The Chartered Accountant • Journal of ICAI August 2022 • Vol. 71 • No. 2 • pp. 33–38 (Journal pp. 149–154)
SUSTAINABILITY

Sustainability and how quick companies can start implementation

CA. Shailesh Haribhakti and CA. Suyash Agrawal Authors are members of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI). They may be reached at eboard@icai.in

A Generational Reflection and Urgent Call to Action

Reflecting Across Generations:

Hold on for a minute. Close your eyes. Think. For baby boomers (born 1946-1964) and generation X (born 1965-1980), take this minute to reflect on your childhood and adolescence. What was the world, nature and the climate, like when you were growing up? Now think about what happened between now and then. Is this the world one wants to leave behind for our future generation?

For millennials (born 1981-1996) and generation Z (born 1997-2012), what is the climate impact of our fast-internet, fast-fashion, fast-food, fast-travel, fast-gratification, and fast-life? Is this sustainable? Is this the world our parents brought us in? Where are we headed? Are we so lost in social media that we have forgotten the sounds of birds chirping, the warm embrace of a tree and the ocean breeze?

Through this piece, we want to elicit a response from our decision makers and a call for immediate action from our generation of movers and shakers. We have been presented an unprecedented opportunity to change the course of humanity.

The Multi-Trillion Dollar Sustainable Opportunity:

Massive economic growth, profitability and job creation lies at the heart of this evolution. According to the World Business Council for Sustainable Development (WBCSD), the sustainable economy has the potential to unlock USD 12 trillion in economic value and 380 million jobs by 2030. What we need is collaboration, change in mindsets, technology, and innovation.

Setting this as our prologue, let’s take a deep dive into the world of sustainability and ESG:

Net Zero • ESG • Climate-technology • 1.5 degrees target of the Paris Agreement • Carbon credits • GHG emissions • Green finance • GRI • SASB • BRSR • Integrated Report

The aforementioned are a few terms, most people are hearing these days. Before we get into specific actions to be taken by companies to set themselves on the path of sustainability, it is imperative to understand, how the world economy evolved, what happened to our climate and how we got here.

Evolution of the World Economy and the Social Contract

International trade continued to evolve in the 19th century. Colonialisation was at its peak. Powerful countries from the west exerted their force on weaker ones, exploiting their resources, leaving them with pittance. This started unravelling in the 20th century. This century was marked by two world wars, liberation of several erstwhile colonies, massive post-world war industrialisation, rise of corporations and an unending race to establish supremacy between the Americans and Soviets.

Evolution of the World Economy

Business models, population and rising temperatures are all interlinked

Parameter / Metric Up to the 19th Century 20th Century 21st Century
Dominant Business Model Colonialism Capitalism Entrepreneurialism / Consumerism
Key Drivers Countries and Dynasties Corporations Citizens
Metrics Power Profits Purpose
Population Figures 1850 – 1.2 Bn
1900 – 1.6 Bn
1950 – 2.5 Bn
2000 – 6.1 Bn
2010 – 6.9 Bn
2020 – 7.8 Bn (7x growth)
Global Emissions (CO2) 1850 – 196.9 Mn Tons
1900 – 1.95 Bn Tons
1950 – 6 Bn Tons
2000 – 25.23 Bn Tons
2010 – 31.61 Bn Tons
2020 – 34.91 Bn Tons (176x growth)
Global Mean Annual Temperature 1880s – 13.73°C 1900s – 13.74°C
1960s – 13.99°C
1990s – 14.31°C
2020s – 14.91°C

As we complete, over 70 years since the end of World War II and the formation of United Nations, the 21st century is seeing unprecedented nuclear stockpiles, global warming, mass pandemics and a failing economic agenda. As per the Global Risks Report 2022 by the World Economic Forum, the top 5 risks are either environmental or social.

The answers to most of our questions lie in the evolution of the social contract. The social contract is an implicit agreement on which all societies rest. It is an accord that balances the roles and responsibilities of corporations and states with that of individuals. While the exact terms keep evolving based on the law of a society, the larger idea is to keep humanity harmonised. This contract, in one way or the other is breaking globally.

While every country faces its individual problems, the premise has remained the same. In the “so-called” liberalised economies, corporations started to write rules, making way for monopolies. On one hand, China seemed to have combined top-down authoritarianism with the efficiency of capitalism. The world has never been so polarised before.

As corporations grew bigger, governments in liberalised economies ceded control. Focused on shareholder value, corporations failed to deliver on environmental and social agendas. What we are left with is global warming, unbridled consumer price inflation, fear of constant surveillance, human rights’ violations and mass wealth disparity.

Having failed to deliver on its promise of equitable growth, it is time to reform capitalism. India must lead this reformed and more equitable model of “Conscious Capitalism”. This is where ESG comes in.

ESG stands for:
• E – Environmental Stewardship
• S – Social Responsibility
• G – Purposeful Governance
ESG, sustainability, climate action, impact investing, PRI (Principles of Responsible Investing), called by several names, have multiple overlaps.

ESG is a mindset, a tool or framework to deliver on the promise of “Conscious Capitalism”. An attempt to refocus on stakeholder primacy over shareholder value, to think long-term value over short-term profits, to drive equitable distribution of opportunities and to restore the ecological balance.

What Must Companies Do, How Must They Implement, How Must They Report?

We believe, that the most important for companies is to STOP seeing ESG as an additional burden or cost. It is an opportunity to rethink supply chains, business models and processes, to make them more eco-friendly and future proof. What you see below is our Standard Model of ESG. While we have tried to incorporate everything relevant on one image, the model is continuously evolving.

THE STANDARD MODEL OF ESG: A Journey Beyond Net Zero

Journey Beyond Net Zero ➔ CO2 Net Zero Target ➔ Value Accretion via Sustainable Solutions ➔ Green Finance ➔ Better Ratings
Collaboration
Mindset
Technology
Innovation

Five Exercising Economic Interests: Customers • Governments Around the World • Investors • Bankers • People & Planet

Environmental Stewardship (E)

  • Energy Transition: Carbon capture, carbon sequestration and conversion to energy.
  • Circularity: Reduce, reuse, recycle, and replace.
  • GHG Elimination: Eliminating carbon dioxide, methane, CFCs, and neutralizing nauseous toxic gases at source.
  • Biodiversity Preservation: Reforestation using fruit trees, cleaning air, and rejuvenating water bodies.
Mapped SDGs: 7, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15

Social Responsibility (S)

  • Human Rights: High-quality health, telehealth, mapping genome/microbiome, cloud blood markers & DNA.
  • Basic Services: Education, clean water, sanitation, data privacy, and legal access with minimum latency.
  • DEI: Zero discrimination across caste, creed, religion, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation.
  • Financial Inclusion: Universal Basic Income (UBI) and Universal Basic Services (UBS).
  • Policy Orientation: POSH, whistleblowing, ethical conduct, workplace neutrality, and lifework balance.
Mapped SDGs: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 10

Purposeful Governance (G)

  • Accountability & Auditing: Independent auditing, blockchained accounting, RPA, bot/AI-driven audit, quantum computing.
  • Transparency: Zero latency information transmission across high-power internet networks.
  • Integrated Reporting: ISSB, TCFD, CDP, GRI, VRF, and SEBI BRSR alignment.
  • Anti-Greenwashing: Rigorous heuristics and defined deviation thresholds for credible investor assurance.
  • Conflict Mitigation: Tracing, monitoring, and eliminating Related Party Transactions (RPT) conflicts.
Mapped SDGs: 8, 9, 16, 17
Learning & Info: dial ESG by YOW Communication: TEDx Talks of ESG Comm. ERP & Procurement: SAP Carbon Accounting Impact Showcase: Netflix of Outcomes

Our research across multiple sectors has shown that globally companies that have adopted sustainability with a defined net zero target have managed to attract green finance and better ratings. They implement sustainable solutions that drive enterprise value accretion and report transparently.

We call our model “A Journey Beyond Net Zero”. We are moving towards more natural disasters if we do not change course immediately. Critically important is for all organisations to make their net zero commitments taking into account Scopes 1, 2 and 3. Companies must believe that a change in their business model will lead to better unit economics. Therefore, ESG will take route only by lowering cost of operation. Once you have the definition of your journey it becomes important as a validation to seek green finance and to have objective assessments of your activity through an external rating of credibility.

Risk, Reporting, and Disclosures: The Six Capitals & Global Frameworks

Following the growing support for ESG and Stakeholder capitalism, a whole new era of corporate reporting is emerging with a focus on 6 capitals: Financial, Environmental, Human, Physical, Relationship, and Innovation.

The Five Forces: Planet, People, Customers, Governments, and Investors will operate on Innovation, changed mindsets, and a commitment to a better tomorrow. Unless all of us pull together we won’t achieve the exponential results that we are capable of delivering. The evolving model of Reporting will have Integrated thinking and love for the Planet reflected fully!

Companies must adopt risk management tools that can help:

  • Evaluate gaps between companies’ risk management initiatives and global best practices and implement enhancing actions;
  • Assess materiality and review of priorities;
  • Effectively capture and measure data sets;
  • Commit to science-based commitments and targets;
  • Produce accurate and reliable outcomes and end reports.

Evolution of ESG Reporting in India: NVG (2009) to BRSR

As for India, the transition to ESG reporting started in 2009 with the MCA issuing National Voluntary Guidelines (NVGs) on Corporate Social Responsibility, our first step towards mainstreaming ESG. Since then, ESG reporting in India has continuously evolved. A decade of several iterations has got us to the Business Responsibility and Sustainability Reporting (BRSR) today.

Drawing inspiration from GRI, the BRSR is a comprehensive extension of BRR. Continuous efforts by the SEBI and MCA have demonstrated their intent and commitment towards ESG. Corporates must invest in accurate AI/ML-led data capture to enable reliable reporting. Dedicated efforts to embed ESG in the organisational purpose and culture will create long-term value.

Global Regulations & TCFD Thematic Pillars:

Globally, the UK and US are recognising climate risks and mandating climate reporting like never before. While the UK has gone with data driven disclosures, the US has proposed to draw heavily from the “four pillar” disclosure framework of the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) and Greenhouse Gas Protocols (GHG):

1. Governance
2. Strategy
3. Risk Management
4. Metrics and Targets

Corporations Must Act: The Case of Unilever

While regulators are doing their bit, laws and guidelines mean nothing without honest and committed enforcement. Corporates must implement ESG through the virtuous cycle of measuring, mitigating, monitoring and transparent reporting. This will be enabled by engaging experts, exponential technology solutions and collaborative partnerships.

Future CEOs and Board Members must understand that companies driven by societal purpose have delivered long-term value across key drivers such as sales, brand and reputation, capital access and market value, operational efficiency, talent retention and risk mitigation.

Case Benchmark — Unilever:

Integrating sustainability in its organisational purpose, deep stakeholder engagement and prioritising long term value has delivered profitability, stable shareholder returns and deep penetration in competitive emerging markets.

Focused Implementation: 10 Critical Targets to Eradicate for India at 100 in 2047

While our Standard Model, reporting frameworks and regulations push for adoption of sustainable practices, actual change has to come from within the organisation. Focused efforts on implementing sustainable technologies and solutions that will help decarbonise are the need of the hour. With the commitments at the COP26, the Prime Minister has set the tone at the top; corporates must now absorb, implement, and decarbonise.

To see India becoming great at 100 in 2047, our efforts must be realigned to eradicate the following 10 challenges:

1. Eradicate Construction Waste

Stop construction waste being sent to landfills; enable precision construction using 3D printing and green cement at scale.

2. Eradicate Coal, Oil and Gas

India must transition to become the world’s first completely fossil fuel-free economy at 100.

3. Eradicate Virgin Steel Production

Completely eliminate the production of virgin steel by 2050 through circular metallurgy and green hydrogen.

4. Eradicate Water-Guzzling Crops

Phase out low-margin, water-guzzling crops and reallocate agricultural land to fruit trees at scale.

5. Eradicate Illegal Delays & Transform Jails

Eliminate systemic judicial delays, restore human rights, and transform the prison and correctional apparatus.

6. Eradicate Lack of Access to Education

Deploy digital and high-skill learning infrastructure ubiquitously to eliminate educational deficits.

7. Eradicate Low-Quality Healthcare Access

Eliminate deficient healthcare access through telemedicine, digitized diagnostics, and cloud genomics.

8. Eradicate Newsprint Import

Eliminate timber dependency and newsprint imports through digital publishing and indigenous agro-fibres.

9. Eradicate Lack of Care for Biodiversity

Eradicate neglect of animals, aquatic life, forests, and living ecosystems across all urban and rural spheres.

10. Eradicate Suspicion & Build Mutual Trust

Eliminate societal suspicion among fellow citizens and forge unwavering mutual trust across communities.

Extinction is Closer Than It Seems, Our Time to Act Is Now or Never

A garbage patch thrice the size of France is floating in the Pacific, Australia is reeling under one its worst floods in history and constant drilling in Siberia is causing temperatures to soar.

Imminent Water & Climate Crisis in India:

India faces the probability of one of the worst water crises ever: 35 million people will face coastal flooding and 40% of the population is to face water scarcity [1]. Concentrated efforts to push for fast adoption of sustainable technologies is the only way forward. Governments, corporates (large and small), non-profit organisations (NPOs), professionals, and citizens, must all take note, our planet is on the brink of extinction, an event that happened 65 million years ago.

All governments must immediately push for mass clean-ups of water bodies, zero waste to landfill, waste segregation at source and incentives for full-scale circularity initiatives. At companies and NPOs, from the board to the last employee in the organisation, all must speak only one language of sustainability and climate action.

Only policy formulation will not make the cut anymore. Implementation is the need of the hour. Progress on implementation must be measured, monitored and reported adequately, accurately and communicated transparently. Data and analytics must be available for the world to see in real-time.

We have no time, we can’t take pride and relief in committing to net zero by 2050. While we should have taken action yesterday, all we have now is today and every day.

Conscious Capitalism, Spiritual Heritage & India’s Soft Power

“Conscious Capitalism” is built on a greener planet, far-reaching and inclusive community development and transparent tech-enabled governance. Technology and ESG must fuse together in the context of our innate spiritual teachings to see India rise as the nation with a maximum quantum of soft power.

Official References & Citations

  1. Forbes India / IPCC Report Analysis on Global Warming Economic Impacts: India can face 92% GDP loss by 2100 due to global warming (IPCC Report)