Salient Features of Interim Budget, 2019
Handed with the difficult task of presenting the final budget of the Government before general elections, the Interim Finance Minister (FM), CA. Piyush Goyal took centre stage last month to present the Government’s financial vision for the coming year. While pre-election budgets are usually limited and do not bring in new proposals, the FM did take some leeway to announce some sops for the rural and agricultural sector. He also used this opportunity to share the various changes made and his take on this Government’s achievements since 2014. Read on…
The Country’s Balance Sheet
For the coming year, the Government has planned to spend a lavish ₹ 27.84 lakh crore. I say lavish because this is an increase of 14% over last year’s budgeted expenditure. The bulk of this increase is going to the central schemes for agriculture. The planned allocation on such schemes have been increased by a whopping 135% to ₹ 1.5 lakh crore from ₹ 63 thousand crore. Substantial increase has also been planned for subsidy for petroleum. This may translate into relief of fuel prices, possibly just before elections.
Interestingly, despite the planned increase in seats in educational institutes by around 2 lakhs on account of the new reservation, the increase in expenditure on Education has only been 10% to ₹ 93 thousand crore.
The growth in expenditure is expected to be funded by a similar increase in tax revenues (15%) while hoping to maintain the fiscal deficit at 3.4%. This includes an increase of 17% in personal taxation from last year. With the current GDP growth rate hovering in the range of 7-8% and no new taxes being introduced, the growth expectation in tax revenues may fall short and keeping the fiscal deficit at 3.4% might be difficult to achieve.
Growth in expenditure is expected to be funded by a similar increase in tax revenues (15%) while hoping to maintain the fiscal deficit at 3.4%. This includes an increase of 17% in personal taxation from last year. With the current GDP growth rate hovering in the range of 7-8% and no new taxes being introduced, the growth expectation in tax revenues may fall short and keeping the fiscal deficit at 3.4% might be difficult to achieve.
The Schemes
Being an interim budget, the FM did not announce any new scheme for industry or on infrastructure. Most of the existing schemes such as MNREGA, Gram Sadak Yojna, Ayushman Bharat, Awas Yojna, etc. were continued with moderate increases. However, the FM did announce income support scheme for the farmers holding land up to 2 hectares of ₹ 6000 per year effecting from December 1, 2018.
Benefit of interest subvention was extended to farmers engaged in animal husbandry and fisheries and to those who receive assistance under National Disaster Relief Fund. Interest subvention would also be available to GST registered SME units on incremental loan of up to ₹ 1 crore.
The above schemes will primarily benefit the rural sector increasing their income directly. This should indirectly lead to growth in the rural retail sector giving a small boost to the economic growth.
Pension scheme for the unorganised sector was announced with an assured monthly pension of ₹ 3000 per month from the age of 60 years on payment of monthly contribution starting from ₹ 55 per month. Matching contribution would be made by the Government. While the Government has only planned an outlay of ₹ 500 crore for this scheme, the scheme will need to be reviewed for the long term impact.
First, the planned amount of ₹ 500 crore is meagre. With the FM himself estimating 10 crore people to benefit from this scheme, the minimum matching contribution comes at ₹ 6,600 crore. Further, the benefit of this scheme would at least take a decade to come as the corpus would have to reach a reasonable size for any person to be able to receive this amount of money. By that time, possibly the value of ₹ 3000 per month might not be significant enough.
The FM has also proposed amendments in the stamp duty to streamline the process of levy and collection of stamp duty on financial securities. The change will allow uniformity of taxation throughout the country and check evasion of duty. The system will allow collection of duty at one point with seamless distribution of duty to the relevant state. This will help in easing administrative loads for all investors while augmenting the revenue of the States.
The FM has also proposed amendments in the stamp duty to streamline the process of levy and collection of stamp duty on financial securities. The change will allow uniformity of taxation throughout the country and check evasion of duty. The system will allow collection of duty at one point with seamless distribution of duty to the relevant state. This will help in easing administrative loads for all investors while augmenting the revenue of the States.
Other Proposals
To support the SME sector, the FM has also proposed to increase the requirement for sourcing from SMEs by Government Enterprises to 25% from the existing 20%. A 3% sub-limit has been kept for SMEs owned by women. The FM also proposed to extend the ‘Government e-Marketplace’ for public procurement by all Centre-owned Public Sector Enterprises.
Both these steps will be welcome by the SME sector as it will allow a bigger market for their products with country owned enterprises being significant consumer of such goods.
Direct Taxes
In line with the theme of the budget, the direct tax proposals also primarily focused on lower segment of the taxpayers. While no new schemes/deductions/exemptions were proposed for the businesses, the entrepreneurs will take solace in the fact that at least no new taxes were introduced this time. The FM also did not propose any tweaks in the existing law. The changes proposed in the current budget are as follows.
In line with the theme of the budget, the direct tax proposals also primarily focused on lower segment of the taxpayers. While no new schemes/deductions/exemptions were proposed for the businesses, the entrepreneurs will take solace in the fact that at least no new taxes were introduced this time. The FM also did not propose any tweaks in the existing law.
1. Rebate for resident individuals having taxable income up to ₹ 5,00,000
The FM announced full rebate from income tax for all resident individuals whose net taxable income is ₹ 5 lakhs or less. The rebate has been given by amending Section 87A and increasing the eligibility limit from an income of ₹ 3,50,000 to ₹ 5,00,000. The quantum of rebate has also been increased from ₹ 2,500 to ₹ 12,500. It is important to note that this benefit is only to those individuals who are resident and whose income is upto ₹ 5 lakhs. The FM has not made any changes in tax slabs for individuals earning more than ₹ 5 lakhs.
No marginal relief has been proposed for those taxpayers who would be earning income slightly above ₹ 5 lakhs. Consequently, these taxpayers may end up having a lower net income after payment of tax than those with a lower income. The same can be understood by way of the following example. This is an anomaly which needs to be addressed by the Government.
| Particulars | Mr. X | Mr. Y |
|---|---|---|
| Total Income | 5,00,000 | 5,05,000 |
| Tax on total income | 12,500 | 13,500 |
| Rebate u/s 87 A | 12,500 | - |
| Net Tax (incl cess) | - | 14,040 |
| Net income after tax | 5,00,000 | 4,90,960 |
Coupled with other deductions currently available such as for investments, interest on housing loan, standard deduction, etc., a person having an income up to ₹ 9.85 lakhs may end up with paying no taxes.
| Particulars | Amount (₹) |
|---|---|
| Gross Total Income | 985,000 |
| Less Deductions: | |
| - Standard Deduction under Section 16 (applicable for salaried taxpayers only) | 50,000 |
| - Interest on housing loan under Section 24 | 200,000 |
| - 80C (Eligible Investments) | 150,000 |
| - 80CCD(2) (National Pension Scheme) | 50,000 |
| - 80D (Medical Insurance) | 25,000 |
| - 80TTA (Bank Interest) | 10,000 |
| Total Deductions | 485,000 |
| Net Taxable Income | 500,000 |
| Applicable Tax | Nil |
This amendment will benefit a large section of taxpayers especially the younger generation of salaried individuals earning between ₹ 40,000 to ₹ 80,000 per month.
It is important to note that while no tax is payable by such individuals having income upto ₹ 5,00,000, they would still need to file their tax returns as their total taxable income is more than the maximum amount not chargeable to tax, i.e., ₹ 2,50,000. Hence, it is advised that tax returns should still be filed to avoid any default under section 139 and to avoid consequent penalty.
2. Increase in Standard Deduction for salaried taxpayers
The Standard Deduction provided under Section 16(ia) of the Act of ₹ 40,000 has been marginally increased to ₹ 50,000 which will provide slight relief to all salaried taxpayers. Pensioners would also be benefitted by the relief since standard deduction is also available against pension income.
The effective saving for each individual would be between ₹ 2,080 and ₹ 3,120 depending on the tax slabs they fall in. Standard deduction was introduced in the previous budget in lieu of the transport allowance and medical reimbursement. The amount of increase being small may not be enough to bring any smile to the salaried individuals.
| Individuals falling in highest slab rate of 30% | FY 2018-19 | FY 2019-20 |
|---|---|---|
| Net taxable income before standard deduction u/s 16 | 1,200,000 | 1,200,000 |
| Standard deduction u/s 16 | 40,000 | 50,000 |
| Net taxable income after standard deduction u/s 16 | 1,160,000 | 1,150,000 |
| Income tax liability | 166,920 | 163,800 |
| Net Savings due to increase in standard deduction | - | 3,120 |
| Individuals falling in slab rate of 20% | FY 2018-19 | FY 2019-20 |
|---|---|---|
| Net taxable income before standard deduction u/s 16 | 800,000 | 800,000 |
| Standard deduction u/s 16 | 40,000 | 50,000 |
| Net taxable income after standard deduction u/s 16 | 760,000 | 750,000 |
| Income tax liability | 67,080 | 65,000 |
| Net Savings due to increase in standard deduction | - | 2,080 |
3. Relief from Notional rent
A major relief that this budget brings in is for people owning multiple houses/buildings and for real estate developers. If a person owns more than one house/building, according to Section 23 of the Act, the second house is presumed to be let out and taxed at notional rent even when no rent is received by the owner.
The Budget has exempted taxation of notional rent for the second self-occupied house owned by any person. Section 23 is proposed to be amended to allow two self-occupied houses to be excluded from the calculation of notional rent. The FM shared that this has been allowed keeping in mind the large number of people who work in a city different from their native place and own two houses consequently.
Further, under Section 23(5), in the case of real estate developer, who holds any property or properties as stock in trade, notional rent is charged from the second financial year after the completion of the construction of the property. This will allow real estate developers an additional period of one year to sell off their properties.
The said section is proposed to be amended to provide such exemption from the existing one year to a period of two years from the end of the year in which building is completed.
4. Capital Gain relief for homebuyers
The budget has also given relief under section 54 to assessee being an individual or HUF selling their existing house to buy residential houses. Up till now, exemption from Capital Gain on sale of residential house was only limited to the amount used for purchase of one new residential house. The Finance Bill, 2019 has now proposed to allow additional relief from tax on capital gain where an assessee being an individual or HUF invests the capital gain on sale of one residential property to buy two residential houses. The relief has been limited to the small and middle class families, as it can only be availed where capital gain from sale of the residential property is upto ₹ 2 crore. This benefit of buying two houses can only be obtained once in a lifetime by an individual.
5. Extension of deadline for deduction for affordable housing developers
Developers of affordable housing projects whose projects are registered with the Competent Authority up to March 31, 2019 were eligible for exemption from tax on income from such projects under section 80-IBA. The Finance Bill has proposed to extend the deadline to register the projects by one year to March 31, 2020. No other changes are proposed in the given scheme.
The three proposals above are probably an attempt by the Government to give a mini boost to the real estate sector which has been languishing for the last decade.
6. TDS thresholds
The Finance Bill, 2019 also increases the minimum threshold for deduction of tax at source in case of rent and interest from bank and post offices deposits. The threshold for deduction of tax at source on interest under section 194A is proposed to be increased from ₹ 10,000 to ₹ 40,000. This is only applicable for interest from bank, cooperative banks and post offices. For interest from other than banks, cooperative banks and post offices the threshold for deduction of TDS on interest shall continue at ₹ 5,000.
The threshold for deduction of tax on rent under section 194-I is proposed to be increased from ₹ 1,80,000 to ₹ 2,40,000. This will again be a welcome step to all taxpayers particularly to the individuals in lower and middle income strata, especially the ones who need to file the returns only to claim the refund of TDS. While this may reduce a little bit the tax base, this will also reduce the unnecessary compliance for all the tax deductor, taxpayer and the tax administrator.
7. Administrative ease
The FM in his budget speech also announced some steps the tax department is taking for easing the process for the taxpayers. The processing of tax returns is now planned to be made practically instantaneous with all returns to be processed in 24 hours. The refunds will also be issued simultaneously by the system once the return is processed. This is a welcome step as it will incentivise people to file their returns at an early date immediately at the beginning of the assessment year to get the return processed and obtain their refunds. The only challenge will be submission of TDS return by the deductor so that credit of TDS appears in form No. 26AS. Since the returns would be processed quickly, any shortcomings/defaults would be easier to catch and correct by the department or taxpayer.
The Finance Minister also announced plans to take the process of assessments online completely in a period of two years. The process would require no personal interface and will also be anonymised, i.e., the assessee and assessing officer would have no direct access to each other. This would be a welcome step, as it would lead to greater transparency, quicker resolution and reduction in corruption.
Concluding Remarks
With 2019 being the election year, we all expected a populist budget and the Government delivered, albeit to some extent. With the planned income support and interest subvention to farmers, pension scheme for unorganised sector, the agricultural and rural sector for sure would definitely get some cash in their hands. However, this will come at the cost of middle class, small businesses and corporates who would have to foot the bill. The big question that is definitely going to be is the fiscal deficit which may be difficult to manage. The new Government would again get a chance in July 2019 to rework the numbers which is when the complete scenario would unfold and we can expect many more changes in the Direct Taxes including new Income-tax Act. ■
“Doing what you like is freedom. Liking what you do is happiness.”