Finance

Re-engaging with Financial Planning and Analysis in Professional Perspective: An Overview

CA. Saumil S. Chogle • The Chartered Accountant, April 2019 • pp. 66–70 (Journal pp. 1446–1450)
The author is a member of the ICAI. He can be reached at saumil.chogle@gmail.com or eboard@icai.in

Today many Chartered Accountants in Corporates are experts in Financial Planning & Analysis (FP&A) department. Business leaders and Chartered Accountants in FP&A department have a lot to do to reset their working relationship. Effective partnership starts when leaders take defined steps to rethink how they work together. When this happens, companies will have an additional source of competitive advantage. Read on…

The biggest investment of Chartered Accountants in finance function is in the field of analysis. Leaders, today, use financial analysis for guidance in budget, research & development and capital investments and accordingly are presented with daily/weekly financial analysis from Business Intelligence Group, Corporate Finance and Business Finance Team. Many CFOs expect the Chartered Accountants (finance function) to be the analytic expert – guiding and advising the business decisions. Towards this end, they create the Financial Planning & Analysis (FP&A) team. This team is dedicated to provide improvised and specialised analysis for larger strategic analysis.

However, a lot of analyses are found to be not resulting in better decision making despite the midnight excel marathons resulting in under performance of finance’s biggest investment. As per a survey of 2,305 business leaders conducted recently, 25% of the decisions with financial implications are made without financial analysis.

Perhaps worst, a survey of 635 FP&A directors reported that 61% of the decision makers selectively choose analytics to validate their gut feeling. Most companies are losing up to 1% of revenue due to misuse of financial analysis during major strategic decisions. The misuse of analysis happens when decision makers:

  • Don’t use financial analysis: This could be because the analysis is brought in late to the table and hence is only treated as a “check-in-the-box” exercise.
  • Misinterpret financial analysis: Lack of analytical judgment on the part of the decision maker can lead to misinterpretation.
  • Selectively use financial analysis to support their decisions: Analysis is “cherry-picked” to align it to their preordained conclusion. In this case, decision makers just need data points to validate their well-founded initiatives.

Is FP&A Going Wrong?

Many Chartered Accountants may attribute the misuse of analysis to organisation culture which is beyond their control; however, there is more to it. Decision makers’ use of financial analysis is within our control.

If Finance and its decision partners each contribute to the problem, they both own the solution. Financial analysis without decision-maker contribution lacks the detailed, business-level knowledge to make an impact, and business analysis without the oversight of a skilled analyst frequently lacks the financial acumen to factor in the key risks to profitability.

The answer is not for executives to resist financial checks and balances on decisions, nor is it for Chartered Accountants to push an oversight agenda into every corner of the organisation. Rather, both parties must redefine their working relationship, moving from a model of analytical support to one of joint decision making.

Although Chartered Accountants can fix flaws in how it designs, conducts and delivers analysis, it cannot do so effectively without input from business leaders. Decision makers need to bring in their deep business knowledge to bear and express their unique preference. Both producers and consumers of analysis need to pursue their shared goal; the best possible business decision.

Although Chartered Accountants can fix flaws in how it designs, conducts and delivers analysis, it cannot do so effectively without input from business leaders. Decision makers need to bring in their deep business knowledge to bear and express their unique preference. Both producers and consumers of analysis need to pursue their shared goal; the best possible business decision.

To get decision makers to reengage with financial analysis and to realign the producers and consumers of financial analysis for better decisions, executives need to do three things:

  1. Create a shared view of business objectives and drivers
  2. Enhance routine reporting with dialogue and discussion
  3. Reorient business and finance roles for joint decision making

1. Create a Shared View of Business Objectives and Drivers

When financial analysis lacks an intuitive view of what drives the business, decision makers are discouraged from using it, avoiding meetings with finance analysts and choosing not to use Finance’s work in their decision processes.

Once the team reaches a shared understanding of the business goals, assumptions, and drivers, the analysis team can begin creating prototype reports and managing conversations. This will lead to a more aligned decision making teams – able to focus on driving business results, not debating financial methods and measures. With a better financial analysis product in hand, teams can focus more on using financial reports’ working together to interpret the analysis, debate solutions, and make decisions.

Knowing the past and understanding the trends makes FP&A a credible partner in discussion about the feasibility of the plan. It is, therefore, good if FP&A is involved during the phase when plans are being built. People can be very sensitive when challenged, and to overcome the resistance it is helpful to keep the conversation factual.

For situations where plans had already been defined and the main objective is to secure that they materialise, FP&A should continuously track the progress. Having the chance to see a big picture gives opportunity to identify safety measures:

  • If sales are falling behind, which products could be pushed (i.e. temporary promotions, price assessment), which costs could potentially be reduced, which activities could be rescheduled?
  • If sales of the current period are exceeding the target, is there a risk for (some of) the next periods or the overall market situation is more favourable?
  • If there are significant one-time impacts, results should be assessed from the neutral perspective, excluding those non-standard events
  • If business is done in different markets, are there opportunities to off-set lower volume in one country with the upsides in another?
  • If spending is exceeding the budget, follow up with the budget owners and assess which costs are indeed necessary. Is there a link between increased spending and sales, and would there be a top-line upside?
  • If spending is behind the schedule, is it just a temporary situation, or at least part of the funds can be used for other activities or released to protect profitability?

Besides suggestions for tactical and operational measures, FP&A can contribute in the process of defining strategic responses – recognising the trends enables giving rational proposals about the changes in price positioning, portfolio, business models.

2. Enhance Routine Reporting with Dialogue and Discussion

Although most managers trust Chartered Accountants to govern financial data, a large number of them believe that the same people can provide them with insightful commentary on what is occurring in their business and why, especially when business occurs outside the financial reporting calendar.

When asked to rate their finance partners on the work Finance performs for them, business leaders give Chartered Accountants high marks for its traditional governance and risk-related controls. To shift financial analysis from passive, standardised reporting to more engaging and relevant guidance, progressive firms are changing the underlying analytical approaches in their reports, embedding more opinion and redesigning reports to be more accessible.

Although most managers trust Chartered Accountants to govern financial data, a large number of them believe that the same people can provide them with insightful commentary on what is occurring in their business and why, especially when business occurs outside the financial reporting calendar.

FP&A team operates best when cooperating with other functions. Managing the relationship with colleagues from other departments is important as it secures the flow of vital information and protects the interests of the company. As much as possible FP&A should maintain its professional position, staying away from internal politics.

Take a typical departmental budget report that compares actual with plan. These provide managers with a financial perspective of ‘performance’ that, for example, shows customer support expense as being 40% over budget. The real question is whether this overspend is ‘good’ or ‘bad’ so that we can assess the right response. In practice this variance is probably highlighted in ‘red’ and so an assumption has already been made.

In the above it’s obvious that we don’t have enough information to decide – so what should that supporting information be? Being able to ‘drill down’ to more detailed levels of data may help but the chances are that even this will not be enough.

The key to the usefulness of any report is to first establish its purpose. Why it is needed and what decisions must it be able to support. Importantly, those decisions must be aligned with corporate strategy or there may be unintended consequences. For example, we could deem that sticking to the budget is very important and so it’s easy to make the decision to cut down expenses to bring the department back in line with the budget. However, that may result in poor customer support that in turn will eventually affect sales and hence profitability in the future.

So, let’s go back to our example – in fact for any typical departmental report that shows actual performance against budget. What’s its real purpose? I doubt if it is to keep a department from spending too much in which case it’s too late. The trouble is that most budget reports are entirely focused on finance along with supporting data showing even more levels of financial detail. The reason for this is the general ledger from which these reports are produced. These tend to only hold financial transactions, which isn’t enough for most management purposes.

For any report and its key measures to be of real value, i.e. to achieve its purpose, it must always be presented in the context of the decisions it was designed to support. That context will typically come in the form of other measures. So, in the above example let’s set the following purpose:

To ensure that the customer support department can manage the level of sales being forecast at the lowest possible cost, we can categorise the context measures under the following headings.

Supporting detail:

  • What level of activity was involved in generating the actual expense?
  • Was that activity in line with the sales generated?
  • Have any of the assumptions in terms of the level of activity and associated cost made when setting the budget, changed?

Strategic Outcomes:

  • What impact does this level of activity have on strategic objectives?
  • If the activity was to be put back in line with the budget, how would our strategic objectives be affected in the future?

Financial implications:

  • Is this expense directly related to the revenue generated?
  • What impact does this expense have on profitability and our other financial goals?

Competitor / market view:

  • How does this level of expense compare with competitors?

Trends:

For each of the above we need to know:

  • In terms of finances, is this variance an exception or are things getting better or worse?
  • What will be the impact on finances if this trend on expense continues?

Risk:

  • What level of risk as we run if we were to ignore this variance?

Not all the data that answers these questions will exist or be easy to access, but that doesn’t mean it can be ignored. In these cases, estimates will need to be made.

Once all this data has been assessed, ideas can be generated as to the decisions that should be made. This could include using more experienced staff to support sales; additional training; adopting technologies that could help; outsourcing the whole department; or just realising that the level is the right one and budgets may need to be reset.

The chances are that unless you are a very small organisation, you will need to use a modern FP&A analytic system to bring this data together and present it in a form that can be easily understood and from which decisions can be made. Similarly, the potential solutions will need to be modelled to assess whether a change will help in both the short and long-term.

Make financial analysis and reports more engaging by building in more commentary and opinion – Managers consume most financial analysis in scheduled, invariant, routine and methodical reports. They have little time to read between the lines to uncover novel insights or issues of concern. Unless reports show large variances from anticipated results, many business managers are inclined to “sleepwalk” through inboxes brimming with detailed financial accounts of performance.

Building reports that go beyond routine analysis to include discussions of emerging issues or at risk assumptions can dramatically increase their relevance and use.

Make financial analysis more accessible to decision makers – Finally, sometimes even seemingly simple steps to make financial analysis more readily available can dramatically increase its value – and therefore its use in decision making and management.

The spreadsheet or PDF format of analysis reports is highly context-specific: they take a long time to read and must be viewed on a desktop computer. But if managers are mobile, moving from office to office, the slow medium limits their access.

Some companies are using simple, low-tech solutions such as voice mail-based reporting to make financial analysis more accessible. They ‘re adapting to the busy schedules of their decision makers. They are setting up a cheap and secure voice mail broadcast service to share concise insights from the latest financial report. In this way, they increase the chances that managers who spend a lot of time away from their desks will have easy access to the latest analysis and reports. These managers are more likely to engage with and understand the most recent financial analysis and its relevance to their business.

Organisations that change the medium of analysis delivery can extend the reach, understanding and application of financial analysis.

3. Reorient Business and Finance Roles for Joint Decision Making

Create effective debate by focusing on business decisions first and financial analysis last. Rather than diving into the intricacies of financial metrics and analysis at the beginning of operational reviews, progressive organisations have reoriented their process to review the business qualitatively first. Instead of starting with an assessment of financial performance, the review focuses on progress against goals and reviewing key assumptions.

For example, teams may begin an operating review with a qualitative risk and opportunity assessment led by business management, leaving the financial review to the end as a counterpoint. This approach repositions the Finance-business relationship as collaborative, not adversarial. Both business managers and financial analysts focus on the operations, activities and challenges of the business first, developing a better joint understanding of the context or financial performance.

While business management takes the lead on reviewing progress and key assumptions, Finance should provide relevant market and macroeconomic colour in the form of succinct analysis to contextualise the risks and opportunities section of the agenda. Finance leads the final portion of the agenda, in which the team reviews performance against targets.

By inverting the typical review agenda in this way, business management spends less time defending performance and more time discussing areas for improvement and how to fund them.

Conclusion – Knowledge is Power

There is no big secret – in order for FP&A professionals to give credible recommendations to senior management, it is required that they understand the company, industry and the latest trends associated with those. As knowledge depends on the access to right information, FP&A leads should work with CFOs to secure that the team has optimal tools and systems.

There is no big secret – in order for FP&A professionals to give credible recommendations to senior management, it is required that they understand the company, industry and the latest trends associated with those. As knowledge depends on the access to right information, FP&A leads should work with CFOs to secure that the team has optimal tools and systems.

Still, it is a responsibility of each team member to keep up-to-date with how performance is evolving.

One final part to master before joining the table with decision makers is to understand what goals, objectives and targets the enterprise has set. To help someone in reaching the destination, besides knowing weather conditions and how to read the map, it is crucial to know where he or she wants to arrive. ■

References:

  1. Source: CEB Financial Analysis Impact Assessment
  2. Source: http://ww2.cfo.com/
  3. FP&A and Performance Management, 2018
  4. Reinventing FP&A, Michael Coveney, 2019
“Life is like riding a bicycle. To keep your balance, you must keep moving.”
– Albert Einstein