Home › Refund of Tax under GST Law- An Update
GST

Refund of Tax under GST Law- An Update

CA. Kashish Mittal

The author is a member of the Institute. She can be reached at kashishmittal12@gmail.com and eboard@icai.in

At the time of implementation of GST law on 1st July, 2017, availability of forms were not available on GSTN portal in respect of processing of refund through RFD-01 therefore refunds were processed through manual application by submitting with its Jurisdictional officer resulting in delay in processing of refund. The procedure of manual submission of refund application was prescribed by various circulars on time to time by the Government in last two years.

Now Government in a welcome step has issued master circular No. 125/44/2019-GST dated 18th November, 2019 which has clarified various issues being faced by taxpayers in getting refunds. It is important to note that w.e.f. 26th September, 2019, refund procedure has been made fully automatic at the portal and board withdraws its all circular issued for manual processing of refund. Continue reading to know more…

Section 54 of CGST Act, 2017 provides provision of refund primarily in respect of zero rated supply, i.e., exports and supplies made to SEZ and the following refund types:

  • Tax on the supply of goods regards as deemed exports.
  • Inverted duty structure, i.e., rate of tax on input is higher vs rate of tax on output is lower.
  • Refund in pursuance of Section 77, i.e., tax paid under wrong head i.e, CGST, SGST or IGST.
  • Refund of tax paid on a supply which has not been provided and a refund voucher has been issued.
  • Others like Refund in case of international tourists, etc.

There are various limitation and condition with its procedure to avail refund which has been prescribed in Rule 89 to Rule 97A of CGST Rules, 2017 which prescribe procedure to be followed by taxpayer or jurisdictional officer in terms of application of Refund in RFD-01, acknowledgement, grant of provisional refund, order sanctioning /rejecting refund and interest on delayed refund, etc.

Primarily refunds are being availed by taxpayer in respect of zero rated supplies, i.e., exports and supplies made to SEZ. There are two methods of availing refund under the law:

  1. Refund of Input tax credit on Inputs and Inputs services with prior submission of Letter of undertaking for permission of export of goods or services or both without payment of tax.
  2. Refund of IGST by paying it. Taxpayer may utilise input tax credit, input services and capital goods and differential balance due to value addition be paid in cash.

It is well known fact that refund under option (b) would be processed quickly compared to refund under option (a). However, option (b) carries the additional burden of payment of tax in cash is involved which result in blockage of working capital on value addition being made by the exporter.

There is one more important point to note that Section 54 of CGST Act, 2017 does not permit refund on account of Inputs availed on Capital Goods in option (a); whereas option (b) read with Section 16 of CGST Act, 2017 does not stop utilisation of credit on account of capital goods resulting in grant of refund on tax paid on procurement of capital goods.

With effect from 26.09.2019, the applications for the following types of refunds shall be filed in FORM GST RFD 01 on the common portal and the same shall be processed electronically:

  1. Refund of unutilised input tax credit (ITC) on account of exports without payment of tax;
  2. Refund of tax paid on export of services with payment of tax;
  3. Refund of unutilised ITC on account of supplies made to SEZ Unit/SEZ Developer without payment of tax;
  4. Refund of tax paid on supplies made to SEZ Unit/SEZ Developer with payment of tax;
  5. Refund of unutilised ITC on account of accumulation due to inverted tax structure;
  6. Refund to supplier of tax paid on deemed export supplies;
  7. Refund to recipient of tax paid on deemed export supplies;
  8. Refund of excess balance in the electronic cash ledger;
  9. Refund of excess payment of tax;
  10. Refund of tax paid on intra-State supply which is subsequently held to be inter-State supply and vice versa;
  11. Refund on account of assessment/provisional assessment/appeal/any other order;
  12. Refund on account of “any other” ground or reason.

Now Government, in a welcome step, has issued master circular No. 125/44/2019-GST dated 18th Nov, 2019 which has clarified various issues being faced by taxpayers in getting refunds. It is important to note that w.e.f 26th Sep, 2019, refund procedure has been made fully automatic at the portal and board withdraws its all circular issued for manual processing of refund.

The Board vide master circular No. 125/44/2019-GST dated 18th Nov, 2019 has clarified the following major doubts of the taxpayers; which are summarized as follows:

Question 1. If a refund application is electronically transmitted to the wrong jurisdictional officer then what will happen?

Answer. Jurisdictional officer shall reassign it to the correct officer electronically as soon as possible, but not later than 3 working days, from the date of generation of the ARN. Deficiency memos shall not be issued in such cases merely on the ground that the applications were received electronically in the wrong jurisdiction.

Question 2. What is the period taxpayer has to choose on the portal to file the refund?

Answer. Taxpayer at his option may file a refund claim for a tax period or by clubbing successive tax periods. However, period cannot be spread across different financial years. Registered persons opting to file FORM GSTR-1 on quarterly basis can only apply for refund on a quarterly basis or clubbing successive quarters only.

Question 3. What is a deficiency memo and what is the procedure to reply of the same?

Answer. Where Jurisdictional officer has found certain deficiency in refund application, then he shall issue a deficiency memo in GST RFD-03 within 15 days from the filing of application by generating an ARN. Once deficiency memo has been issued the amount debited from electronic credit/cash ledger would be re-credited automatically and a new refund application to be submitted by the taxpayer. Care must be taken that deficiency memos are not issued on frivolous grounds resulting in re-filing of refund application being time-barred.

Question 4. Taxpayer has submitted a fresh application in response to deficiency memo being issued, whether officer can again issue a deficiency memo citing others shortcoming in the application?

Answer. It has been clarified that proper officer will not serve another deficiency memo with respect to the application for the same period unless the original deficiency remains unrectified. In other words, once shortcoming of earlier deficiency memo has been rectified then chances of rejection of refund claim is negligible.

Question 5. What is the procedure to be followed in situations where the final refund amount to be sanctioned is less than the amount of refund sanction provisionally?

Example: Applicant files a refund claim of Rs. 100/- on account of zero-rated supplies. The proper officer, after prima-facie examination of the application, sanctions Rs. 90 as provisional refund through FORM GST RFD-04. However, on detailed examination, it appears to the proper officer that only an amount of Rs. 70 is admissible as refund to the applicant.

Answer. In this case, officer issues a show cause notice to the applicant, in FORM GST RFD-08, under section 54 of the CGST Act, read with Section 73 or 74 of the CGST Act, requiring the applicant to show cause as to why:

  1. the amount claimed of Rs. 30/- should not be rejected as per the relevant provisions of the law; and
  2. the amount of Rs. 20/- erroneously refunded should not be recovered under section 73 or section 74 of the CGST Act, as the case may be, along with interest and penalty, if any.

Question 6. What would happen if refund claim is rejected and what is the procedure of re-crediting of electronic credit ledger on account of rejection?

Example: a refund claim of unutilised/accumulated ITC of Rs. 100/-, only Rs. 80/- is sanctioned (Rs. 15/- is rejected on account of ineligible ITC and Rs. 5/- is rejected on account of any other reason).

Answer. A show cause notice, in FORM GST RFD-08 will be issued to the applicant, requiring him to show cause as to why –

  1. the refund claim amounting to Rs. 20/-should not be rejected under the relevant provisions of the law; and
  2. why the ineligible ITC of Rs. 15/- should not be recovered under section 73 or Section 74, as the case may be, with interest and penalty, if any.

If the said notice is decided against the applicant, Rs. 15/-, along with interest and penalty, if any, shall be entered by the officer in the electronic liability register of the applicant through issuance of FORM GST DRC-07. Further, Rs. 20/- would be re-credited through FORM GST PMT-03 only after the receipt of an undertaking from the applicant to the effect that he shall not file an appeal or in case he files an appeal, the same is finally decided against the applicant.

Question 7. What is the procedure of rectification of error made while filing the returns in Form 3B?

Answer. The procedure for rectification of errors made while filing the returns in Form 3B has been provided in Circular NO. 26/26/2017-GST dated 29.12.2017. In case of discrepancies between the data furnished by the taxpayer in Form GSTR-3B and Form GSTR-1 the proper officer shall refer to the said Circular and process the refund application accordingly.

Question 8. What is the solution wherein errors have been made committed in declaring the export of services on payment of IGST for zero rated supplies made to a SEZ developer or SEZ units?

Answer. Taxpayers have shown such supplies in the Table under column 3.1(a) instead of showing them in column 3.1(b) of FORM GSTR-3B whilst they have shown the correct details in Table 6A or 6B of FORM GSTR-1 for the relevant tax period and duly discharged their tax liabilities. It has been clarified that for the tax periods commencing from 01.07.2017 to 30.06.2019, such registered persons would be allowed to file the refund application in FORM GST RFD-01 on the common portal subject to the condition that the amount of refund of integrated tax/cess claimed shall not be more than the aggregate amount of integrated tax/cess mentioned in the Table under columns 3.1(a), 3.1(b) and 3.1(c) of FORM GSTR-3B filed for the corresponding tax period.

Question 9. What is the recent change in regards refund disbursal by single authority?

Answer. A refund application assigned to a Central tax officer, both the sanction order (FORM GST RFD-04/06) and the corresponding payment order (FORM GST RFD-05) for the sanctioned refund amount, under all tax heads, shall be issued by the Central tax officer only. Similarly, for refund applications assigned to a State/UT tax officer, both the sanction order (FORM GST RFD- 04/06) and the corresponding payment order (FORM GST RFD-05) for the sanctioned refund amount, under all tax heads, shall be issued by the State/UT tax officer only. It is a welcome step which will facilitate trade friendly measures. Earlier there was substantial delay in processing of state refund, if refund was earlier sanctioned by Central authority or vice-versa.

Question 10. Whether bank account number can be changed by taxpayer with each filing of refund application?

Answer. Taxpayer can select a bank account only from the list of bank account provided by him at the time of registration. It is important to note that, taxpayer should not change his refund account number each time, refund application being filed as system will create a unique file and change of account number will delay the refund processing.

Question 11. Whether refund of input tax credit shall be allowed in case supplier avails drawback of central tax?

Answer. Proviso to Section 54 (3) of the CGST Act states that no refund of input tax credit shall be allowed in cases where the supplier of goods or services or both avails of drawback in respect of Central tax then refund of eligible credit on account of State tax only shall be available. However, if supplier has availed drawback in respect to custom part only then refund on account of Central tax also can be taken.

Question 12. What is the procedure for refund of tax paid on deemed exports?

Answer. Certain supplies of goods have been notified as deemed exports vide notification No. 48/2017-Central Tax dated 18.10.2017 under section 147 of the CGST Act. Further, the third proviso to rule 89(1) of the CGST Rules allows either the recipient or the supplier to apply for refund of tax paid on such deemed export supplies. In case such refund is sought by the supplier of deemed export supplies, the documentary evidences as specified in notification No. 49/2017- Central Tax dated 18.10.2017 are also required to be furnished which includes an undertaking that the recipient of deemed export supplies shall not claim the refund in respect of such supplies and shall not avail any input tax credit on such supplies or vice versa as the case may be.

Question 13. Whether refund of compensation cess can be granted, where final product is not leviable to cess?

Answer. A registered person is eligible to claim refund of unutilised input tax credit of compensation cess paid on inputs, where the zero-rated final product is not leviable to compensation cess. Example could be coal has been used in manufacturing and export of aluminium, wherein coal is subject to compensation cess and there is no levy of compensation cess on aluminium. Even though refund can be granted for use of coal for captive generation of electricity.

Question 14. A registered person reversed ITC of compensation cess so availed on purchase of coal which are used in making zero rated outward supplies.

Answer. Reversed amount is again availed in a later tax period, subject to the restriction under section 16(4) of the CGST Act, it can be refunded in the ratio of export turnover to total turnover in that tax period. This is subject to the restriction that the accounting entry showing the said ITC as cost is also reversed.

Question 15. An exporter has not submitted (Letter of Undertaking) LUT before affecting zero rated supplies. Whether refund can be granted to the said exporter?

Answer. The board has clarified that substantive benefits of zero rating should not be denied where it has been established that exports in terms of the relevant provisions have been made. The delay in furnishing of LUT in such cases may be condoned and the facility for export under LUT may be allowed on ex post facto basis taking into accounts the facts and circumstances of each case.

Question 16. Value declared in tax invoice is different from the export value declared in the corresponding shipping bill under the Customs Act.

Answer. It has been clarified by board that the value recorded in the GST invoice should normally be the transaction value as determined under section 15 of the CGST Act read with the rules made thereunder. The same transaction value should normally be recorded in the corresponding shipping bill / bill of export. During the processing of the refund claim, the value of the goods declared in the GST invoice and the value in the corresponding shipping bill / bill of export should be examined and the “lower of the two values” should be taken into account while calculating the eligible amount of refund.

Question 17. Whether there is any requirement to submit BRC /FIRC in case of export of goods for getting refund claim?

Answer. Proof of realisation of export proceeds for processing of refund claims related to export of goods has not been envisaged in the law and should not be demanded from the taxpayer. The condition in Rule 89(2) is applicable in case of export of services.

Question 18. Whether refund on input tax can be availed for making zero rated supplies which is an exempt supply?

Answer. As per Section 16(2) of the IGST Act, credit of input tax may be availed for making zero rated supplies; notwithstanding that such supply is an exempt supply. In terms of Section 2 (47) of the CGST Act, exempt supply includes non-taxable supply. Therefore, refund can be granted in such cases. Further, in case of zero-rated supply of exempted or non-GST goods, the requirement for furnishing a bond or LUT is not there, for which jurisdiction officer should not be insisted upon.

Question 19. Whether exporter who has received capital goods under the Export Promotion Capital Goods Scheme (EPCG Scheme), can avail the facility of claiming refund of the Integrated tax paid on exports?

Answer. Exporters who have imported inputs in terms of notification Nos. 78/2017-Customs dated 13.10.2017, after the issuance of notification No. 54/2018 – Central Tax dated 09.10.2018, would not be eligible to claim refund of Integrated tax paid on exports. However, exporters who are receiving capital goods under the EPCG scheme, either through import in terms of notification No. 79/2017-Customs dated 13.10. 2017 or through domestic procurement in terms of notification No. 48/2017-Central Tax, dated 18.10.2017, shall continue to be eligible to claim refund of Integrated tax paid on exports and would not be hit by the restrictions provided in sub-rule (10) of rule 96 of the CGST Rules.

Question 20. In terms of Notification No. 20/2018-CT dated 26th July, 2018 accumulated ITC is required to be lapsed and taxpayer have reversed it through Form-3B due to which portal does not take ITC reversed in RFD-01A; resulting in inability to claim refund by taxpayer of full amount of ITC.

Answer. Refund of accumulated ITC on account of inverted tax structure, for the period(s) in which there is reversal of the ITC required to be lapsed in terms of the said notification, is to be claimed under the category “any other” instead of under the category “refund of unutilised ITC on account of accumulation due to inverted tax structure” in FORM GST RFD-01A. It is emphasised that this application for refund should relate to the same tax period in which such reversal has been made. Further, those registered persons who have required to make the reversal in terms of the said notification and who have not yet done so, may reverse the said amount through FORM GST DRC-03 instead of through FORM GSTR-3B with applicable interest.

Question 21. How should a merchant exporter claim refund of input tax credit availed on supplies received on which the supplier has availed the benefit of N No. 40/2017-Central Tax (Rate), dated the 23rd October, 2017?

Answer. Merchant exporter can procure goods at concessional rate of tax of 0.05% or 0.1% due to which supplier of such goods has accumulated input tax credit. This refund of accumulated ITC under rule 89(4B) of the CGST Rules shall be applied under the category “any other” instead of under the category “refund of unutilised ITC on account of exports without payment of tax” in FORM GST RFD-01. It is important to note that exporter of such goods can export the goods only under LUT / bond and cannot export on payment of Integrated tax.

Merchandise exports from India scheme (MEIS) and Service Exports from India Scheme (SEIS) is rewarded on the basis of FOB value of exports realised and net free foreign exchange realised respectively.

Question 22. Whether refund on account ITC on stores and spares, packing materials, materials purchased for machinery repairs, printing and stationery items are eligible?

Answer. ITC of the GST paid on inputs, including inward supplies of stores and spares, packing materials etc., shall be available as ITC as long as these inputs are used for the purpose of the business and/or for effecting taxable supplies, including zero-rated supplies, and the ITC for such inputs is not restricted under section 17(5) of the CGST Act. It is further clarified that Stores and spares, the expenditure on which has been charged as a revenue expense in the books of account, cannot be held to be capital goods.

Further, circular provides list of all statements/ declarations/ undertakings/ certificates and other supporting documents to be provided along with the refund application.

It is important to note that there are incentive schemes for service / merchandise exports are notified under foreign trade policy which is granted as reward to compensate cost to the manufacturer or service provider. Merchandise exports from India scheme (MEIS) and Service Exports from India Scheme (SEIS) is rewarded on the basis of FOB value of exports realized and net free foreign exchange realised respectively.

Some interesting pointers to consider that emerges from this circular:

  • All refund applications filed on or after 26 September 2019 would come within the guidance in this circular. Considering that it is issued under section 164 of the CGST Act, the statutory force of the guidance by way of interpretation of extant provisions is unmistakable. Trade would do well to freely cite relevant portions of this circular and expect that it will be followed by refund sanctioning authorities in processing their claims;
  • All refund claims are also required to comply with requirements of Rule 36(4) of CGST Rules. While 20 per cent of ‘unmatched credits’ are admissible under this new rule, care must be taken in filing refund claims, para 36 of the circular appears to do two things, namely, (i) all credits included in the refund claims must appear in GSTR 2A and (ii) only 20% of the credits included may be separately supported by invoices even when it does not appear in GSTR 2A. With Rule 36(4) being applicable to refund claims, Government’s resolve to push-through with the concept of matching is noteworthy;
  • Where refund applications are filed and ARN is generated, in case of any deficiencies, Proper Officer is obliged to issue a deficiency memo (RFD 03) within 15 days. At this point, the circular states in para 9 to 11 that amount of credit reversed (in support of refund claim) will be recredited to Electronic Credit Ledger of taxpayer. As a result, the taxpayer is effectively put in the position ‘prior’ to filing the refund. Taxpayers need to take care that this deficiency memo can result in refund claim being time-barred. And when refund claims are filed close to the end of 2 years from relevant date (for claiming refund in each case), receiving a deficiency memo would permanently deny the benefit of refund;
  • Exporters were allowed rebate under rule 89(4B) of CGST Act, even if imports are under 78/2017-Cus. and 79/2017-Cus. And para 51 and 52 make it clear that this benefit of refund will NOT be available after 9 October 2018 (when amendment was made vide 54/2018-Central Tax). Taxpayers would do well to avail this guidance and expedite disposal of refund claims up to 9 October 2019 and not thereafter.

Conclusion

This master circular is a welcome measure to put to rest concerns of trade in securing refunds. It addresses several aspects that could have potentially led to rejection of refunds. It is both timely and comprehensive. In addition to coming to the aid of trade, it also alleviates concerns of refund sanctioning authorities as to the correct approach in numerous situations. Trade would be most pleased with such a comprehensive and authoritative master circular that is issued under section 168, giving it legal sanctity too.