in respect of financial institutions (43B(d)), NBFCs (43B(da)), and banks (43B(e)).

Debentures & Debt Instruments Brought under Section 43B

Under the proposed amendment, if the due date for payment of interest liability is deferred to a future date by conversion into a “Debenture” or “any other instrument”, the deduction will be allowed only upon actual redemption or cash payment thereof.

  • Structural Asymmetry: Lending institutions/banks are bound to recognize and offer the debenture interest as income upon allotment, yet the borrower is denied deduction, creating timing distortion and tax mismatch.
  • Absence of Redemption Mechanism: The statute omits any specific mechanism for claiming deduction upon future staggered redemption.
  • Conversion Complexities: Acute complexities will arise where debentures are subsequently converted into equity shares.

6. Amendment to Section 50: Removal of Goodwill as a Deemed Transfer

Following Finance Act 2021 which stripped Goodwill of depreciation under Section 32, Finance Bill 2022 amends Section 50 (computation of capital gains in depreciable assets):

The amendment deals with the removal of ‘Goodwill of a business or profession’ from the ‘block of assets’ in accordance with sub-item (B) of item (ii) of sub-clause (c) of clause (6) of section 43, treating such removal as a deemed transfer.

Since the substantive disentitlement of depreciation took effect from AY 2021-22, this computational amendment operates retrospectively from 1st April 2021, applying to Assessment Year 2021-22 and subsequent years.

7. Amendment to Section 68: Onus to Prove “Source of Source” for Cash Credits

Section 68 taxes unexplained cash credits appearing in the books of account. Historically, the assessee was required to discharge the three-fold burden: (1) identity of creditor, (2) creditworthiness of creditor, and (3) genuineness of the transaction.

The New Burden: Explaining the Creditor’s Underlying Source

The proposed amendment severely burdens the assessee to prove the source of such credits in the hands of the person in whose name the entry is recorded to the satisfaction of the Assessing Officer (effective from AY 2023-24 onwards).

Statutory Carve-Out: Regulated investment entities—specifically Venture Capital Funds (VCFs) and Venture Capital Companies (VCCs) registered with SEBI—are exempt from proving the source of source.

Friction & Double Additions: Forces normal business assessees to act as investigative agencies before accepting loan funds or trade credits. Failure could trigger double additions: under Section 68 in the hands of the receiver, and under Section 69 in the hands of the lender!

8. Insertion of Section 79A: Bar on Set-Off of Losses against Search/Survey Income

Newly inserted Section 79A provides that ‘No set-off of losses consequent to search, requisition and survey’ shall be permissible.

Where additional income is disclosed or assessed pursuant to a search initiated under Section 132/132A or survey conducted under Section 133A (excluding survey under Section 133A(2A)), no set-off of brought-forward losses or unabsorbed depreciation shall be allowed against such undisclosed income (effective from AY 2022-23 onwards).

9. Corporate Tax Concessions, Anti-Avoidance & Foreign Dividend Parity

Section 80-IAC Start-Up Holiday Extension

Turnover limit of Rs. 100 crore and Inter-Ministerial Board certification. Period of eligible incorporation extended by one full year up to 31st March 2023 to alleviate pandemic disruptions.

Section 115BAB Concessional 15% Manufacturing Rate

For new domestic manufacturing companies registered on or after 1st October 2019. The deadline to commence commercial manufacture or production is extended by one year to 31st March 2024.

Section 94 Bonus Stripping on Securities & InvIT/REIT/AIFs

Anti-avoidance provisions of Section 94(8) are expanded to encompass securities (equity shares) and units of Infrastructure Investment Trusts (InvITs), Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs), and Alternative Investment Funds (AIFs) w.e.f. AY 2023-24.

Section 115BBD Deletion: Foreign Dividend Parity

Concessional 15% rate on dividends received by Indian companies from specified foreign companies (≥26% shareholding) is deleted. Foreign dividends will now be taxed at normal corporate rates, establishing parity with domestic dividends w.e.f. AY 2023-24.

10. Amendments in Search & Seizure: Sections 132 and 132B

For searches initiated after 1st April 2021, the erstwhile search assessment regime under Sections 153A and 153C was dismantled.

Consequential amendments are enacted in Section 132 and Section 132B for holding books of account or other seized assets. Releasing or retaining seized records will now be anchored strictly to orders of assessment or reassessment passed under Section 143(3), Section 144, or Section 147 (effective 1st April 2022).

11. The Updated Return Framework: Section 139(8A), Section 139(9) & Section 140B

Finance Bill 2022 introduces a landmark compliance window by inserting sub-section (8A) in Section 139, allowing assessees to file an Updated Return of Income within 24 months from the end of the relevant assessment year to correct omissions and under-reported income.

Statutory Bar: When an Updated Return CANNOT be Filed

  1. Cannot be filed if it results in reducing total loss returned earlier, reducing tax liability, or increasing refund;
  2. Cannot be filed sequel to a search initiated u/s 132/132A or survey conducted u/s 133A;
  3. Cannot be filed if notice issued intimating that money, bullion, jewellery, or books seized/requisitioned belong to the person;
  4. Cannot be filed if an updated return has already been furnished once for that assessment year;
  5. Cannot be filed where any assessment, reassessment, recomputation, or revision is pending or completed;
  6. Cannot be filed where AO possesses information under PMLA 2002, Black Money Act 2015, Benami Property Act 1988, or SAFEMA 1976 and communicated to assessee;
  7. Cannot be filed where information received under DTAA / Tax Exchange Agreements has been communicated to the assessee;
  8. Cannot be filed where prosecution proceedings have been initiated under Chapter XXII (Sections 275A to 280D);
  9. Cannot be filed for two preceding assessment years in search/survey cases;
  10. Cannot be filed by any notified class of persons.

Tax on Updated Return under Section 140B & Defective Return Linkage u/s 139(9)

Under Section 139(9), an updated return shall be treated as defective unless accompanied by proof of payment of tax, additional tax, interest, and fee computed under Section 140B:

Filing Window Additional Tax Rate Base for Additional Tax Computation
Within 12 Months from end of relevant AY 25% Aggregate of tax and interest payable on the additional income returned (including surcharge and cess).
Between 12 to 24 Months from end of relevant AY 50% Aggregate of tax and interest payable on the additional income returned (including surcharge and cess).

Interest Liability (Sections 234A, 234B & 234C): Additional tax is paid alongside mandatory interest under Section 234A (on total income returned), Section 234B (shortfall of advance tax), and Section 234C. Under Section 153, the time limit for the department to complete assessment of an updated return is 9 months from the end of the financial year in which the updated return is furnished.

12. Amendment to Section 144B: Omission of the “Non-Est” Sub-Section (9)

Section 144B governs the procedure for Faceless Assessments. Previously, sub-section (9) contained a vital taxpayer safeguard: if an assessment order was passed in deviation from the statutory faceless procedure, such order was declared non-est (void ab initio).

Severe Dilution of Procedural Safeguards

Finance Bill 2022 prescribes a revamped faceless workflow with Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) to be issued by CBDT, while omitting sub-section (9). The authors critique this omission as a potential cause of serious injustice: taxpayers will no longer have the automatic remedy of having arbitrary procedural deviations declared non-est. Furthermore, because internal electronic communications at the back-end are inaccessible to taxpayers, proving non-adherence to SOPs will be exceptionally arduous.

13. Reassessment Overhaul: Sections 148, 148A, 148B, 149 & 153B

The revamped reassessment regime enacted in Finance Act 2021 underwent substantial procedural recalibrations in Finance Bill 2022:

Section 148 & 148A Carve-Outs

No separate approval required to issue notice u/s 148 where an order u/s 148A(d) is passed with prior approval. Inquiries under Section 148A are dispensed with where information is received under faceless collection schemes (Section 135A).

New Section 148B Prior Approvals

In search/survey assessments, no order shall be passed by an AO below rank of Joint Commissioner without prior supervisory approval of Additional/Joint Commissioner or Director.

Section 149(1)(b) Scope Enlargement

Reopening beyond 3 years up to 10 years expanded from income represented in the form of an asset to also include expenditure incurred in relation to an event/occasion, or entries in books amounting to Rs. 50 lakh or more.

Section 149(1A) Multi-Year Notices

Where expenditure or asset investment of Rs. 50 lakh+ spans across more than one previous year, notices u/s 148 can be issued for every such assessment year within the 10-year period.

14. Dispute Management, IBC Harmonization & Business Reorganisation

Key Institutional and Dispute Reforms

  • New Section 156A (Demand Modification under IBC): Where tax demands issued under Section 156 are subsequently reduced or modified by an order of the NCLT Adjudicating Authority under Section 31 of IBC 2016, NCLAT, or the Supreme Court, the Assessing Officer is statutorily mandated to modify the demand notice accordingly.
  • New Section 158AB (Avoiding Repetitive Revenue Appeals): Replaces Section 158AA. Where an identical question of law is pending before the jurisdictional High Court or Supreme Court in any assessee’s case, the collegium can direct the Pr. CIT not to file repetitive appeals before ITAT/High Court, deferring filings until the question of law is finally decided.
  • Section 170(2A) & New Section 170A (Business Reorganisation): Where business restructuring (merger/demerger) is sub judice before NCLT/court, predecessor and successor remain governed for intervening proceedings. Upon final sanction, successor entity must furnish a modified return of income within 6 months from the end of the month of the sanction order.
  • Section 179 (Director Liability Clarification): Resolves the misleading title ‘Liability of directors of private company in liquidation’ by clarifying that directors are jointly and severally liable for unpaid taxes of a private company whether the company is under liquidation or not.

15. Enhanced Withholding Tax Ambit: Sections 194-IA, 194R, 201/206C & 239A

Section 194-IA: Stamp Duty Value Threshold

1% TDS on immovable property transfer exceeding Rs. 50 lakh must now be deducted on the higher of actual consideration or Stamp Duty Value (SDV) w.e.f. 1st April 2022.

New Section 194R: 10% TDS on Business Perquisites

Enforces 10% TDS on value of non-monetary benefits or perquisites arising from business/profession u/s 28(iv) exceeding Rs. 20,000 per financial year w.e.f. 1st July 2022.

Section 201 / 206C: Statutory Default Interest

Explicit liability on assessees to pay interest determined by the AO associated with failure to deduct, collect, or pay TDS/TCS obligations w.e.f. 1st April 2022.

New Section 239A: Refund on Section 195 Withholding

Where tax on remittance to a non-resident is paid under protest, payer can apply for refund u/s 239A before AO within 30 days. AO passes order within 6 months, appealable to CIT(A) u/s 246A(1)(ia).

16. Conclusion & Professional Impact

The corporate and personal direct tax proposals of Budget 2022 represent a dual-track strategy: offering voluntary compliance avenues through Section 139(8A) Updated Returns and relief extensions for new manufacturing units and start-ups, while simultaneously shutting down aggressive tax avoidance windows.

However, retrospective disallowances of Education Cess from 2005, the statutory expansion of Section 14A to scenarios with zero exempt income, and shifting the onus of proving the source of source under Section 68 will impose heavy compliance and litigation burdens on businesses.

Chartered Accountants play an essential role in auditing transaction trails, evaluating withholding exposures under Sections 194S and 194R, guiding clients on the updated return window under Section 140B, and representing assessees through restructured faceless and reassessment proceedings.

The Chartered Accountant • Journal of The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI)
March 2022 Issue • Vol. 70 • No. 9 • pp. 67–78 (Journal pp. 1107–1118)
Authors may be reached at: bdbhide@gmail.com and eboard@icai.in