Stressed Assets of Road & Highways Sector and its Resolution— Industry Perspective
While the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), 2016 has proven to be a structural game-changer across manufacturing sectors like steel, the resolution of stressed assets in the Roads and Highways sector presents unique economic challenges. Unlike commodity sectors with tangible residual assets, highway projects depend entirely on intangible concession rights, promoter expertise, and ongoing execution capacity. Finance professionals, particularly Chartered Accountants, possess the specialized domain skills required to facilitate viable resolutions both within the IBC framework and through proactive sector-specific mechanisms.
Dynamics of Stressed Assets in Public-Private Partnerships
Industries where underlying physical assets lack standalone liquidation value rarely achieve optimal resolution solely through standard insolvency proceedings. The IBC operates effectively for commodity-driven enterprises with realisable physical plant and machinery, but it frequently produces unintended disruptions in sectors characterized by deep promoter involvement, extensive technical pre-qualification standards, and complex Public-Private Partnership (PPP) or Engineering, Procurement, and Construction (EPC) arrangements.
In PPP and EPC highway projects, the core intrinsic value of an EPC contractor lies in its qualifying track record and balance-sheet eligibility. When insolvency proceedings commence against a contractor, this pre-qualification standing collapses overnight. Project clients immediately invoke Performance Bank Guarantees (PBGs), triggering aggressive defensive reactions from commercial lenders. Banks promptly appropriate margin money, liquidate pledged collateral, and freeze ongoing credit facilities across all group entities under common management. This unleashes a cascading systemic shock across the entire corporate group and the broader infrastructure industry.
Standard Model Concession Agreements (MCAs) in highway PPP and EPC contracts contain explicit termination clauses that empower authorities to cancel contracts upon the institution of insolvency proceedings. Such actions induce severe organizational anxiety, resulting in a flight of experienced technical and project management personnel. The resultant operational paralysis brings ongoing highway construction to an abrupt halt, forcing formal contract termination by NHAI.
Comprehensive Measures Adopted by NHAI to Mitigate Stress
To prevent value destruction and assist concessionaires in overcoming liquidity constraints, NHAI and the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways (MoRTH) have established nine proactive restructuring interventions:
1. Hybrid Annuity Model (HAM)
Confronted with severe credit tightness in Build-Operate-Transfer (BOT) Toll projects and systemic liquidity constraints in BOT Annuity projects where financial institutions hesitated to take large exposures, MoRTH introduced the Hybrid Annuity Model. Under HAM, NHAI contributes up to 40% of the Bid Project Cost as an inflation-indexed capital grant during construction. This framework effectively eliminates the funding-related time overruns of BOT Annuity models while removing traffic volume risks and competitive corridor threats that previously undermined BOT Toll concessionaire cash flows.
2. Lender Substitution of Concessionaire
Senior lenders, acting through their designated Lenders’ Representative, are contractually empowered to replace an underperforming concessionaire pursuant to a tripartite Substitution Agreement entered into among the Concessionaire, NHAI, and the Lenders’ Representative. Upon substitution, the nominated entity seamlessly steps into the legal shoes of the concessionaire, assuming all contractual rights and obligations. In cases where the concessionaire is in default on the substitution date, NHAI provides a mandatory Cure Period of 120 (one hundred and twenty) days to rectify outstanding breaches.
3. Harmonious Substitution
Where NHAI or senior lenders reasonably apprehend that a concessionaire faces imminent financial distress and will likely breach concession covenants, harmonious substitution may be initiated prior to an actual occurrence of formal default. This acts as a preventive remedy at the onset of initial symptoms before fatal project impairment sets in. The concessionaire may also proactively submit a formal representation to the lenders with a copy to NHAI. Under this mechanism, the identification of the substitute entity and the valuation of existing equity are mutually determined by both the concessionaire and the lenders, drastically minimizing the likelihood of protracted legal disputes.
4. Securitization of Future Surplus Cash Flows
To alleviate equity shortages and inject liquidity into prospective bids and projects under execution, NHAI permits concessionaires of operational BOT assets possessing revenues substantially exceeding debt repayment mandates to raise subordinate debt. This financing can reach up to 30% of the Total Project Cost based on the securitization of projected future surplus cash flows. Contractually, debt servicing for this subordinate borrowing must be subordinated to the last priority in the cash flow waterfall.
5. Deferment of Concession Premium
For BOT projects awarded on a premium or negative grant basis experiencing temporary subsistence revenue deficits, NHAI permits the staggered deferral of annual premium commitments. This ensures vital project liquidity during revenue-stressed periods, with deferred amounts carrying interest until full regularisation.
6. 100% Equity Divestment Policy
Concessionaires awarded projects under standard NHAI procurement processes are permitted 100% equity divestment once construction is completed and a period of 2 years has elapsed. However, during active construction and through the initial two operating years, the lead bidder or consortium members (along with their corporate affiliates) are strictly required to preserve a minimum equity stake of 51% to ensure sponsor accountability.
7. Refinancing and Restructuring of Senior Debt
NHAI facilitates 100% loan refinancing and restructuring to optimize debt service terms, extend maturities, and reduce borrowing costs, conditioned strictly upon verifying that the future contingent termination liabilities of NHAI do not escalate as a consequence of the restructuring.
8. Liberal NOC Issuance for Additional Borrowings
NHAI provides No Objection Certificates (NOCs) to enable concessionaires to secure supplementary borrowing lines for project completion, with the covenant that all debt servicing and principal repayments on such loans maintain junior standing at the lowest tier of the escrow waterfall mechanism.
9. Release of 75% of Arbitral Award Amounts
To rapidly unlock trapped contractor liquidity, NHAI releases 75% of arbitral award sums awarded to concessionaires, even where formal appeals have been preferred before the High Court, against the provision of equivalent Bank Guarantees.
Contractual Termination and Compensation Mechanisms
When proactive measures cannot avert terminal insolvency, the Model Concession Agreement governs formal termination and settlement of terminal liabilities. Under the MCA termination framework, a concessionaire is deemed in default upon failing to cure specified breaches within the designated Cure Period. Fundamental default events include:
- (a) Financial Default: The occurrence of a financial default where the Lenders’ Representative requires NHAI by formal notice to execute Suspension or Termination in terms of the Substitution Agreement, and the default remains uncured after the expiry of the stipulated Cure Period;
- (b) Judicial Insolvency / Bankruptcy: The concessionaire is formally adjudged bankrupt or insolvent, or a trustee or receiver is appointed over all or any material portion of assets essential to the ongoing execution of the project;
- (c) Corporate Dissolution / Restructuring: The concessionaire undergoes liquidation, dissolution, winding-up, amalgamation, or corporate reorganization that, in the reasonable appraisal of NHAI, produces a Material Adverse Effect on the project.
Termination Payment Formulas Under the Model Concession Agreement
The Model Concession Agreement establishes distinct formulas for computing termination payouts payable by NHAI across different fault categories:
| Event of Termination | Termination Payment Payable by NHAI |
|---|---|
| Authority Event of Default | Debt Due + 150% of Adjusted Equity |
| Concessionaire Event of Default | 90% of Debt Due |
| Force Majeure Events |
Non-Political Event: 90% of Debt Due |
|
Indirect Political Event: Debt Due + 110% of Adjusted Equity |
|
|
Political Event: Debt Due + 150% of Adjusted Equity |
The disbursement of all calculated termination proceeds must strictly adhere to the mandatory statutory distribution waterfall established under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 and related IBBI regulations where corporate insolvency proceedings are ongoing. ■
“Luck is a matter of preparation meeting opportunity.”