The Transformation of Work
The author is an Australia based journalist. He can be reached at lachlan@collinscommunications.com.au and eboard@icai.in
Stephanie Forsyth started noticing that something was changing in auditing in 2008, when she was at one of the global accounting firms in Sydney.
“I noticed that instead of carrying piles of paper in suitcases, the auditors were starting to look into big screens,” she says.
Her role in the firm straddled both audit and a regional role responsible for strategic initiatives, and it gave her a unique perspective on the implementation of technology, and how that was changing the finance function.
“It was interesting because you could see the new tools that were being delivered,” she says.
Now at leading Australian bank Westpac, Forsyth – a CA - has moved deeper into the world of technology with the change in her role as a senior manager in technology finance, where she delivers innovation to the bank’s business units.
This includes demonstrating the benefits of working with robots, but also in helping her colleagues in their “mindset shift” to embrace the changes which have gone well beyond moving from paper to laptops. Read on…
“I am fascinated with how we can employ technology to facilitate our insights, and what technology such as robotics and automation can mean for the finance role,” she says.
“I think this shifts us to being a much bigger player.”
Forsyth recently ran a trial with some of her colleagues to illustrate the potential of robots. They took some tasks which were normally done manually and gave them to robots, which executed the work overnight – while the humans were at home, relaxing.
“You could see the excitement when they understood the potential,” says Forsyth.
“They could see how they could get a robot to run numbers while they could continue their analysis the next day.”
Forsyth’s examples and experience are symbolic of the wave of change which is sweeping through the accounting profession as new technologies such as artificial intelligence, machine learning, natural language processing and robotic process automation continue to be implemented, increasingly at scale.
Having robots as colleagues and working alongside humans, is transforming the nature of work in the finance industry, and many of the changes have only just begun.
Alongside technologies which change processes, there are also technologies which change responsibility and subject matter areas.
The explosion in concern about cyber security for example, is adding layers of responsibility and governance to the world of the Chief Financial Officer, many of whom are finding that cyber is an emerging part of their remit.
Much of the change is driven by data, in a world where more than 90% of data is estimated to have been generated since 2016, much of it financial.
The sheer volume of data necessitates the use of the latest tools to sift through to find the relevant data points so the work of analysis can begin.
With these changes, and within decades, the role of the CA is likely to be radically different.
The positive vision is one where technology tools take the drudgery, data entry and manual work away, leaving the finance professional to interpret data, story tell, visualise and advise.
For auditors, in one example, the new technologies promise to transform the profession from a reactive and backward looking exercise into a proactive and constant source of forward looking insights, with the auditor as custodian and interpreter of the underlying data foundation.
On the other extreme, it is a world where jobs are sacrificed for the sake of efficiency and cost.
The reality is likely to be somewhere between the two extremes, and will depend very much on effective execution, which includes good change management around processes and culture.
Barriers and the Next-Generation Infrastructure
To put change in perspective, one of the most popular new technologies is Robotic Process Automation (RPA), but according to a major 2018 study by Chartered Accountants ANZ, ACCA and a big accounting firm, 50 percent of businesses are yet to implement Robotic Process Automation (RPA) into their finance function.
Barriers to implementation are varied, from a lack of understanding of what RPA is to cultural issues and challenges around change, but the danger is that those organisations which fail to embrace RPA in finance will be left well behind, creating a new digital divide.
According to Nikki McAllen, a partner at a big accounting firm in Australia who worked on the report, many of those organisations which are taking advantage of the RPA opportunity are doing so in the context of wider digitisation and transformation projects.
“RPA is part of the evolution into the next generation infrastructure,” she says.
“We see people moving their data into cloud platforms where they are much more nimble with it. They are moving data streams from A to B, and it is easier to evolve with this technology rather than build your own or patch what you already have.
“But in my view, the bigger prize from RPA is in machine learning and AI, and already we see organisations leapfrogging RPA and moving in this direction.”
Practice Level Automation: From Manual Coding to Real-Time Insights
At the ‘coalface’ of accounting practice, there are already some RPA case studies revealing rapid change.
When James Carey began his accountancy career, only a decade ago, his first task was to write account codes with a pencil on bank statements.
Although his Sydney-based firm, had internet banking and an array of computer equipment he was still required to code client transactions and then input them manually into the computer system.
“It was quite a traditional business servicing accounting firm back then, and it still hadn’t quite made the leap into the 21st century,” says Carey.
“It made me start thinking about why was I doing all this manual data entry, and that led to us investigating how we could do things better and that led us to Xero accounting software, and the real benefit which started with bank feed automation.”
Today, the firm is using a suite of automated processes which Carey describes as “like a robot doing something that a person used to do.”
It has, he says, been revolutionary not just for his firm, but for the small businesses who are his client base and who are also increasingly integrating and collaborating with the accountancy firm around automation.
“Instead of us being financial historians, as we used to be, we are using this information to look forward and help our clients with business planning and improvement discussions,” says Carey.
“It used to be that we would meet with clients in September or October and review their accounts for the period to the end of July that year, so whatever we were doing was around 18 months out of date.
“I can see where automation is taking us and I think that eventually accounts will be happening in the background and they’ll be updated in real time with most of the reporting automatic, and that is going to free up so much time for accountants.”
Enterprise Scale RPA: Volvo Group Case Study
At another end of the corporate scale, car maker Volvo has been another organisation to implement RPA.
Until very recently it took senior accountants at car company Volvo four days every month validating financial reports coming in from business units and operations around the world.
Now, after the company has implemented RPA across this part of the finance function, robots do the work in two minutes, leaving the accountants to focus on reconciling exceptions and also on the quality of the reports they provide the board and senior management.
This is from the work of one of around 35 robots, 25 of them in the finance function, which Volvo has implemented since establishing a Centre of Excellence for RPA in Bangalore, India, around two years ago.
Kishan Bhat, the Site Head for Accounting Services at the Volvo Group, says that the company had already been automating several processes as part of its shared services and business process outsourcing strategy based on leveraging the IT expertise of Bangalore.
When the new generation of RPA tools came on the market over two years, the company benchmarked its performance against global peers and trends and understood that it should embrace RPA to remain competitive.
“We took a Centre of Excellence approach and collaborated with Volvo IT to create a cross functional team with people from finance to introduce robotic processes,” says Bhat.
“We did some work with a vendor and started experimenting with RPA in some pilot processes.”
Today, the 25 robots have already made Volvo’s finance function up to 25 percent more efficient, with a goal of reaching 70 percent.
Before that happens, says Kishan Bhat, a number of processes need to be standardised before robots and RPA can be introduced.
“Our focus with RPA is on creating value through faster turnaround times,” he says.
“Already we have seen turnaround times on some processes dramatically reduced, all of which means that our experienced accounts are able to focus their times on qualitative tasks rather than the volume of work.”
Overcoming Fear: Cultural Alignment and Value Creation
Other implementations have begun as cost cutting exercises, but have developed a life of their own as they have impacted on culture.
One leading Australian wholesale business, for example, started its project of robotic process automation (RPA), it was in the aftermath of a major cost cutting exercise which severely cut the organisation’s headcount.
According to the program manager “it wasn’t a good start to the project.”
“RPA equaled FTE (employee work load) loss which equaled fear in the business,” she says. “RPA was introduced by our shared services provider and a couple of keen people in our business, but the problem was that they were in the cost cutting business unit.”
From this inauspicious start, the company was able to turn its RPA project around and, within six months, turn it into a significant success, and one which has buy-in throughout the organisation.
A key first step was to restructure the ownership of the project. It was taken away from IT and was directed by the finance function.
“We took over from a group finance perspective and it is now funded by the CFO, with a steering committee identifying a pipeline of opportunities which tackle the low hanging fruit, things like reconciliations and the really easy stuff which is where we can show we are performing well.”
“Every time we put in a bot we tell the CFO because he is the sponsor, and he then tells the CEO and the Board so there’s an up and down stakeholder engagement.”
The mandate, she says, is to simply and automate the low value and repetitive tasks.
“Our mantra is to give the human back the human, and the way we do that is look at any process which is digitised and look at how it can be automated.
“We say if your fingers are doing the work we can probably get your brain to do it faster.
“The result is that it’s an overzealous macro which does the work for you. Overzealous, but very honest.”
Some of the savings have been a “bit embarrassing” in the way they have shown up the clumsiness of previous manual processes, many of which were built on manual data entry and legacy IT systems.
“We have a pipeline of about 20 opportunities and we hope to do 30 projects by financial year 2020,” says the manager.
“That sounds a lot but they are fast and easy to do.
After the rocky start, the bots have been welcomed by employees who understand that RPA is now not about cost savings but is about saving time.
After going through the pain of cost cutting the company is now left with “really good people we really want to retain” but it was important that they were not left with “lots of mundane work because they weren’t taken out in the cost cutting.”
“We won’t retain them by keeping their jobs boring,” the program manager says.
“We had created a bit of a treadmills culture where there was a level of mediocrity creeping into the business, and this was cited in exit summaries with people who were leaving the business.
“So in addition to making time for people we try and make it fun. We have races – human against bot – and show the business the benefits and for a lot of people this is jaw dropping.”
Six months in and with the project now on the right track, she offers some advice to other organisations which are pondering a journey into RPA.
“RPA just can’t be a band aid, you can’t just stick it over the top,” she says.
“It’s all about process improvements, and you streamline along the way.
“Some of the processes didn’t actually need to be automated, they just needed to be fixed and streamlined, but this RPA process helped identify that.”