Taxation of the Digital Economy
The author is a member of the Institute. He can be reached at vivekrajup@yahoo.co.in and eboard@icai.in
The advent of information technology has changed the way business is conducted across the globe. There is a complete disregard of geographical barriers. New business models which have not been envisaged by international tax rules have been deployed. These models don’t require them to be even physically present to do business in a country. Nexus based on physical presence is no longer relevant these days, which was the foundation of most tax conventions. Substantial valuation is derived by companies from the data and information collected, transmitted and exchanged through the digital channels. The proliferation of internet in emerging economies coupled by lower cost of devices greatly increased the market reach of digital companies. Companies like Amazon, Google, Netflix and Facebook only operate on digital space and mostly need no physical presence for their activities.
OECD – BEPS Project
The Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), began to delve on the intricacies of taxation in the digital economy. Globalization meant that domestic tax policies, cannot be designed in isolation it needs revamped approach and cooperation among jurisdictions for mutual benefit. The increasing interconnectivity among global economies, particularly due to digital means exposed the gaps that can be created by interactions between domestic laws. Hence, OECD felt a pressing need to complement rules with a fundamentally new set of standards to establish international coherence in corporate taxation.
The first action plan of OECD BEPS project was to address the tax challenges of the digital economy. The aim was to identify the main difficulties from digital economy for application of the current international tax rules. It required a holistic approach on this subject and considers both direct and indirect taxes. The main focus areas have been around significant digital presence in another economy without taxation due to nexus under current rules, attribution of value created from generation of marketable location relevant data, application of related source rules, etc.
Some of the solutions proposed in other action plans to deal with this issue have been:
- Modification of the definition of Permanent Establishment (PE).
- Review of PE exceptions and introduce new anti-fragmentation rules.
- Updates to transfer pricing guidance related to intangibles.
- CFC rules to tax digital income in the jurisdiction of ultimate parent.
OECD also spent efforts on indirect taxes side, as there are challenges pertaining to Value Added Tax (VAT) collection, where goods, services and intangibles are acquired by private consumers from overseas entities.
The final report for BEPS Action Plan 1 – Chapter 4 deals with sectors which are impacted by the digital economy. It specifies among others certain business models like ecommerce, digital payment services, online advertising, cloud computing, digital platforms, etc. These models make it possible to conduct significant business in any geography with minimal or no personnel. The business is conducted across the internet and servers and intellectual property are mostly located in offshore tax free offshore locations. The business is structured to ensure that profits accrue in entities which are located in tax holiday jurisdictions or have tax incentives.
Indian Initiatives
On the domestic front the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT), has constituted a committee under the chairmanship of Mr. Kanwaljit Singh way back in 1999, with the objective of examining the projected growth of ecommerce and whether it should be taxed. The committee in its 2001 report had no reliable data either in India or elsewhere to estimate the size of ecommerce business, but opined that for the sake of uniformity with traditional commerce, there should be no case for exemption of ecommerce from direct taxes. It also mentioned that cross border ecommerce transactions need to be examined for incidence of tax and mechanism for levy and collection.
The committee also noted that ‘Base Erosion’ approach in the form of a low ‘Withholding tax’ for any payment to a foreign enterprise with the option of being offset by tax on net income by the receiver in his country is a workable option. It has been recommended that CBDT should examine this option and the implementation mechanism.
CBDT has set-up another Committee on taxation of e-commerce to examine the business models for ecommerce under the Chairmanship of Sri Akhilesh Ranjan. The said Committee submitted its report in March 2016. This report was taken into consideration for Finance Bill, 2016. It provides a view on issues related to taxation of e-commerce and recent international developments in this area.
Committee’s key observations were– Redundancy of physical presence in other tax jurisdictions, characterising the payments for digital goods and services, significant challenges to levy taxes in the source jurisdiction, unfair advantage over domestic players and the necessity of withholding tax on digital transactions and Equalisation Levy.
Its key recommendations were –
- Equalisation Levy may be imposed on payments to non-residents by a separate chapter in the Finance Act, 2016
- Levy at 6% to 8% should be applicable on specified digital services
- Levy should be at gross value received by non-resident in all cases where it exceeds Rs 1 lakh from a resident or PE of a non-resident based in India
- No levy on PE of non-resident in India
- The definition of business connection in Section 9 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 may be expanded to include the concept of significant economic presence
The Central Government introduced an ‘Equalisation Levy’ on online advertisement and services under Chapter VIII in the Finance Act, 2016 with effect from 1st June 2016. The levy showed good progress and it collected ₹ 315 crore in FY 2016-17 and ₹ 700 crore in FY 2017-18. Successively, there have been recommendations to extend it to the whole gamut of international transactions like website hosting, cloud services, etc., however, the government has not taken any action in this regard as of date. It was widely expected that the scope of this levy along with the rates may be increased in subsequent budgets, however such a move has not happened as of date.
However, to establish a business connection, still required physical presence of non-resident or its agent in India. This requirement of having physical presence for constituting a PE has already outlived its shelf life and is no longer relevant in the digital age. Yet the tax regulation was still to catch up with the changes in the business models to make it more robust. Significant revenues are derived just using digital platforms that lie outside India and hence cannot fit into the definitions given in the act.
Significant Economic Presence
The Finance Bill, 2018 introduced a new Explanation 2A to Section 9(1)(i) to expand the scope of “Business Connection” by introducing a new concept “Significant Economic Presence” (SEP). It is worth noting that this was an import from OECD BEPS Action Plan 1, which defines significant economic presence as an option to create taxable presence in a country on the basis of certain factors that evidence a sustained interaction with the economy of that country through technology.
SEP expands the scope of income of non-residents, which accrues or arises in India. Activities such as downloading of data or software in India, continuous business activities in India and interaction with users in India through digital means will be considered as SEP.
Finance Act 2018 defines Significant Economic Presence as:
a. Transaction in respect of any goods, services or property carried out by a non-resident in India including provision of download of data or software in India, if the aggregate of payments arising from such transaction or transactions during the previous year exceeds such amount as may be prescribed; or
b. Systematic and continuous soliciting of business activities or engaging in interaction with such number of users as may be prescribed, in India through digital means.
It further mentions that significant economic presence is not impacted for the fact whether the agreements for transactions or activities thereof have been entered in India, the non-resident has a residence or place or business in India or whether the non-resident renders services in India.
Further the second provisio to Explanation 2A to Section 9(1)(i) of the Act, only the income attributable to transactions or activities that constitute SEP will be deemed to accrue or arise in India. The profit attribution rules earlier needed guidance. On 18th April 2019 the CBDT released a recommendatory report on attribution of profits to PE, in order to solicit views from stakeholders. The government will soon come out with the rules in this aspect hopefully bringing much needed clarity on this aspect for the department to take subjective decisions as per the rules laid out.
However, it is also to be noted that Section 90(2) of IT Act provides that the provisions of Income-tax Act, 1961 or DTAA, whichever is more beneficial to the taxpayer shall prevail. As such the amendment in the Finance Act, 2018 will not have any impact with respect to taxation on the digital economy transactions in India. The exiting treaty provisions are more beneficial to non-residents and ecommerce companies and as such will override the tax law. The provisions enacted will be effective only when amendments giving effect to significant economic presence are made in the treaties, else this concept would remain relegated to the domestic law without any use. The memorandum to Finance Bill, 2018 also mentions the fact that unless corresponding modifications to PE rules are made in the DTAAs, the cross border business profits will continue to be taxed as per the existing treaty rules.
Other Initiatives
There are other initiatives also which will render the digital economy move base to India and thus subject itself to taxation. The government and authorities are working on data security and privacy of data originating and belonging to Indians. Some of the measures in this regard have been:
Payment Systems: On 6th April 2018 RBI issued a circular on storage of payment system data. The circular aims to ensure safety and security of customer information. This circular mandates the storage only in India of data pertaining to payment systems operated by system providers. International card companies, fintech payment service providers currently use international servers to store and process data, all these companies will now be required to have a local server and store the data, which will automatically render create a business connection and establish a PE for them in India. In October 2018, companies like Visa, Mastercard and Amazon mentioned that they are maintaining the data locally, and data outside India pertaining to Indians will be deleted.
Data Protection Bill: The central government has introduced the Personal Data Protection Bill, 2018, the bill introduces the data localisation concept wherein every entity processing personal data shall ensure the storage thereof on a server or a data center located in India of at least one copy of the personal data to which the act applies. The central government however can notify certain categories of personal data as critical personal data that shall only be processed in a server or data center located in India. The bill is likely to be taken up in the Parliament by Government shortly. This will also result in having servers of the foreign companies located outside India, and establish permanent establishments and nexus in India, provided the functions are performed through the server. If data like mobile numbers, location, addresses, credit card / wallet info are notified as critical, this will mean companies like Uber will have to maintain the data on Indian servers only in which case a PE gets created.
Draft e-Commerce Policy
On February 24, 2019 the government has introduced the draft national e-commerce policy. The primary focus therein has been centralisation of data arising in India and use of the same for national development. The draft proposes that e-commerce websites and social media companies store customer data exclusively in India. If the policy is implemented it will require data localisation in certain cases and result in some form of nexus for e commerce companies with India.
India will have to amend individual treaties which take long time, however the government may try to renegotiate only those treaties which are the need of the hour with the jurisdictions which contribute to the digital economy. Further the Multilateral Instrument (MLI) route can be explored for a quicker resolution in this regard. These changes will ensure that those entities which are not subject to data localization or are by passing these norms through means are brought under the purview of taxation. This will vastly enhance the tax base for the government and offers scope for rationalised tax structures.
Conclusion
Similar to India, a lot of other countries are working on taxing the digital economy. In March 2018, the European Union proposed a 3% excise tax on turnover from certain online activities as a temporary levy till long term international agreements on how to tax digital profits is arrived. However no progress has been made here as yet due to objections from countries like Ireland, Sweden and Denmark. If passed though highly unlikely, the tax will come into effect from January 2021.
However, independent of EU, France introduced a new law in March 2019 to collect 3% tax on digital revenues from France. The UK is working on its tax from 2020 for a 2% tax on similar lines. Austria, Spain and Italy are working on their own versions of the above tax.
Singapore in November 2018, amended the GST law to bring into ambit digital services like software, online subscription fees, video streaming etc. The tax is to come into effect from January 2020. A similar amendment is made in Malaysia’s new Sales and Service Tax (SST) to tax digital transactions from January 2020.
Elsewhere other countries are working on coming up with their own forms of tax to get digital revenues under the tax net to ensure parity and level playing field for online and traditional companies and thereby widen the tax base.
Countries are currently working on short term fixes to the tax laws, any long term resolution is bound to take time and lengthy negotiations due to the high stakes involved in this area.