Executive Perspective

An intra-group service is a service performed by one member of a multinational group for the benefit of one or more group companies. Considering the international environment and increasing competition, multinational enterprises (MNEs) are required to provide a range of services within the group in order to ensure better synergies, efficiency, economies of scale, and confidentiality. In addition, the creation of intra-group service centers to centralise service offerings in the group has been the trend of recent years. Accordingly, there is no need for group members to separately outsource different services to third parties.

IGS Charges: Definition and Categorisation

An intra-group service is a service performed by one member of a multinational group for the benefit of one or more group companies. Considering the international environment and increasing competition, the multinational enterprises (MNEs) are required to provide range of services within the group in order to ensure better synergies, efficiency, economies of scale and confidentiality. In addition, the creation of intra-group service centers to centralise the service offering in the group has been the trend of the recent years. Accordingly, there is no need for group members to separately outsource different services to third parties.

Following is the illustrative list of services that are generally categorised as IGS:

  • Administrative services;
  • Management services;
  • HR related services;
  • Financial services;
  • Legal services;
  • Information technology services.

Chapter VII of the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines 2017

OECD transfer pricing guidelines address two issues1: (1) Determining whether IGS have been provided including benefit test (i.e. demonstrating receipt of benefits based on evidences), and (2) Whether IGS charge is in accordance with the arm’s length principles.

1 Para 7.5 of OECD TP Guidelines 2017

As per the OECD guidance2, IGS must provide economic or commercial value/ benefit, which would enhance commercial position of service recipient. This can be determined by considering whether an independent enterprise would pay for the activity, if performed for it by an independent enterprise or if the activity is performed in-house and the same results in direct or indirect benefits. Once it is determined that IGS have been rendered, it is essential that reliable documentation should be maintained which can be provided to tax authorities for verifying that the services have actually been rendered by the service provider. In order to determine the arm’s length charge for such IGS, OECD has suggested3 use of CUP or cost-based method as the most appropriate method to determine arm’s length charge for such services.

2 Para 7.6 of OECD TP Guidelines 2017
3 Para 7.31 of OECD TP Guidelines 2017

Under cost based methods, first step is to determine cost pool of service charges which can be allocated to group entities. While determining allocable costs, costs incurred in relation to shareholder activities, duplicative services, services providing incidental benefits to other group members should be excluded. Further, while determining appropriate mark-up to be charged, economic alternatives available to the recipient of the service should be considered. Then allocable costs, which can be directly allocable to a particular group entity as a result of specific services provided, should be allocated to all such group entities. Balance allocable costs should then, be allocated between all group entities using appropriate allocation keys.

OECD Analytical Framework for Intra-Group Services

Non-Chargeable Activities (Exclusions from Cost Pool)

  • Shareholder activity: Activity performed by Group member solely because of its ownership interest.
  • Duplicative services: Activity performed by Group member that merely duplicates a service that other Group member is performing for itself or availing from third party.
  • Incidental benefits: Activity performed by Group member which relates only to some Group members but incidentally provides benefits to other Group members.
  • Passive association benefits: Incidental benefit attributable solely to an entity’s association and linkages with other entities that are part of an MNE.
Result: No Intra-Group Services / Non-Chargeable

Chargeable Services & Arm’s Length Allocation

Benefit Test Satisfied: Yes → To be allocated to group entities.

Most Appropriate Method: CUP or Cost Plus Method (CPM) (Preferred, but difficult to apply).

Two-Step Cost Allocation Process:

  • Step 1 (Direct Charge Method): Directly attributable costs charged to specific Group entities.
  • Step 2 (Indirect Charge Method): Balance cost allocated to all Group entities using allocation keys.

Mark-Up Determination (Economic Alternatives Evaluated):

  • Pass Through Cost: No mark-up since no service element.
  • Low Value-Added Services: Maximum 5% mark-up.
  • High Value-Added Services: Mark-up to be supported by benchmarking study.

Low Value Adding IGS (LVA-IGS)

The revised OECD TP Guidelines 2017 introduced an elective, simplified approach for low value-adding services. As per the guidance, ‘low value-adding IGS’ (LVA-IGS)4 are services which are:

  • Supportive in nature;
  • Not part of core business of the group;
  • Do not use or create unique and valuable intangibles; and
  • Do not involve significant risk.

4 Para 7.45 of OECD TP Guidelines 2017

A Group which elects to apply simplified approach is required to identify, on an annual basis, pool of costs (direct as well as indirect) associated with categories of LVA-IGS which are provided to multiple members of its group (excluding costs related to shareholder activity, services performed solely on behalf of one other group member). The costs so identified need to be allocated among members by selecting appropriate allocation keys depending on nature of services. The guidance provides 5% mark-up on costs (excluding pass through costs) to be used for all LVA-IGS, irrespective of categories of services and the same does not need to be justified by benchmarking study. Further, the guidance has specified for simplified benefit test, whereby the taxpayer needs to demonstrate only the fact that assistance was provided along-with sufficient evidence that the benefit test is met.

Further, under US regulations as well there is simplified approach provided for ‘low margin covered services’ where an elective method i.e. ‘Services Cost Method’ (SCM)5 has been prescribed. Under SCM, covered services which includes low margin services can be charged out at cost. In such case, commissioner’s allocation will be limited to adjusting the amount charged for such services to the properly determined amount of the total services cost. For low margin services, a minimum median mark-up of 7% on cost has been prescribed.

5 Section 1.482-9(b) of Treasury Regulation

Under Indian TP regulations, there are no detailed guidelines for determination of Arm’s Length Price (ALP) for IGS. However, pursuant to the OECD Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS) Action Plan 8-10, Indian Revenue Authorities (IRA) introduced new category of LVA-IGS under safe harbour regime prescribing maximum threshold of INR 10 crores (~USD 1.4 million) in respect of transaction value and maximum mark-up of 5% to consider the same at arm’s length.

Stranded Cost

At the international arena also, IGS are being scrutinized in detail by the revenue authorities, since they may have an assertion that some MNEs may consider using these transactions to optimize taxes by way of repatriation of funds. Therefore, IGS transactions have caught the interest of tax authorities and are being constantly monitored.

Tax authorities of home country (i.e. country of service provider), usually take a view that a particular service is clearly for the benefit of other group entities, which are enjoying higher quality and reliability than would be possible from engaging a local low-cost service provider, and accordingly, should be charged back along-with appropriate mark-up on the same. In case where costs are not charged back to Group entities, they could question the relevance of such costs to the business of the service provider, thereby, possibly, denying the tax deduction for such costs. On the other hand, tax authorities of recipient country thoroughly scrutinise the payments, corresponding economic benefit and in case they are not satisfied, they take a view that no deduction should be allowed on the ground that it lacks commercial expediency. This situation is referred to as “Stranded Cost” where the tax authorities of service provider country challenge the deductibility, if not recharged and the tax authorities of the service receiving country challenge the deductibility/ arm’s length nature for lack of evidences and service valuation. As a consequence of disagreements between tax administrations of the service provider and service recipient, there lies a risk of double taxation.

IGS from Perspective of IRA & India Litigation Experience

As mentioned above, apart from reference in the definition of ‘International Transaction’, there are no detailed guidelines for determination of ALP for IGS in Indian TP regulations. In the absence of detailed guidelines, principles provided in OECD guidelines are generally referred. Transfer Pricing Officers (TPOs), while analyzing IGS transactions usually look into commercial necessity of availing intra-group services, benefits derived and evidences in support of the same. Accordingly, IGS transactions are usually scrutinised from the perspective of:

  • Need test: Commercial necessity for availing services from group companies;
  • Evidence test: Evidence to support actual receipt of services from group company;
  • Benefit test: Benefits derived from service fee (cost – benefit analysis); and
  • Quantification test: Analysing the allocation keys, nature of expenses allocated, justification of mark-ups (if any).

In the absence of satisfactory justification to the above tests, the TPOs have historically considered the arm’s length price of payment of IGS charges as ‘Nil’. Further, Assessing Officers (AO) look into genuineness of the transaction and as a part of this exercise ask for justification of the payment of service charges, benefits derived out of payment, etc and usually contend as to whether the expenditure is incurred wholly and exclusively for the purpose of business to consider deductibility of the same under section 37(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (the Act). Unless taxpayers provide convincing evidences, possibility to get relief from appellate authorities is usually less.

There are several rulings pronounced in favour of taxpayers by ITAT, the ‘final fact finding authority’, however, in most cases matters have been remanded back with instructions to the lower tax authorities for verification. Accordingly, it takes several years (approximately 10 to 12 years) to reach finality and all the subsequent years get piled up under litigation, since field officers, typically, follow same adjustment approach for subsequent years till the issue achieves certainty, thereby, giving rise to in significant efforts and substantial cost. Further, funds are blocked for a substantial period on account of requirement to pay partial/ full demand before filing an appeal before the appellate authority.

Alternative Dispute Resolution Mechanisms (ADRs) – Options Worth Evaluation!

Given the protracted and cascading litigation around IGS, ADR mechanisms like Advance Pricing Agreement (APA), Mutual Agreement Procedure (MAP) and Safe Harbour Rules (SHR) are worth evaluation, to achieve certainty, avoid double taxation and save significant time and efforts involved under traditional litigation procedure. Following is the snapshot of the ADRs vis-à-vis IGS:

Advance Pricing Agreement (APA)

  • Offers time certainty, provides certainty for a period of 9 years (5 years + 4 years roll back option) and unilateral possible with less efforts.
  • Bilateral/Multilateral APA also help to avoid double taxation within group.
  • Roll back not available for a particular year, if the Tribunal has passed an order in relation to covered international transaction in case of Taxpayer.
  • Approximate time: 3.5–4.0 months for Unilateral & 28–34 months for Bilateral.
  • As per APA annual report for FY 2017-18, 12% of the Unilateral applications and 18% of the Bilateral applications were pertaining to IGS.

Mutual Agreement Procedure (MAP)

  • Resolves disputes relating to taxation not in accordance with DTAA and helps in resolving economic double taxation.
  • MAP can be pursued simultaneously with domestic litigation.
  • Taxpayers have an option to accept or reject resolution under MAP and MAP resolution, once accepted by Taxpayer, is binding on Revenue.
  • Approximate time: 2–3 years for reaching a resolution.

Safe Harbour Rules (SHR)

  • In June 2017, CBDT amended SHR and introduced new category of ‘receipt of LVA-IGS’, in line with OECD BEPS Action Plan 8-10.
  • Definition of LVA-IGS is largely in line with OECD guidelines except the exclusion of IT services, BPO services, KPO services and purchase activities from the scope of LVA-IGS and SHR can be opted in the absence of other/unfavourable comparable companies; these appear to be stringent and scope limiting conditions.
  • Applicable to service recipients in India.
  • Maximum threshold of INR 10 crores (transaction value), prescribed as eligibility criteria to apply for SHR.
  • The allocation of service cost using cost pooling method and reasonableness of allocation keys to be certified by Chartered Accountant of foreign AE.
  • Maximum mark-up of 5% on cost has been prescribed.

Suggested Best Practices

Though there are ADRs as mentioned above, MNEs may consider the following best practices to justify the IGS charge:

  1. Scientific study of services incurred for benefit of the group, creation of cost centres for quantification of total cost incurred for each category of service along-with differentiation between high and low value added services, identification & quantification of stewardship/ shareholder/ duplicative costs for their exclusion from allocable cost base;
  2. Identification of scientific allocation keys for each category of service like headcount for payroll service, numbers of PC in use/ users for technology services/ license cost, cost of goods for strategic product planning, turnover for marketing support, finance services, etc.;
  3. A benchmarking study should be in place in support of mark-up to be charged on intra-group services;
  4. Inter-company agreements should be in place documenting roles and responsibilities in relation to intra-group services;
  5. A detailed working to be prepared and certified at year end, providing costs incurred by service provider(s), identification and exclusion of shareholder/ duplicative costs, identification of directly allocable costs to specific group entities, service category-wise cost pool of allocable costs and final cost allocation to various group entities using appropriate allocation keys;
  6. The service provider should also maintain evidences in support of services rendered along-with detailed cost allocation model as mentioned above;
  7. The service recipient should collate evidences in support of actual receipt of services and benefits derived, wherever possible. For example, the benefits from services in the nature of customer relationship services, marketing support services would be new contracts/ agreements entered into with customers, expansion of customer base, increase in sales, etc. In support of the same, service recipient could consider maintaining copies of customer correspondence, contracts/ agreements entered into with customers (existing/ new);
  8. Companies can explore technological tools that could be available and which are designed to collate details/ evidences like emails from system on a real time basis which can save time and efforts involved in collating details at the time of audit proceedings;
  9. Based on the facts of the case, company should evaluate alternate dispute resolution options that could be explored along-with cost-benefit analysis.

Pitfalls to be Watched Out

• Withholding Requirements

The reimbursement of expenses, being pass-through costs, ideally should not lead to withholding requirements by service recipient. However, such reimbursements do attract withholding implications, if in the first place, withholding is required. Further, as per OECD guidance on LVA-IGS, the withholding of tax should be done only on the mark-up element6. However, service recipient generally deducts tax on whole amount on a conservative basis in light of a possible disallowance under section 40(a)(i) of the Act, considering the rate which is lower of the rate as per domestic laws or as per DTAA. Further, if the contract for payment of management fees stipulates for a single consideration for services which also includes ‘out of pocket’ expenses, the same may lead to withholding requirement on entire amount i.e. taxation at gross level. This is generally the case of non-separable costs, for example in case of IT support services the service charge may include cost for certain licenses purchased for all group entities along-with its implementation and training for employees/ users.

6 Para 7.65 of OECD TP Guidelines 2017

In India, there is controversy around determination of nature of such expenses in view of scope of ‘fees for technical services (FTS)’ especially where there are favourable treaty provisions in terms of “make available” clause (applicable in case of DTAA with certain countries like USA, UK etc, whereby the payments should be treated as “FTS” only when non-resident makes available technical knowledge, experience, skill, know-how or processes or transfers technical plan or technical design). There are certain adverse judicial precedents to taxpayers pronounced by courts whereby it is positioned that management services in the nature of business development, risk management, customer/ public relation services, staff training, tax planning advice, implementation of global IT policies and systems etc, received by an entity, including services those are enabling such entity in its decision making process should be regarded as FTS [Cochin ITAT decision in case of US Technology Resources Private Limited, ruling pronounced by Authority for Advance Rulings (AAR) in case of Intertek Testing Services India (P) Limited]. The ruling of AAR in the case of Intertek gives an open room to IRA to cover many of the executive, managerial and consultancy services within the ambit of FTS under the treaty, accordingly, litigation on classification of some of the proposed services as satisfying ‘make available’ condition cannot be ruled out particularly at field level. In such case, taxpayers may consider filing an application before IRA for lower withholding or filing an application before AAR in order to determine withholding applicability. If litigation is faced, a MAP as an ADR should be actively considered.

• Foreign Tax Credit (FTC)

Withholding of taxes on IGS by service recipient on ‘Gross Basis’ and taxability of the same in the country of residence of service provider on ‘Net Basis’ could lead to tax leakage. This has been explained below with the help of an illustration:

Sr. No. Particulars Service recipient (I Co) Service provider (F Co)
1 Intra-group service charges received by F Co from I Co
- Income offered in country of residence of F Co (profit element) - Amount on which taxes withheld by I Co
100 20
2 Taxes withheld by I Co. (@ 10%) 10 -
3 Tax on Income in country of residence of F Co. (@ 30%) - 6
4 Less: Foreign Tax Credit: Proportionate - (6)
5 Total taxes paid 10 0
6 Possible tax leakage (10 - 6) 4

• Permanent Establishment (PE) Exposure

The evidences provided by taxpayers in support of receipt of IGS usually include emails, presentations, minutes of call/ meeting, records of conference calls, invoices in relation to travelling expenses of employees visiting India for providing services, training material, internal manuals and policy documents, etc. However, one needs to be mindful of potential PE exposure in such a case. Considering the fact that, as a part of rendering services to Indian entity, employees of foreign entity might have to visit India and the same may lead to service PE exposure in case presence of these employees in India exceeds specified number of days as per the respective treaty. Further, the recent decision of Bangalore ITAT in case of ABB FZ LLC has introduced concept of ‘Virtual Service PE’ whereby, services provided through virtual modes such as internet, email, video conferencing, remote access to the desktop, etc should be taken in account for determining service PE exposure and this is relevant in today’s technology era. Although BEPS action plans have not provided for taxing virtual PE, a litigation on this point can’t be ruled out.

• Secondary Adjustment

From financial year 2016-17 onwards, in case of primary TP adjustment (exceeding INR 1 crore) resulted from voluntary declaration by taxpayer in its return of income, or made by tax officer and accepted by taxpayer, or made as per SHR, or determined by an APA, or resulted from resolution under MAP, the excess money (i.e. difference between ALP as per primary adjustment and transaction price) needs to be repatriated to Indian taxpayer by its AE within prescribed time. Failing this, such ‘excess money’ would be deemed to be an advance made by the taxpayer to such AE and notional interest on such advance would be computed that would be taxable in the hands of taxpayer. This may pose practical challenges where the fees paid may need to be repaid by the service provider to the extent of the TP adjustment faced by the service recipient which may also be challenged by the tax authorities of service provider.

Concluding Thoughts

IGS — a soft charge with hard facts around litigation may lead to challenges which could range from loss of FTC to PE exposure to double taxation to secondary TP adjustment. Accordingly, a detailed study, robust documentation is necessary & strategy to get certainty through ADRs becomes a need of the hour.

About the Authors

CA. Amit Dhadphale and CA. Abhishek Apte are members of the Institute. They can be reached at addhadphale@gmail.com or abhi.apte89@gmail.com.