“Banning of the Unregulated Deposits Schemes Ordinance, 2019 (‘UDS’) is a bold ordinance introduced to comprehensively ban the illicit deposit-taking schemes. In this article, the author has elaborately taken up the issue through various demarcated sections, such as Background, Important Sections, Understanding the Ordinance and FAQs. The author is of the view that due to leaving out the enumeration of Unregulated Scheme for residual interpretation or extrapolation by default, there is open-ended scope for subjective or arbitrary decisions by the authorities. The author says that this law is the need of the hour especially for the regions where investment quantum is enormous in such Ponzi schemes, since this may help create a fear psychosis against the illegal transactions. Read on to get to the author’s other concerns in this regard…”

Author: CA. Viren Doshi
Credentials: Member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
Contact: doshiviren@live.com and eboard@icai.in
Published In: The Chartered Accountant, August 2019, Vol. 68, No. 2, pp. 89–95 (253–259)

I. Background

1. Need of UDS

On the social media platforms, UDS (Unregulated Deposits Schemes Ordinance, 2019) is being viewed as a law to restrict raising of unsecured loans by individuals and businesses. This is incorrect interpretation. The real reason of bringing up this law is rising instances of people being defrauded by illicit deposit taking schemes in the various parts of the country. Did it require enactment of such bold legislation? Well, let us have a look at some data¹ of the last 4 years:

Regulator Cases related to illicit deposits
Central Bureau of Investigation 146
Directorate of Enforcement 56
Ministry of Corporate Affairs and Serious Fraud Investigation Office 32 (involving 223 companies)
Securities and Exchange Board of India 64
Cases referred to various investigation agencies by the State Coordination Committees 978
Total cases investigated 1276

¹ As per the details provided by Secretary, Department of Financial Services to the members of the Standing Committee on 26th September 2018

This is the kind of the menace which unregulated deposit taking companies or entities pose. We are aware of the Saradha Chit Fund Scam which has wiped out savings of so many small and marginal investors.

2. Present Regulatory Structure

The Indian non-banking financial sector is large, diverse and complex. Non-banking entities are allowed to raise deposits from the public under the provisions of various statutes enacted by the Central Government and the State Governments. For instance -

Type of Companies Regulator
NBFCs RBI
Housing Finance Companies National Housing Bank
Collective Investment Schemes SEBI
Companies accepting deposits other than NBFC Ministry of Corporate Affairs
Chit Funds and Money Circulation Schemes State Governments

Despite such diverse regulatory framework, schemes and arrangements leading to unauthorised collection of money and deposits fraudulently are still operating in the society. This is done by inducing public to invest in uncertain schemes promising high returns or other benefits. Hence, it is apparent that the regulatory framework for deposit taking activity at present is not adequate, effective and seamless.

3. Why Ordinance route?

The Twenty-First Report of the Parliamentary Related Standing Committee on Finance (Sixteenth Lok Sabha) titled as Efficacy of Regulation of Collective Investment Schemes, Chit Funds, etc. highlighted the regulatory gap. The said Committee in its Report has recommended the above-referred requirement of appropriate legislative provisions, coupled with effective administrative and enforcement measures in order to protect the hard-earned savings and investments made by millions of people. In line with these recommendations, our Hon’ble Finance Minister in his Budget Speech 2017 mentioned that bill to curtail the menace of illicit deposits will be introduced. He also acknowledged the urgent need to protect the poor and gullible investors from set of dubious schemes, operated by unscrupulous entities who exploit the regulatory gaps. Post this; the UDS Bill was introduced in Lok Sabha on 18th July 2018. It was referred to the Standing Committee of Finance on 10th August 2018 and was finally passed in Lok Sabha on 13th February 2019. It could not be passed in the Rajya Sabha as the house was not in session; it has been introduced as an Ordinance.

II. Important Sections

Important sections which are elementary to the law have been analyzed:

1. Section 2(4) – Definition of Deposit

Deposit is defined in such a manner that deposit takers are restricted from camouflaging public deposits as receipts, and at the same time not to curb or hinder acceptance of money by an establishment in the ordinary course of its business. It means money received and not commodity. Thereby meaning that deposits of Gold or Silver are not governed by this ordinance. However, deposit taker with a promise to return the money either in cash or kind or in the form of a specified service is covered.

From the definition of deposit some of the transactions with relatives and others are excluded.

Relatives is defined to mean any one who is related to another if they are members of an HUF, or is husband, wife, father, mother, son, son’s wife, daughter, daughter’s husband, brother or sister of the individual.

2. Section 2(6) - Definition of Deposit Taker

Deposit Taker means all possible entities (including individuals) receiving or soliciting deposits, except specific entities such as those incorporated by legislation and banking companies.

3. Section 2(14) - Definition of Regulated Deposit Scheme read with First Schedule

Regulated Deposit Schemes (‘RDS’) are the ones specified in the First Schedule to the Ordinance. The First Schedule has specified the following schemes as Regulated Deposit Schemes:

Regulator Schemes
Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) i. Collective Investment Scheme;
ii. Alternative Investment Funds;
iii. Mutual Funds;
iv. Schemes managed under SEBI (Portfolio Managers) Regulations, 1993;
v. Schemes managed under SEBI (Share Based Employee Benefits) Regulations, 1993 or as permitted under the Companies Act, 2013;
vi. Any other scheme or arrangement registered under the SEBI Act or under its regulations.
Reserve Bank of India (RBI) i. Deposits accepted by NBFCs;
ii. Scheme or arrangement under which funds accepted by individuals, business correspondents or facilitators subject to RBI Circulars and Guidelines;
iii. Funds received by authorized system provider operating under Payment and Settlement Systems Act, 2007;
iv. Any other scheme or arrangement regulated by RBI.
Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority (IRDA) Contract of Insurance
State Governments i. Any scheme or an arrangement made or offered by Co-operative Society registered under the Co-operative Societies Act, 1912 or a society registered or deemed to be so under any other law at the time in force;
ii. Any chit business with the previous sanction of the State Government in accordance with the Chit Funds Act, 1982;
iii. Any scheme or an arrangement related to money lending regulated by State Government or Union Territory;
iv. Any prize chit or money circulation scheme covered under section 11 of the Prize Chits and Money Circulation Schemes (Banning) Act, 1978.
National Housing Bank (NHB) Any scheme or an arrangement for acceptance of deposits under the NHB Act, 1987.
Pension Fund Regulatory and Development Authority (PFRDA) Any scheme or an arrangement under the PFRDA Act, 2013.
Employees’ Provident Fund Organization (EPFO) Any scheme, Pension Scheme or Insurance Scheme framed under the Employees’ Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952.
Central Registrar, Multi-State Co-operative Societies Any scheme or an arrangement for acceptance of deposits from voting members by a Multi-State Co-operative Society registered under the Multi-State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002.
Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) i. Deposits accepted or permitted under the provisions of Chapter V of the Companies Act, 2013;
ii. Deposits accepted by a company declared as a Nidhi or a Mutual Benefit Society under section 406 of the Companies Act, 2013.

4. Section 2(17) - Definition of Unregulated Deposit Scheme

This definition is the backbone of the Ordinance. Accordingly, let us first read the entire definition, then break it down and analyse it –

(17) “Unregulated Deposit Scheme” means a Scheme or an arrangement under which deposits are accepted or solicited by any deposit taker by way of business and which is not a Regulated Deposit Scheme.

i. UDS means a Scheme or an Arrangement: To qualify as UDS, it should first be a Scheme or an Arrangement. Now what is a Scheme or an Arrangement? Since these are not defined in the Ordinance, let us have a look at its definition in the Oxford Dictionary.

Scheme : Large-scale systematic plan or arrangement for attaining some particular object or putting a particular idea into effect.
Arrangement : A plan or preparation for a future event.
So can a one-off transaction be considered as UDS? No.

ii. Under which deposits are accepted or solicited by any deposit taker by way of business: Deposit taker should accept the deposit by way of business. This is a critical phase which mandates acceptance of deposits by way of business. Definitions of ‘by way of’ and ‘business’ as per Oxford Dictionary are reproduced below –
By Way Of : So as to pass through or across; Constituting; By means of
Business : A person’s regular occupation, profession, or trade; Commercial Activity

Therefore, it should be the business of deposit taker of accepting deposits. This means that it should be the regular occupation of deposit taker of accepting-repaying deposits and providing something in return for the same (like an unregistered financial or banking entity). Accepting money for conducting say trading business is not considered as a business of accepting deposits and is hence not considered as UDS. Accepting loans by individuals, firms, etc. for conducting their normal business activities (except financial or banking) are not considered as Unregulated Deposits.

iii. And which is not a RDS: If the scheme is covered under the RDS, it will not be considered as UDS.

5. Section 3 imposes a blanket ban on UDS. It also bans deposit taker to promote, operate or solicit directly or indirectly any participation or enrolment in unregulated deposit scheme.

6. Section 4 prohibits committing fraudulent defaults in repayment of deposit or rendering specified services promised while accepting deposits.

7. Section 5 prohibits any person other than deposit taker to induce someone to participate in an UDS. Deposit taker is already prohibited for soliciting under section 3.

8. Section 7(3) authorises Competent Authority to provisionally attach the deposits obtained by deposit taker vide UDS. It also allows attaching property, if any acquired out of the deposits accepted.

9. Section 9 enables the Central Government to designate authority for creating, maintaining and operating an online database for information on deposit takers operating across the country. The present regulators and officers empowered under this law may also be required to share information on deposit takers with the database maintaining authority.

10. Section 10 of the ordinance provides that every deposit taker who commences or carries on its business as such on or after 21st February, 2019 shall intimate the authority appointed by the Central government under section 9(1) of the ordinance about its business in the prescribed form.

11. Section 16 authorises the Court to attach the properties in case the Court is of the view that the deposit taker has transferred the property with a fraudulent intention. Laws of natural justice will be followed while attaching the properties transferred to such malafide transferees.

III. Understanding the Ordinance

1. Applicability: This is a prospective law made applicable from 21st February 2019. It would apply to the whole of India except the State of Jammu and Kashmir. For all the deposits before 21st February 2019, the regulatory framework at that point of time would continue to apply.

2. Targeting Unregulated Deposit Schemes: UDS contains a substantive banning clause which bans Deposit Takers from promoting, operating, issuing advertisements or accepting deposits in any Deposit Taking Scheme which is not regulated. The principle is crystal clear that this Ordinance bans unregulated deposit taking activities altogether, by making them an offence ex-ante, rather than the existing legislative-cum-regulatory framework which only comes into effect ex-post with considerable time lags.

People of the western regions of the country may not understand and appreciate the importance of this law. But when we see the investment patterns of the households of the southern region of the country and even some eastern parts, the amount of investment in such deposit schemes like chit funds are huge. And these marginal and gullible investors are the real victims of the illicit deposit schemes.

3. Prescribed Offences: The Ordinance broadly prescribes three different types of offences and prescribes severe punishment and heavy pecuniary fines for the same. The offences are –
i. Running of Unregulated Deposit Schemes;
ii. Wrongful inducement in relation to Unregulated Deposit Schemes; and
iii. Fraudulent default in Regulated Deposit Schemes.

4. Administrative Segment: The Central Government will establish an online database for maintaining records of deposit takers. All the deposit takers pan-India have to provide the information on the database portal regularly. Time and form of reporting has not been prescribed yet. This online portal once made accessible to all, people can verify the genuineness of the deposit takers and substantially reduce the flow of money to illicit deposit schemes. Further, any violation of provisions related to reporting on online database by deposit takers would invite penalty of up to INR 10L.

Deposit takers covered under Regulated Deposit Schemes are allowed to accept deposits. However, any fraudulent default in repayment or servicing of deposits would invite fine of higher of INR 5L; INR 25 cr.; or thrice the amount of profits made on such default. This will be in addition to imprisonment which may extend to 7 years.

Operating an Unregulated Deposit Scheme has been declared as an offence ex-ante. In case where unregulated deposits vide any schemes are still raised, the law provides for attachment of assets and subsequent realization of assets for repayment to depositors. Clear-cut time lines have been provided for attachment of property and restitution to depositors. Fines and punishment prescribed for offences related to unregulated schemes are as follows:

Type of Offence Fine (in INR) Imprisonment (in years)
Soliciting for UDS 2L to 10L 1 to 5
Accepting deposits under UDS 3L to 10L 2 to 7
Accepting deposits under UDS and fraudulently defaulting in repayment or servicing 5L to Twice the aggregate funds collected 3 to 10
Failure to furnish information u/s 10 0L to 5L -

5. Major Beneficiaries
i. Poor and gullible people who are being duped by illicit deposit schemes launched by rapacious operators. This law will protect them by altogether banning unregulated deposit taking schemes.
ii. Due to UDS Ordinance, public faith in deposit raising entities which are regulated by and accountable directly to the Government or to Regulators will increase.

6. Myths: A lot of misinformation has been spread using the social media platforms related to this Ordinance which has resulted in panic among people. It is being circulated that one cannot obtain personal loans; loans for business can be obtained only from relatives, etc. These claims are result of incomplete reading coupled with pre-conceived notions. The author has tried to clarify the same in the next section of FAQs.

IV. FAQs: Myth Breakers

Q1. Mr. X has a function in his house. He borrows INR 1L from his friend Mr. Y. Will this be considered as illegal under this law?

A. Mr. X being an individual is covered under the definition of deposit taker. Accepting loan from friend is squarely covered in the definition of deposit. However, accepting deposits is not the business activity of Mr. X and hence, not considered as Unregulated Deposit Scheme. It is not illegal under this law.

Q2. Mr. A had individually started an unregistered chit fund on 1st January 2019. He gathered 1000 participants to contribute INR 5k every month. He had received instalments on 5th January 2019 and 5th February 2019. Will the instalments already collected be considered as illegal under this law? Can he collect the instalment due on 5th March 2019?

A. It is crystal clear that this is a prospective law applicable from 21st February 2019. Hence, deposits accepted prior to this law will be governed by the respective legislations in force at that point of time.

Mr. A being an individual falls under the definition of deposit taker. Accepting money from non-relatives falls under the definition of deposit. Also, this is an entire arrangement of chit fund which is not registered. Therefore, it is UDS and Mr. A’s scheme is illegal from 21st February 2019. He cannot collect the instalment due on 5th March 2019, if he does, he would invite severe punishment coupled with heavy pecuniary fines. Further, he will have to report this scheme to the Competent Authority from the date of coming into existence of this Ordinance.

Q3. Mr. X, a software engineer wishes to invent business software based on block chain technology. Mr. Y, his friend agrees to give him a loan of INR 15L. Now, Mr. Y is of the view that Mr. X cannot accept the loan according the provisions of UDS Ordinance? Is the view of Mr. Y correct?

A. Obtaining loans for the purpose of business bearing a genuine connection therewith is exempted from being considered as deposits. Further, accepting deposits is not the business activity of Mr. X and hence, not considered as Unregulated Deposit Scheme. The view of Mr. Y is incorrect.

Q4. ABC Pvt. Ltd. advanced INR 5L for supply of polymers to XYZ Pvt. Ltd. The time period for supply of goods was one month. It has been 2 months since the amount was advanced, but XYZ has neither supplied the goods nor it has refunded the amount due. What are the implications under UDS?

A. Advancing money for supply of goods in the normal course of business is not considered as deposits. However, when such advance becomes refundable, it will be considered as deposits if not repaid within 15 days of it becoming refundable. INR 5L has qualified as deposits in the hands of XYZ Pvt. Ltd. but since it is not its business activity of accepting deposits, this transaction will not be considered as Unregulated Deposit Scheme.

Q5. M/s Hari Bros., a partnership firm is DCA-cum-Super Stockist of HUL. HUL delivers the goods to the customers of Hari Bros. as per their instructions. The customers of Hari Bros. receive bill from HUL and Hari Bros. receive commission from HUL. HUL provides credit period of one week. Not all the customers of Hari Bros. are able to pay up in the credit period provided. Hari Bros. pays on their customers’ behalf and charges them interest. Is the credit provided by Hari Bros. prohibited under UDS?

A. The amount paid by Hari Bros. to HUL on behalf of its customers is advance in the normal course of business. Hence, it is exempted from being considered as deposits and accordingly, not banned under UDS Ordinance.

Q6. Mr. A wants to individually start a chit fund (without getting it registered). He has decided to get 1000 participants in his scheme. The monthly contribution decided is 5 grams of silver per participant. He will accordingly fix the monthly prize too. Is this Scheme prohibited under UDS?

A. Mr. A being an individual is covered under the definition of deposit taker. Starting a chit fund is a Scheme. However, the definition of deposit covers only receipt of money and not any commodity. Accordingly, since the receipt of silver is not covered under the definition of deposit, this scheme will not be prohibited under UDS.

This is space where the Government should verify as to whether it wanted to allow such Schemes or it is lacunae in the law which needs to be amended.

V. Conclusion

An exhaustive list of Regulated Deposit Scheme is provided. Therefore, the enumeration of Unregulated Scheme is left for residual interpretation or extrapolation by default. It, thus, leaves wide, unfettered and rather open-ended scope for subjective or arbitrary decisions by the authorities.

Although there would be an online database but execution on ground will be in the hand of the officers. There are heavy pecuniary fines prescribed with punishment. Manual handling supported with harsh legal provisions certainly leads to increasing corruption on ground. A law drafted for protecting the money of small, marginal and gullible investors may to a certain extent end up filling the pockets of the so called law enforcers.

With these few challenges we may face practically, this law is the need of the hour especially in the regions where the investment quantum is enormous in such Ponzi schemes. Government may come up with further clarifications on the law because of the misinformation spread across social media. One should wait for it.

It is the style of this government to bring in laws, which impose blanket bans with huge penalties. One such example is the Black Money Law. This may help create a fear in the minds of the people and hence discourage the illegal transactions. However, at the end of the day, it should not end up hampering the lives of small people, unintentionally.

“If you light a lamp for someone else it will also brighten your path.” — Buddha