The Income Tax Slabs Conundrum
The Illusion of Simplicity in India’s Tax Slabs
“The Income Tax Slabs in India at times may appear to be simple but aren’t, especially after the amendments made in last year’s budget on 01st Feb 2021, where new rates of Income Tax u/s 115BAC were introduced subject to no allowance of standard deductions for Salary and deductions u/s 80C, 80D etc. As per the new scheme, If Total Income of an individual assessee is Rs 15 lakh, Tax Payable is Rs 195000 as per the new rates and tax payable as per old rates is Rs 257400. Benefits arising to the taxpayer here is Rs 62400. However, this benefit is only achievable if assessee is in the Rs 13 -15 lakh bracket and has no real deductions under 80C/80D. Frankly, which salaried Employee in this income bracket would not have deductions like school fees, LIC, repayment of principal and interest on housing loans, Mediclaim and how many such assesses actually get the tax benefit remains to be seen. But if one were to closely analyse the tax slabs in India, a lot of other interesting, confusing and heart-breaking facts come out.”
1. Comparative Slab Structures: Old Scheme vs. Section 115BAC New Scheme
Currently the Income Tax slabs structure under the old scheme is as follows. Let us look at the old scheme first, as a majority of assessees have not opted for the new scheme:
| Income Tax Slab (Old Scheme) | Rate in Percentage (%) |
|---|---|
| Upto Rs 2,50,000 | 0% (Nil) |
| Rs 2,50,000 – Rs 5,00,000 | 5% (with rebate u/s 87A upto Rs 12,500 for income upto Rs 5 lakh) |
| Rs 5,00,000 – Rs 10,00,000 | 20% |
| Above Rs 10,00,000 | 30% |
With the rebate given u/s 87A, income up to Rs 5 lakh will have no tax liability. Now, let us look at the new scheme introduced u/s 115BAC:
| Income Tax Slab (New Scheme u/s 115BAC) | Rate in Percentage (%) |
|---|---|
| Upto Rs 2,50,000 | 0% (Nil) |
| Rs 2,50,000 – Rs 5,00,000 | 5% (with rebate u/s 87A upto Rs 12,500 for income upto Rs 5 lakh) |
| Rs 5,00,000 – Rs 7,50,000 | 10% |
| Rs 7,50,000 – Rs 10,00,000 | 15% |
| Rs 10,00,000 – Rs 12,50,000 | 20% |
| Rs 12,50,000 – Rs 15,00,000 | 25% |
| Above Rs 15,00,000 | 30% |
For example: If an individual assessee’s Total income is Rs 5,02,000, his tax liability will be Rs 12,900 plus 4% education cess, thereby leaving him with Rs 4,88,500 approx in his pocket. Whereas if an individual assessee has total income of Rs 4,95,000, his tax liability will be Nil. It effectively means that a person earning Rs 4,95,000 ends up richer than a person earning Rs 5,02,000.
2. Stagnation in Tax Returns: F.Y. 2016-17 vs. F.Y. 2020-21 Data
In F.Y 2016-17, the data released by the Income Tax Department showed that out of 3.6 crore people that had filed tax returns, nearly 1 crore reported an income less than the income tax exemption limit of 2.5 lakhs at the time.
Five years later, the situation in F.Y 2020-21 has not changed much either. Interestingly, nowhere in the budget speech on 1st Feb 2022, the number of returns filed for F.Y 2020-21 and the gross income tax receipts from these returns were mentioned. It is obvious that because of the pandemic, these numbers are way lower than the estimates despite taxing Dividend at highest rates in the hands of the recipient and bringing tax on Long Term capital gains at the rate of 10% a couple of years back.
3. Economic Survey Findings: 7 Taxpayers Per 100 Voters
The Economic Survey produced by the Chief Economic Adviser Arvind Subramanian in F.Y 2016-17 substantiated that India had only 7 income tax payers out of every 100 voters, among the lowest of all G20 democracies. Less than 3 percent Indians pay Income tax is an established common parlance and this percentage unfortunately has not changed much in the last 5 years.
“Instead of having 7 taxpayers out of every 100 voters, India with this change in tax slabs can easily have 25-30 taxpayers for every 100 voter in the next 3-5 years.”
India is an extremely poor country with a per capita GDP of less than Rs 1.5 lakh (i.e. an average Indian earns Rs 1.5 lakh per year which is sadly even lesser than that of Bangladesh), whereas the income tax threshold for paying income tax is Rs 5 lakh considering the rebate given u/s 87A for income between 2.5 lakh–5 lakh. Which means people earning Rs 5 lakh or below need not pay any income tax. While the average Indian earns Rs 1.5 lakh, an income tax exemption of Rs 5 lakh removes a sizeable majority of the population from the requirement of paying any income tax.
If lowering the income tax rate to 5% would have been coupled with lowering income tax exemption, we would have added more taxpayers. But sadly, that is not the case and there is absolutely no indication from the government that this precarious scenario will change in the near future.
4. The Rs 2.5–5 Lakh Bracket: Over 75% of India’s Working Population Legally Exempt
This bracket of Rs (2.5 - 5 lakh) comprises more than 75 percent of India’s entire working population, consisting of:
If we would be able to get them under the tax net by removing the rebate u/s 87A at a nominal rate of 5%, we can double the nation’s income tax collections within 3-5 years. This will not only lead to parity or rationalization in tax laws but increased compliance and increased participation from taxpayers at large.
Instead of having 7 taxpayers out of every 100 voters, India with this change in tax slabs can easily have 25-30 taxpayers for every 100 voters in the next 3-5 years. This could be one kind of financial inclusion in a true sense which the government over the last 7 years has been bragging about. Having said that, it is imperative to bear in mind that taxation, if levied to lower income class cannot be at the benefit of the super-rich class because that will not justify social distribution.
5. Global Comparison: Exemption Threshold vs. Per Capita GDP Ratio
It is interesting to note here that the average ratio across 20 developed and developing countries is 0.5 — i.e., the income tax exemption threshold is only half of its per capita GDP.
Whereas back home, it’s the reverse. It is more than 3 times that of per capita GDP, which means even if the per capita GDP were to double or triple in the next 3-5 years, it will still be less than the income tax exemption limit, and doubling or tripling of per capita income will lead to no increase in the amount of income tax collected.
6. Salaried Case Study: How an Annual Income of Rs 7.2 Lakh Pays Zero Tax
Let us compare that with India where say for example, a person earning a salary of Rs 60,000 per month would have an annual income of Rs 7,20,000. Assuming he or she has no other income and his savings bank interest of less than Rs 10,000 is already deducted u/s 80TTA, his total income is Rs 7,20,000.
| Computation Component / Deductions Claimed | Amount in Rs |
|---|---|
| Gross Annual Salary Income (Rs 60,000 × 12) | 7,20,000 |
| Less: Deduction u/s 80C (LIC premium, housing loan principal, school fees for 2 kids) | (1,50,000) |
| Less: Deduction u/s 80D (Mediclaim premium for self/family) | (25,000) |
| Less: Deduction u/s 80CCD(1B) (National Pension System - NPS) | (50,000) |
| Total Deductions Claimed | (2,25,000) |
| Net Total Taxable Income | 4,95,000 |
| Tax Payable after Section 87A Rebate | NIL (Rs 0) |
School fees of two children in a metro area in India in today’s time itself easily exceeds Rs 1,50,000. Therefore, his net total income comes to Rs 4,95,000 because of which he is liable to pay zero tax. A person earning up to Rs 60,000 per month is not required to legally pay any income tax in India. That accounts for more than 75% of the working population. The law itself, which was originally meant to help small taxpayers reduce the burden of tax, automatically and legally exempts more than 75% of the country’s working population from paying income tax.
7. The Vicious Economic Cycle: Under-Collected Direct Tax vs. Exorbitant Fuel Taxes
Another way of looking at this: India collects Income Tax roughly about less than half of its potential and this automatically puts pressure on the Government in terms of borrowings and managing fiscal deficits. It then leads to them increasing indirect taxes on oil and various other commodities, thus ever rising exorbitant fuel prices which lead to:
It is like a vicious cycle. So much so that fuel in India as on today is dearer than some of the underdeveloped Asian Economies and it does not look like we are going to be out of this situation any time soon.
8. The Public Value Trade-off: Rs 12,250 Tax vs. Rs 20,000–25,000 Inflation Savings
From both examples given earlier, when an assessee earning Rs 4,95,000 directly or indirectly (Rs 7,20,000 less deduction of Rs 2,25,000), the tax liability which would have been a meager Rs 12,250 plus 4% education cess is as per the current slab rates Nil.
Rs 12,250 of tax is effectively only 2.47% of total income of Rs 4,95,000, which people in today’s day and age wouldn’t mind paying for the nation’s progress. Sadly, more than half of India’s working population falls under this (2.5 lakh - 5 lakh bracket) and India loses at least a few lakhs of crores of Rupees of tax if not more.
The Rational Economic Trade-Off: If by paying Rs 12,250 of tax, a middle-class person in India earning Rs 60,000 per month can contribute to the country’s welfare schemes which in turn will lead to savings of Rs 20,000–25,000 approx in terms of fuel prices and consequently food and other essential commodity prices, why will he not pay?
Also, in today’s day and age, with so much technology at the government’s disposal as well as the taxpayer’s disposal — with the help of Form 26AS, stringent TDS compliances, and AIS / TIS reflecting on the Income Tax Portal — there is no question of too much hardship to be faced by the lower and middle class taxpayer. The whole perception that India is largely a non-tax-compliant state ironically has very little to do with the fact that people don’t pay taxes truthfully, but more to do with the fact that a large chunk of the population is itself legally exempt from paying any Income Tax due to the current income tax slabs.
9. Thomas Piketty’s Prediction & The Section 10(1) Agricultural Exemption
Economists Thomas Piketty and Nancy Qian did a research back in 2009 that accurately predicted that India’s income tax base is likely to stagnate between 2-3 percent of the working population, driven by a very high income tax exemption threshold. 13 years later, as on today, their research appears to be spot on and there is nothing to suggest that this statistic will change in the coming years.
The Agrarian Exemption Loophole: Section 10(1)
Also, the problem does not stop at the income tax threshold. India is largely an agrarian economy with about 60% or more of its population living in villages. Of this rural population, a vast majority is farmers. However, it is a known fact that while many farmers are small and marginal, there is a section of farmers in different parts of the country who have income above Rs 10 lakh through basic farming, rental incomes from land given to other small farmers etc.
The blanket exemption given to Agricultural income u/s 10(1) in the Income-tax Act leads to zero tax collection from any farmer and transfers the burden of taxes onto the urban taxpayer in terms of exorbitant surcharges.
10. Policy Reflection: Why Keeping Both Regimes Alive Defeats the Purpose
Before we advocate or justify complex policy measures such as demonetization or taxing agriculture income to widen India’s direct tax base, surely the fact that a large majority of Indians are anyways legally exempt from paying income tax is to be pondered over.
To overcome this facet, the Indian Government has already adopted the New Scheme where there is denial of exemption and taxation was charged at a lower rate. But by keeping both the old and new regime live, the benefit of both purposes — taxing at a lower rate in the lower bracket as well as maintaining socio-economic incentives — is lost by the government.
“By keeping the old and new regimes running simultaneously, the policy goal of expanding the direct tax base while preserving socio-economic welfare is undermined. Reforming the exemption threshold and rationalizing Section 87A rebate remains the single most effective path towards genuine financial inclusion and fiscal sustainability.” ■■■