“The Sabka Vishwas (Legacy Dispute Resolution) Scheme, 2019 represents a landmark dispute resolution cum amnesty measure proposed by the Government in the Union Budget 2019. Similar in spirit to legacy settlement schemes recently launched across Maharashtra, Karnataka, West Bengal, and Gujarat to conclude outstanding VAT disputes, this central initiative seeks to liquidate legacy litigations locked under Central Excise, Service Tax, and twenty other indirect tax enactments. In this comprehensive analysis, the authors examine the key statutory provisions, procedural workflows, relief matrices, ambiguities, and strategic implications of the proposed Scheme. Read on…”
Authors: CA. Vishal Gill and CA. Ajay Sharma
Credentials: Members of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI)
Contact: gill_vishal@yahoo.com and eboard@icai.in
Published In: The Chartered Accountant, August 2019, Vol. 68, No. 2, pp. 61–65 (225–229)
To foster the ease of doing business and replenish public revenues while unburdening commercial enterprises from long-pending disputes, the Sabka Vishwas (Legacy Dispute Resolution) Scheme, 2019 stands out as a decisive step by the Union Government. This dispute resolution cum amnesty framework mirrors legacy tax settlement initiatives earlier introduced by states such as Maharashtra, Karnataka, West Bengal, and Gujarat to finalize pending VAT matters.
The Union Finance Minister introduced the Sabka Vishwas (Legacy Dispute Resolution) Scheme, 2019 (LDR Scheme) in the maiden Finance Bill of the newly elected government with the following policy statement:
“GST has just completed two years. An area that concerns me is that we have huge pending litigations from pre-GST regime. More than 3.75 lakh crore is blocked in litigations in service tax and excise. There is a need to unload this baggage and allow business to move on. I, therefore, propose, a Legacy Dispute Resolution Scheme that will allow quick closure of these litigations. I would urge the trade and business to avail this opportunity and be free from legacy litigations.”
The scheme has been enacted specifically to settle legacy cases arising primarily under Central Excise and Service Tax, extending also across more than twenty other central indirect taxation statutes that were subsumed into GST. All eligible taxpayers can participate in the scheme to resolve disputes regarding duty, interest, and penalties, subject to specific statutory disqualifications and the condition that the underlying matter had not undergone final hearing prior to the cut-off date of June 30, 2019.
Motivation behind Introduction of LDR Scheme, 2019
While executive efforts to enhance the ease of doing business in India have been widely acknowledged, the unresolved accumulation of appeals, judicial delays, and administrative backlogs remains a major bottleneck. These structural delays hamper contract enforcement, discourage domestic and foreign capital investments, stall critical infrastructure projects, choke tax collections, impose acute administrative stress on taxpayers, and escalate legal expenditures across the corporate ecosystem.
Official data compiled for the quarter ending March 2017 revealed that approximately 1.45 lakh indirect tax appeals were pending adjudication across the Commissioner (Appeals), the Customs Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), High Courts, and the Supreme Court combined, representing a staggering blocked tax value of ₹ 2.62 lakh crore in the final quarter of 2017. The distribution of pending cases and values across the judicial hierarchy stood as follows:
Supreme Court
2,946 Cases
₹ 0.20 Lac Crore
High Court
14,141 Cases
₹ 0.37 Lac Crore
CESTAT
83,338 Cases
₹ 1.92 Lac Crore
An even more remarkable finding highlighted in the Economic Survey 2017-18 is that the success rate of the Revenue Department across all three appellate tiers (CESTAT, High Courts, and the Supreme Court) for both direct and indirect tax litigation is below 30%, dipping in some forums to as low as 12%. The Department unambiguously loses roughly 65% of its appeals. Over time, the Department’s win rate has steadily declined while that of assessees has grown.
Petition rate & Success rate of tax department in indirect tax cases
| Court / Tribunal | ²Petition rate | ³Success rate |
|---|---|---|
| Supreme Court | 63% | 11% |
| High Court | 39% | 46% |
| CESTAT | 20% | 12% |
¹ Chapter 9—Ease of Doing Business’ Next Frontier: Timely Justice of Economic Survey 2017-18
² Petition rate means, % of petition filed by the revenue department in case decided in favor of assessee
³ Success rate means, % of cases where the appeals decided in favour of revenue department.
These figures reflect only the legacy pre-GST regime. Meanwhile, the GST framework has brought its own wave of litigation during its first two years of rollout. Thorny legal controversies regarding input tax credit (ITC) admissibility, transitional credit, e-way bills and transit detentions, advance rulings, and anti-profiteering have consumed immense administrative manpower. Consequently, introducing the LDR Scheme, 2019 serves to liquidate pre-GST disputes cleanly, release revenue manpower, and establish a win-win resolution for both taxpayers and the exchequer given the department’s historically low success rates.
Features of the Scheme
The Scheme is designed as a one-time settlement window to liquidate outstanding disputes under Central Excise and Service Tax and to facilitate full disclosure of unpaid dues by eligible declarants. The Central Government will notify its formal commencement date. The ten cardinal highlights and features of the proposed Scheme are:
- The Scheme shall become operational from a notified date, with procedural rules, forms, and administrative guidelines issued in due course.
- The Scheme applies to Service Tax, Central Excise, and more than 20 other Central enactments governing indirect taxation.
- Dedicated Designated Committees will be constituted to verify and adjudicate declarations filed by applicants for dispute resolution.
- Declarant taxpayers must submit their formal declarations electronically in the prescribed format before the Designated Authority.
- Matters eligible include orders that have not attained finality and are not appealed, orders attaining finality, show cause notices (SCNs) issued, and tax demands quantified on or before June 30, 2019.
- The net tax payable is computed strictly as the difference between the total tax dues and the statutory tax relief determined by the Designated Authority.
- Upon discharging the determined tax payable, the declarant receives a formal discharge certificate granting conclusive immunity from any further duty, interest, or penalty for the declared matter and period.
- Any amount deposited under this Scheme is strictly non-refundable under all circumstances, even if an excess deposit has occurred.
- All immunities and benefits earned through the Scheme will lapse automatically if any misstatement or false information is identified in the declaration.
- The taxability of disputed legal issues remains completely unchanged for subsequent tax periods and for the trade as a whole, notwithstanding the issuance of a discharge certificate to the declarant.
Mechanism and Important Aspect of the Schemes
Under the statutory framework, specialized Designated Authorities will adjudicate declarations and issue discharge certificates. The statute does not provide an appellate mechanism against the statement of amount payable or the discharge certificate. The procedural flow before the Designated Authority proceeds through five sequential stages:
STAGES OF PROCEEDINGS BEFORE DESIGNATED AUTHORITY
*Opportunity of being heard shall be granted where difference exists between amount determined by authority and declared by declarant.
To grasp the statutory mechanics and legislative intent, key definitions governing the LDR Scheme must be evaluated:
Key Statutory Definitions
| TERMS | DEFINITION |
|---|---|
| Amount in arrears |
Means the amount of duty which is recoverable as arrears of duty under the indirect tax enactment on account of—
|
| AMOUNT PAYABLE | Means the final amount payable by the declarant as determined by the designated committee and as indicated in the statement issued by it, in order to be eligible for the benefits under this Scheme and shall be calculated as the amount of tax dues less the tax relief; |
| TAX RELIEF | Means the amount of relief granted under section 123. |
The definition of Amount Payable establishes the net liability remaining after deducting the statutory Tax Relief from Tax Due. The statutory matrix governing Tax Due under Section 122 and Relief under Section 123 operates across various scenarios as follows:
Tax Due (Section 122) and Relief Matrix (Section 123)
| TYPE OF CASES | MEANING OF TAX DUE (Section 122) | RELIEF (Section 123) |
|---|---|---|
| ⁴Appeal Cases |
WHERE A SINGLE APPEAL IS FILED AND PENDING AGAINST THE ORDER: The amount of only duty under appeal WHERE MORE THAN ONE (BY DECLARANT and/or DEPARTMENT): The total amount of only duty of both appeal |
1. Where amount of duty is or less than 50 lac: 70 % of the Tax dues 2. Where amount of duty is more than 50 lac: 50 % of the Tax dues |
| Show Cause Notice | The amount demanded (only duty i.e. tax amount) in the SCN received before 30.06.2019 |
1. Where amount of duty is or less than 50 lac: 70 % of the Tax dues 2. Where amount of duty is more than 50 lac: 50 % of the Tax dues |
| Show Cause Notice (only related to penalty or late fees) | The amount demanded in the SCN received before 30.06.2019 | Where amount of duty in said notice has duly been paid or nil, then relief will be total amount of penalty and fees. |
| Inquiry & Investigation | Amount quantified on or before 30.06.2019 |
1. Where amount quantified till 30.06.2019 is or less than 50 lac: 70 % of the Tax dues 2. Where amount quantified till 30.06.2019 is more than 50 lac: 50 % of the Tax dues |
| Voluntary Disclosure | Amount voluntarily disclosed as duty i.e. tax only | ⁵No relief in respect of tax dues |
| Amount in Arrears | Amount due in arrear (Such as amount payable as per return) |
1. If amount of duty/ indicated in return is less than 50 Lac: 60% of the tax dues 2. If amount of duty/indicated in return is more than 50 Lac: 40% of the tax dues |
⁴ Not to be considered where the final hearing has been done in on or before 30.06.2019
⁵ The relief in relation to voluntary disclosure is exhaustive, scheme defines relief not available instead of available relief
One Can’t Escape from the Consequences even after the Scheme
Certain liabilities and powers remain operative notwithstanding the availment of the scheme and receipt of a discharge certificate:
-
The tax authority may still issue a show cause notice:
- (A) for the same matter for a subsequent time period; or
- (B) for a different matter for the same time period;
- In a case of voluntary disclosure where any material particular furnished in the declaration is subsequently found to be false, within a period of one year of issue of the discharge certificate, it shall be presumed as if the declaration was never made and proceedings under the applicable indirect tax enactment shall be instituted.
The LDR scheme nowhere protects the tax evader for their subsequent default or person making false disclosure in the scheme declaration.
Disqualified Person to File Declaration
- Who have been convicted for any offence punishable under any provision of the PRE GST law for the matter for which he intends to file a declaration.
- Who have been issued a show cause notice under indirect tax enactment for an erroneous refund or refund.
- Who have been subjected to an enquiry or investigation amount of duty has not been quantified before 30.06.2019.
- Who have filed an application in the Settlement Commission for settlement of a case.
- The cases for which final hearing has been done before 30.06.2019 (SCN or Appeal).
- A person making a voluntary disclosure:
- after being subjected to any enquiry or investigation or audit; or
- having filed a return under the indirect tax enactment, wherein he has indicated an amount of duty as payable, but has not paid it.
GLIMPSE - QUALIFICATION AND DISQUALIFICATION TO AVAIL THE SCHEME
| S. No. | Nature of Cases | PERSON/CASES QUALIFY TO FILE | PERSON/ CASES DISQUALIFY FOR SCHEME |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Inquiry/ investigation | Demand quantified before 30.06.2019 | Amount not quantified before 30.06.2019 |
| 2 | Departmental Audit | Demand quantified before 30.06.2019 | Amount not quantified before 30.06.2019 |
| 3 | SCN | Received before 30.06.2019 and final hearing pending before 30.06.2019 Or Order attained finality |
Received after 30.06.2019 or final hearing done before 30.06.2019 |
| 4 | Appeals (Commissioner Appeals) | Final hearing pending before 30.06.2019 Or Where order in appeal attained finality |
Final hearing done before 30.06.2019 |
| 5 | Appeals (CESTAT) | Final hearing pending before 30.06.2019 Or Where order in appeal attained finality |
Final hearing done before 30.06.2019 |
| 6 | Appeals (HC/ SC) | Final hearing pending before 30.06.2019 Or Where order in appeal attained finality |
Final hearing done before 30.06.2019 |
General Disqualifications:
- Where person has filed an application to settlement commission
- Where a person convicted under indirect tax enactment (Pre GST regime) for the same matter
- A SCN for a refund or Erroneous refund
Benefits of the Scheme to Industry & Revenue and to Taxpayers
To Industry and Revenue
- The scheme will be oriented on inclusion of the taxpayers, who have been entangled in the litigation of pre GST regime.
- This scheme will end up pre GST regime to an extent by way of disposal of the maximum number of cases, which is only legacy of the PRE GST era.
- The ease of doing business will get strengthen and entrepreneur will get rid of the legal repercussion due to pre GST dispute.
- The revenue authority will ensure an estimated amount of collection, which is blocked and at stake due to pending dispute.
- There will be notional loss to revenue by analysing this scheme on pretext of time value of money and success rate of the revenue department in tax dispute.
To Taxpayer Availing the Scheme
- ⁶The declarant shall not be liable to pay any further duty, interest, or penalty with respect to the matter and time period covered in the declaration.
- This scheme will have a great impact on liquidity, going concern and prospect planning of organisation.
- The declarant shall not be liable to be prosecuted under the indirect tax enactment with respect to the matter and time period covered in the declaration.
- No matter and time period covered by such declaration shall be reopened in any other proceeding under the indirect tax enactment.
Ambiguities and Challenges before the Scheme
Ambiguities Required Clarification and Challenges & Hardships
- ➤ Contradiction between relief and disqualification: Apparently, there is a contradiction in provision related to the relief and ineligibility to file declaration. The cases where amount payable in respect of a filed return in pre GST regime is specifically in the relief provision as well as in the category of debarred scenario to avail this scheme, which is practically sound against the intent of scheme and causing conflict⁷. (See disqualification of person to file declaration discussed above).
- ➤ Lack of clarity on interest/penalty/late fees: A very critical aspect of the relief from interest, penalty and late fees in case of person granted with relief under this scheme, no specific discussion on this in the proposed scheme.
- ➤ No refund or ITC of excess amount: The assessee will not be eligible for any sort of refund or ITC in respect of amount excess paid or remain unused after scheme such as redeposit etc., this is a factor of great consideration.
- ➤ Ambiguity in ‘final hearing’ concept: Scheme pre-requisite in the pending cases is that these cases must have been heard on their final hearing prior to 30.06.2019, but there is no specific meaning in any act for the concept of the final hearing, it is arbitrary to establish whether final hearing has been done or not specifically for cases pending before Commissioner (Appeals).
Challenges & Hardships
- ➤ Arbitrary benchmark cut-off date: The scheme has been come up with a benchmark date of 30.06.2019, which may restrict the benefit to the assessee and adversely affect the taxpayer’s decision to opt.
- ➤ Risk of excessive delegation: There is critical requirement to formulate rules and regulation for each and every aspect to avoid further litigation, as it is happening in various other cases like Anti profiteering authority, where authority allegedly exercising excess delegation.
- ➤ No mechanism to withdraw declaration: This scheme apparently seems to be a dead end for declarant, as there is no mechanism apparently to withdraw the declaration, if amount payable estimated by the authority is not acceptable to the declarant.
- ➤ Denial of scheme to orders passed post June 30, 2019: The scheme will NOT be available to assessee who receives adjudication order or appellate order after June 30, 2019 and where hearing may have been conducted earlier as it would be treated as ‘finally heard’ on the benchmark date.
- ➤ Critical role of penalty/interest waiver: The quantum of relief for interest and penalty will play a critical role to encourage the taxpayer to adopt the scheme, if it remains unattractive on this prospect, then scheme may face a big blow.
⁶ The quantum of relief from interest and penalty is ambiguous in the proposal for scheme, however notes to clause on page 107 of Finance Bill discuss about relief from payment of interest and penalty.
⁷ Refer Section 124 123(1)(C)(iii) & 124 (1)(f)(ii) of the Finance Bill, 2019.
Conclusion and Way Forward
The Central Board of the Indirect Taxes (CBIC) possesses the experience of the VCES, 2013, wherein lot of challenges and post-introduction litigation arose, some of which persist to date. Therefore, it becomes significantly important to make the rules, provisions, and benefits clear and pro-taxpayer if the intent is to eliminate legacy disputes, otherwise the scheme risks turning into a double-edged sword creating more litigation than resolution. Suggestions from industry stakeholders and professionals must be incorporated prior to notifying procedural rules. Taxpayers planning to avail the scheme should carefully evaluate legal merits and perform cost-benefit assessments factoring in the time value of money, the cost of mental peace, and recurring exposure in subsequent tax periods.
If an issue has strong legal merits and recurring implications, contesting it legally may remain advantageous since the scheme offers no immunity for subsequent tax periods. Furthermore, State Governments should draw inspiration from the Centre and states like Maharashtra and Gujarat to introduce similar dispute resolution mechanisms across state enactments. With constructive and pro-taxpayer implementation by CBIC and the legislature, the scheme can successfully achieve closure for legacy indirect tax litigation.
“Don’t let what you can’t do stop you from doing what you can do.” — John Wooden